From Publishers Weekly
Keeble's debut novel starts off as an engaging, Nick Hornby-style comedy about a young British writer who gets dumped by his gorgeous girlfriend, but the second half descends into turgid family melodrama. Narrator Scott Barron is the ultimate anomaly-a journalist-turned-poet whose book of sensitive verse, Men and Other Mammals, has turned a significant profit. But Scott's life goes downhill when his girlfriend, Ellie, an editor at a women's magazine, breaks up with him after eight reasonably happy months ("we just don't connect"). Another disaster follows when Scott lands a spot on a late-night literary TV show. He has a few too many drinks beforehand to calm his nerves and winds up vomiting on the air. Scott's bad behavior lands him in the tabloids and vaults his book onto bestseller lists. Soon afterward, however, Scott's mother dies from pancreatic cancer, and the novel veers into family terrain as Scott navigates his difficult relationships with his younger brother and his estranged father, who suddenly shows up at his mother's funeral. The sendups of the literary world are amusing, and the romantic material has an edgy appeal even though Barron's insecurities occasionally make him seem overly whiny and unsympathetic. The family drama has some solid, poignant moments, but there are too many hackneyed passages, particularly in a painful, ill-advised subplot that has Barron stealing a penguin from a zoo for his brother, who had a childhood fetish for flightless fowl. What might have been a first-rate romantic comedy instead wobbles between humor and sappy sentiment.
Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Scott Barron has just published his third poetry collection,
Men and Other Mammals, but his success as a poet is the only bright spot in his life. His glamorous girlfriend, Ellie, has just left him, and his relationship with his younger, overweight brother, Jes, grows more contentious by the day. He's asked to read from his new collection on a television show, but in a hilarious scene, Scott manages to screw it up by getting drunk right before going on the air. As if things couldn't get worse, Scott gets a call from Jes telling him that their mother has unexpectedly died. As his relationship with his brother continues to deteriorate, Scott takes a desperate stab at saving it by stealing a penguin from the zoo to bring to Jes, who loved penguins as a child, as a peace offering. It's going to take more than that to fix the problems between them, but this winning debut shows both heart and humor as it chronicles the difficult but loving relationship between the two brothers.
Kristine HuntleyCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved