2.0 out of 5 stars
Not Advantageous, July 21, 2011
Read the book cover to cover, and what advice is good to help my memory? I don't remember!
What I do remember is Crook loves his abbreviations. For example on page 32, he defines MCI as 'Mild Cognitive Impairment', a condition of significant adult memory loss but not dementia. Page 32 is where MCI is defined, and it is used extensively. Twenty pages later, I was wondering why the phone company was in my memory book. If your target audience is not remembering short term things like abbreviations well, why use so many? AAMI, CBT, CL, MCI, MCVI, MTBI, PS, and others decorate the pages -- reading the memory book is itself an exercise in memory.
Early book talks techniques, and I was hoping for a detailed step-by-step on how to build a 'memory palace'. Crook mentions the history of the technique, that it does work, and tells an anecdote of a speaker who pictured place settings at a feast as representing unique topics and good lines in a long speech... but nothing on how to create your own memory palace. Much of the book is like that, mentioning good techniques without explanation of how to use them. Best technique was 'selective forgetting' the art of taking a bad memory you are dwelling on unhealthily and replacing it with a good memory. I tried it and couldn't get it working.
Late book talks about science and studies, including Alzheimer's Research. Certain memory drugs are touted as useful, but they are expensive and the 'normal' supplements on the market do not contain enough of the useful substance(s) to work. Interesting, but not helpful.
My edition of this book is the one with the blue cover from 2006; it is conceivable an editor was found for later editions, in which case maybe it is less impenetrable. It does mention the class of drugs that treat AD (Alzheimer's Disease) with detail. It also contains a selective glossary, an index, graphs, and memory exercises (not for improvement, for judging how bad your memory is).
I had hoped this book would improve my memory, but instead it wasted my time. Tantalizing glimpses of what exists without how to apply them disappointed me, and the overuse of abbreviation was extremely annoying.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No