21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Head's up! You may fall into a trap, July 31, 2000
This review is from: The Medicine Way: A Shamanic Path to Self Mastery (The "Earth Quest" Series) (Paperback)
I have reviewed other books by Kenneth Meadows. I really do like them, but I have to warn readers to be careful. This book suffers from the "Shamanism equals Native American" or the "All Shamans are Native Americans" syndrome. Meadows and many Europeans are being trained in Lakota-esque tradtions and learning a great deal from them. WONDERFUL! However, the outcome is that many of these Europeans become authors and begin writing authoritative books on the subject. I ask the reader to be aware of this ... and then, thus armed, to make much of the good exercises and comfortable language of the book.
For a better idea of Shamanism and its world wide impact, take a look at Michael Harner's 'Way of the Shaman' or Sarangrel's 'Riding Windhorses.' The best books I have read about the Lakota people have been by Ed (Eagle Man) McGaa.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Plastic Shamanism, July 9, 2002
I do not recommend any of Kenneth Meadow's books. He is what many American Indians would call a "plastic shaman," in other words a fake. He fails to mention that the beliefs he has taken are mainly Lakota beliefs, in other words he practically generalizes all American Indian tribes as if they have all the same beliefs. Which is definitely not the case. One of his sources is Harley Swiftdeer. Swiftdeer was officially kicked out of the Cherokee nation because of making sacred beliefs become public.
I would also recommend to STAY AWAY from authors such as Sun Bear, Mary Summer Rain, Ed McGaa, and Dhyani Ywahoo. And there are many more authors to stay away from when it comes to Amerindian spirituality. If you really care about spiritual theft and authenticity do not buy these authors' books and throw them away if you have them. I recommend doing an online research into "plastic shamans." You'll come up with lists of people of who to stay away from and what to watch out for (for example, a Choctaw "medicine man" does not teach Cherokee, Lakota, or Navajo ways and vice versa).
If you are interested in legitimate Amerindian beliefs I suggest these authors and books:
For Southern (Montana) Piegan (Piikani) Blackfoot beliefs I'd highly recommend the book 'Ni Kso Ko Wa: Blackfoot Spirituality, Traditions, Values and Beliefs' by Harold E. Gray Long Standing Bear. He is a known and respected Blackfoot activist and scholar.
For Blood (Kainai) Blackfoot beliefs, I recommend the book 'The Sacred Tree' by Judie Bopp, Michael Bopp, Phil Lane, and Lee Brown. It was developed by the Four Worlds Development Project, an inter-tribal group based in Alberta, Canada. It was guided by the elders of the tribe. It was initially created to help American Indians return to the traditional ways and to stay away from alcohol and drugs, but they eventually decided to release the book to the public at large.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Who are you? The answer is within......., September 8, 1999
By A Customer
This review is from: The Medicine Way: A Shamanic Path to Self Mastery (The "Earth Quest" Series) (Paperback)
Anyone interested in being one with the universe, while maintaining their uniqueness, will find this book helpful and inspiring. If the tasks and quests are attempted, I believe you will come away from them with a renewed respect for all inhabitants of the Earth, animate and inanimate, and for the infinite possibilities beyond.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No