Most Helpful Customer Reviews
30 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One film that demands sensibility and inteligence., May 28, 2006
This review is from: Meetings with Remarkable Men (DVD)
The movie "Meetings With Remarkable Men", is, in my opinion, one
masterpiece. Too many people may disagree, because the movie do
not show the "greatness" of Hollywood superproductions, the dvd
is one remaster form an old material (in fact it has only one
chapter, poor menus, and no further material). The flow of the
movie, some may say, it's too tedious, but, as i say in the
beginning, it's a movie to the sensible and inteligent people.
The movie have too many aspects not immediately perceivable,
that needs more than one single view.
The movie also catches the atmosphere of the singular world of
the people from central asia and middle east.
Besides some defects of the movie in terms of pure technical
sense, the message and concepts of the movie talks to the heart
of the whatcher.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finally available, November 26, 2006
This review is from: Meetings with Remarkable Men (DVD)
After many years of waiting-there it is ,finally made it to DVD!
One of the best films ever.
The music is worth an award.Then the locations are something you don't get to see often.And some of the actors are just incredible in their authenticity.
It might not be everybodys cup of tea and certainly was never a very commercial movie but the depth and insight into the subject is fantastic.It sort of creates that particular longing to free the knowledge that resides in all of us about who we are and what it is that really matters and that will lead us home.
The book ist still better as there is more in it, but nevertheless this movie is it's own version and interpretation that can help us to get in touch with this subject in an additional and beautiful way.
Along with "Circle of Iron"(David carradine)and the movies of Alejandro Jodorowsky this is one of the best of this genre and surely one you will not forget so easily again.
Also read "The teachers of Gurdjieff"by Rafael LeFort (Pseudonym).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
gurdjieff not a charlatan, January 19, 2008
This review is from: Meetings with Remarkable Men (DVD)
Gurdjieff was not a con man or a charlatan. He predicted the clash between the West and East. He regarded the energy of American culture as a possible agent of preventing the destructive potentiality of this clash. But he also observed America's obsession with "dollars, sex and food" as an obstacle.
His system clearly has within it, among other predictive notions, the periodic table, the existence of other planetary bodies within the solar system, and has a breadth of knowledge of science, religion, art, philosophy, history, psychology not found in any western streams of thought or understanding.
In fact his intention was to synthesize eastern awareness with western practical notions in order to prevent the destruction the inevitable clash might bring about.
He used music and dance in a practical way for his students. This film has some very rare videos of the kind of dance he taught. It is hypnotic and unlike anything youve ever seen.
In the 1920s his students, under his direction, performed similar dances(and other demonstrations)at Carnegie Hall in New York. A reading of the newspapers of the day indicate these were a sensation at the time.
The movie used Jean Salzmann as an advisor, the former dancer who was one of his chief followers and whom he intended to be the principal teacher of his system in France after he died.
However, he deliberately fostered the notion that he was a charlatan and fraud, as the first obstacle to be removed, he knew, was one's own egoism and failure to understand that we are ignorant, have no unified identity and lack real will.
Those unable to see through his ruse were those not able to receive his teaching anyway, and were of no use to his greater purpose.
Hence his intention was never to make it easy to understand his ideas or methods.
This obstacle still remains, as he intended it to, and there are many false teachers using his name for their own purposes - which he also knew was inevitable.
This movie is based on the book he wrote, which deceptively appears to be a straightforward account of some episodes in his life.
The movie sets out only to cinematically present some of them and to ask the essential and universal questions he addressed in his teachings. In the book much is buried - much more so than in the movie - and should be construed as a series of parables.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|