Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Nothing to write home about, November 20, 2006
Don't let the presence of Doug Gillard fool you. There are no irresistible riffs or monster power-chord moments here. This is another album in Buckner's trademark style, an inscrutable blend of folk and country-rock with language-poet lyrics (`elliptical' is the standard-issue description.) It's as good as his last, but this isn't to say it's a really satisfying album.
The problem lies in its familiarity. With Devotion and Doubt, Buckner discovered his voice, and though he's varied his arrangements and accompaniment since then, melodically and lyrically he's continued the same course. When style becomes as habitual as this, it's time to move on or risk getting stuck in a rut.
What this artist could use is a producer who really challenges him and forces him to re-think his approach: make him change the tempo, transpose songs into different keys, compose on new instruments, re-write his lyrics, in general shake things up--- you get the idea. The last time Buckner sounded truly different from his usual sound, he was writing songs for another poet's words. I think he thrives on that outside influence, and at this stage in his career, he probably needs it. Otherwise he might as well join Jay Farrar in the ranks of artists in a state of premature rigor mortis.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
richard buckner changed my life..., May 31, 2007
i must have been living under a rock or something because i never heard this guy before i saw him play live with my friends the six parts seven at the beachland taverne. that show totally blew me away and that night my life changed forever. it's hard to explain that, but everyone who was there that day should understand what i mean, i'm sure everyone felt it...with that said, this record paints a small corner of a picture of what happened that night in cleveland. it's not the same backing band but it is CLOSE to what i heard that night, and to me, that is worth it. every once in a while i think i've heard it all, and then someone like richard buckner finds his way into my brain and then all i can do is sit back and shake my head, because it just opens up so many more things...get this and i'm sure you will agree. definately one of the most gifted humans of all time. why aren't musicians like this getting more recognition?
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
in-effin-credible, January 17, 2007
Transistor International, below, may have a point, in the case of experienced Buckner fans; but i am new to him, and as an introduction, Meadow has completely blown me over. Out of ten tracks, at least five are songs i cannot believe i lived without just a week ago. I love the mood of the entire album, and it has not left my 3-disc player since i got it. I ordered Devotion and Doubt a few days after getting Meadow; and find it similar, but not quite as powerfully magnetic as Meadow. So while maybe any introduction to Richard Buckner might impress more than exposure to further material (that thrill of discovery of fresh talent), i am willing to say that Meadow could easily be the highlight of an astounding songwriting/performing career.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|