Most Helpful Customer Reviews
85 of 91 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good, but incomplete, July 16, 2009
This review is from: Men's Health Huge in a Hurry: Get Bigger, Stronger, and Leaner in Record Time with the New Science of Strength Training (Men's Health (Rodale)) (Paperback)
Chad Waterbury is a respected name in the fitness coaching business, largely as a result of his regular contributions to sites like T-Nation and [...]. In fact, Huge in a Hurry is largely a crystallization of the training philosophy that he has elucidated in his articles for those sites. And what Waterbury presents is a logical, practical, empirical guide to strength training, though one that I feel is ultimately incomplete.
The author spends the first several chapters laying the intellectual foundation of his training philosophy. Much of this is information that experienced lifters will already know, but it bears repeating nonetheless, if only to aid the logical flow of the book. The second half of the book consists of various training programs/protocols aimed at different ends. Essentially, the book follows the pattern of many others written on strength training.
The author has been training people for quite a while, and he presents many of his ideas in the context of his own experiences. This is always a positive thing for any kind of practical guide. And it's apparent that Waterbury knows of which he speaks. He quotes peer-reviewed studies to back up most of his larger points, and he holds an advanced degree in the field. I do not take any issue with the author's knowledge; rather I do question some of his conclusions.
Essentially, the author is a proponent of the three-times-per-week, total-body weight training protocol. This is actually a very old-school program that has made a strong comeback in recent years. And it's easy to understand why. The body-part training specialization ad infinitum espoused in the Weider magazines has really veered too far off the track of sanity. Most people don't need twice-per-day workout protocols that drug-enhanced bodybuilders use to prep for the Mr. Olympia. What most people need is basic, sound training ideas that will help them reach their somewhat less lofty fitness goals.
Three-times/total body is one way for people to reach those goals, but it isn't necessarily the route for everyone. The author firmly believes that lifters should train every muscle group in each workout. He bases this idea on his belief that the old notion of the 48-72 hour muscular recovery is incorrect, and on the idea that more volume will lead directly to greater results. The problem with this idea is that recovery time and volume tolerance are two of the most person-specific variables in weight training. No two people respond to a given protocol in the same way. Some need more volume while others do well hitting each muscle group once a week. Some people make tremendous gains on total body workouts, while others run headlong into overtraining and the wall of diminishing returns.
The author claims that he's verified that total-body training is the superior protocol through his own experience, but my experience shows that this is a matter of individual response. Certainly many people will do very well on his program, but just as many will struggle, wondering all the while what they're doing wrong. For these people, some sort of body-part training split may be in order, and I believe that the author should be more careful to note this. Many trainers like the author and Alwyn Cosgrove have made great efforts of vilify body part splits. This seems to me a silly endeavor. Beginning lifters should try all types of programs to see what works best for them. The best program is not what trainer X or Mr. Olympia or Arnold says is the best, it's the one that works for that person.
That said, the information here is solid, and the book is certainly attractive and well written. I will say that if you're interested in getting into total-body-training splits, this is definitely the place to start. I wouldn't, however, go so far as to say that Huge in a Hurry is the definitive word on weight training. Too much is omitted for this book to be considered as such.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
33 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This Will Change The Way You Workout, December 10, 2008
This review is from: Men's Health Huge in a Hurry: Get Bigger, Stronger, and Leaner in Record Time with the New Science of Strength Training (Men's Health (Rodale)) (Paperback)
If you want a change of pace from your traditional workouts, you have come to the right place. If you are tired of the same routine you have been doing for years on end, Huge In A Hurry will provide something you probably haven't done before.
I bought this book because I am a fan of Waterbury's writing and methods. I think he is truly on to something about lifting with heavy weights and doing so in a heavy fashion. If you aren't really set on this technique, try this: Go to your gym and begin another one of your boring workouts. But do something different this time. Increase the weight by 10% or so, and lower your reps to around 4-6. Also, when your lifting the weight, try to move it as fast as possible. Don't think about the lowering phase, just do so in control.
That, in a nutshell, is what this book is about. It has 6 total phases (Get ready, Get big, get bigger, get strong, get stronger, and Get Lean). Many of them last around 16 weeks. It has details on what he recommends to eat after you lift (raisins and whey protein) and how much. I am currently in the Get Ready phase, and i have never felt my heart race so much. The workouts don't take long to do, but they are intense. I think on every workout so far (at least in the Get Ready phase), the workouts only take around 25 minutes or so.
I really don't have any gripes about the book. It is very well put together with photos detailing every exercise. There are also many variations of each workout. And, what I still find mind boggling is that this guy doesn't believe in the bench press! You will still do incline and decline bench, but he doesn't believe the flat bench is good for you.
If you don't believe this book is really as good as it sounds, head on over to T-nation.com to check him out. He writes many articles and puts together some fitness regimens. I can't say enough about how excited I am. You won't be dissapointed!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
24 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Incredible Advice!, March 18, 2009
This review is from: Men's Health Huge in a Hurry: Get Bigger, Stronger, and Leaner in Record Time with the New Science of Strength Training (Men's Health (Rodale)) (Paperback)
I was somewhat skeptical that one could enter and exit a gym, do four exercises and walk out in about twenty five minutes, three times a week, and have any hope at all of gaining any strength or size.
Was I ever wrong! I just completed the 16 week Get Big program and went from 155 pounds to 175 pounds! And that is twenty pounds of MUSCLE, evidenced by the fact that my waist line did not increase one iota!
My fellow employees and friends are telling me that I am starting to look like a Marine!
But the most amazing fact ? While this book is targeted to people between the ages of about 15 and 40,
I achieved these gains at the age of 60 !
I will start another 16 week program in a few more days and cannot wait to see what I can achieve.
I highly recommend this book to anyone that wants to maximize his workout time and achieve real results.
In fact, I think the title should have been; "How to maximize your gym workouts," because that is exactly what one is doing.
Mike G.
Tamarac, Fl
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
