Most Helpful Customer Reviews
23 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very decent reference on MediaWiki, May 21, 2007
This review is from: MediaWiki Administrators' Tutorial Guide: Install, manage, and customize your MediaWiki installation (Paperback)
Although a comparison cannot be made, because of the lack of competition (discarding the online help at MediaWiki.org) the MediaWiki Administrators' Tutorial Guide is a good and must have reference for anyone working with MediaWiki as administrator but also as user, offering almost anything one would want to know to start off with, to maintain and to customise and even hack a wiki installation. For those wanting to go a bit further with writing real PHP code for creating extensions, custom wiki markup and special pages, the book offers some nice code examples to work with and to modify to one's needs.
The book could have benefited from somewhat richer content, such as more references to additional sources on the Internet and especially something like break-out boxes presenting experiences from admins of major wiki real life implementations. Next to that it appears that some more time should have been spend on a better index, correcting language, typos and structuring in general.
My book rating: 8
To summarise: the pros and cons
Pros:
+ Almost everything you will need for a basic MediaWiki installation, its maintenance and some customisation is available in this book. It is a complete reference for admins but certainly also for users, that would like some basic understanding of MediaWiki.
+ Very nice and easy to grasp examples of skin customisation and creation (I am no PHP expert!).
+ Good example on creating an article rating system extension and accompanying special page. With this knowledge and some additional PHP you will be able to try out a couple of your extension idea's quite easily I guess.
+ There is a nice bonus chapter (11) presenting 7 extensions and some support on how to install them.
+ A book is so much easier than an online source! Of course this is not a pro for this book per se, but for others as well.
Cons:
+ Missing 1: some practical case studies of real life MediaWiki implementations and preferably interviews with the admins of the practise of maintaining a wiki
+ Missing 2: More attention to anti-vandalism tools out there, dedicated to preventing rather than cleaning-up.
+ Missing 3: A good index: the index at the end of the book is way too brief to be of real value for someone trying to find something back in the book.
+ Missing 4: Too little in-text references and no references section in the book, for further reading or information, like most important forums for those looking for help (like the MediaWiki Mailing List Archive and MWusers.com).
+ Sometimes the English used suggests a lack of some decent editorial oversight (or shall I call it charming?)
+ Chapter 1, describing wiki's in relation to weblogs, forums and CMS systems and the position in Web 2.0 is not really convincing. Furthermore, although alternative wiki systems are briefly mentioned, no real and "honest" comparison is made.
+ Images and tables are not numbered, which is not good for readability.
+ The typographical distinction between paragraph and sub-paragraph could have been better
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
21 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Subject OK, writing awful, August 18, 2007
This review is from: MediaWiki Administrators' Tutorial Guide: Install, manage, and customize your MediaWiki installation (Paperback)
I think this book sells purely because there is little in the way of alternatives. The documentation in the MediaWiki wiki itself is patchy, jumbled, and confusing to navigate. I wanted a more 'polished' reference book, and this is the only book on Amazon devoted solely to MediaWiki.
Content-wise it is _OK_. There is very little in here that isn't already available on-line, but at least it is presented in a more logical manner. The first half of the book is really aimed at contributors to MediaWiki, such as creating and editing a page, uploading and inserting images, and creating tables. True, Administrators will also need to know this, but it's probably safe to assume that anyone purchasing an "Administrator's Guide" already knows this. Certainly, it didn't teach me anything new. The second half gets more useful, covering administration of access rights, creation of skins, managing namespaces, and so on. That said, it does include huge swathes of code, which take up a fair bit of room - if you don't want to add the 'page rating' the author provides, then it's just a waste of space.
The book is also missing some key information. There's a section on thumbnailing images, but the book neglects to mention that the functionality to deliver this isn't included in MediaWiki and has to be installed separately. (At least in the version I installed, but as there's no information provided on the different versions of MediaWiki there's no way of knowing whether this is why...) It's also vague on some tasks, such as "Figure out how to run PHP scripts from the command line."
My biggest problem with the book is the quality of the writing. This is absolutely appalling. Maybe I'm a bit more sensitive to these things, being a Technical Writer by profession, but the amount of spelling errors and grammatical mistakes is absolutely shocking. I found almost 100 errors just whilst I was casually reading it - I'm sure there would be many more if I looked more closely. Most of these would have been detected by using a spellchecker, and many of the rest would have probably been picked up by Word's grammar checker. For the most part this is just annoying and distracting, but some, such as repeatedly misspelling the HTML HREF tag as HERF, are just unforgivable. It hardly puts ones faith in the author - if they can't get this right, what's the chance of the sample code being correct and actually working? But what is really shocking is that the book lists five editors, two reviewers and a proofreeader in the "Credits". None of these people deserve any credit whatsoever, as the quality of this book is below what I would expect from a 15-year old.
In fact, I suspect that the book was actually written by a 15 year-old. The tone used, the examples (the wiki developed throughout the book is a wiki for ghost stories...), the logic of exposition, is all very 'youthful'. It's as though some teenager with an Internet connection and a bit of time on their hands had built themselves a wiki, and then someone had remarked to his parents "Wow, little Timmy knows so much about wikis I bet he could write a book on it!".
Given the lack of competition you may want to go out and buy this book anyway. Just don't expect a detailed technical reference, and be prepared to overlook the frequent grammar and spelling errors...
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Printed Resource for Managing MediaWiki, May 21, 2007
This review is from: MediaWiki Administrators' Tutorial Guide: Install, manage, and customize your MediaWiki installation (Paperback)
I downloaded the mediawiki code and configured a simple wiki, and then said "Now what?" Fortunately, I ordered this book, and happened to have a flight shortly after receiving it, so I had a few relatively uninterrupted hours to read it. I felt like I moved from just scratching the surface of this powerful tool to really being able to tweak it and stretch it to do some really interesting things.
I was disappointed in a few typos early in the book related to linking, the errors made things much more confusing than they needed to be. But other than that, I found the flow of the book to be very good, moving from installation to basic editing to templating to adding custom tags (which I've now done for my install).
I've pretty much read the book cover to cover, and left it with my client last time I saw him. He, too, read it on his flight home, and told me he is quite jazzed about doing some new things with the system that he never knew were even options.
If you want to manage a wiki, reading this book is much, much easier than using the online documentation. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|