2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
flawed but not unworthy., June 24, 2009
This review is from: Means to an End: Music of Joy Division (Audio CD)
Going up against the mythology and spectre of Joy Division is no small feat, and while the results are not necessarily essential to your CD collection there are some noteworthy moments on this disc and some downright excellent versions of JD tracks, like Low's lovely and stately take on "Transmission" which transforms Ian Curtis's dour post-punk delivery into a floating, haunting lullabye duet.
4AD artist Kendra Smith takes "Heart And Soul" to a dark and moody dancefloor, perhaps one where Laurie Anderson might go on Halloween? Virtually unknown band Further opens up the arrangement of "Insight" just a bit, but in a successful way that almost makes me prefer it to the insular track on the peerless Unknown Pleasures. Moby's interpretation of "New Dawn Fades" grasps the claustrophobia of the song while maybe veering a bit close to arena rock, while Tortoise's understated instrumental "As You Said" drifts by, not nearly as insistent or brash as the hard-wired early electronica of the original. Versus manages to capture and highlight the catharsis implied in the original of "Twenty Four Hours" while throwing in a girl-boy harmony to boot. Definitive slow-core band Codeine gives us a rather perfect, icy reading of "Atmosphere" which somehow transports the song from gray, industrial Manchester to the gray, industrial American Midwest.
A few of these tracks (Moby and Low, notably) have been released elsewhere, making this one for completists only, however for all of the flaws and ham-fisted covers of "Love Will Tear Us Apart" found on A Means To An End, its earnestness is not in dispute, and a band more challenging (and worthy!) to pay tribute to would be hard to find.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This tribute won't tear you apart, February 3, 2003
This review is from: Means to an End: Music of Joy Division (Audio CD)
The cover of "Transmission" by Low is worth the entire CD. Hardcore Joy Division fans might not appreciate the styles on the CD, but heck doesn't that happen with ALL tribute CDs? You should seek out tributes NOT based on who the bands pay homage to, but what bands happen to be on the CD. Fans of the bands Versus, Girls Against Boys, Moby and Face to Face won't be disappointed! I know I wasn't. I find myself listening to this CD all the time, plus it inspired me to learn Low's version of "Transmission" on acoustic guitar. *gasp*
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
bad reviews skew rating against something great, October 3, 2008
This review is from: Means to an End: Music of Joy Division (Audio CD)
i love joy division (have 8 cds) and i love means to an end. i think any real fan will enjoy hearing these versions. the first reviewer is right, low's version of transmission alone makes this worth having.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No