Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Remarkable!, June 10, 2002
Here is a book about poverty, both of the spirit and of the pocket. Written in spare, tidy prose with exceptional characterizations, it is a dark tale periodically shot through with veins of pure gold; moments of such exquisite sweetness (in the character of little Percy, or the aging but quietly heroic Jay Beard) that they are painful. There is nothing stock about the narrative or about the characters who are among the most fully realized I've ever read. The good people (the Hendersons) are all forgivably flawed in some small way. And the bad people are understandable in their angry manipulations, in their negative strengths and human weaknesses. This is not light reading but it is potent and powerful, an evocation of the lengths to which the very poor can be driven. Lyle Henderson, son of the Job-like Sydney, narrator of the family history is a most believably tortured and loving soul. One hopes, throughout this book, for affirming moments that never materialize. Yet there is such truth here that I found it impossible not to keep reading. I am dismayed that I didn't know of the award-winning David Adams Richards before reading this book, but I will certainly be reading his other books at the first possible opportunity. The author's talent is rare and wonderful; his eye is clear and he wastes no time on frilly adjectives. This is prose (and truth) at its purest--a truly remarkable achievement. My highest recommendation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 Stars for writing and philosophy 3 Stars for depression..., January 2, 2002
I believe that I can easily say this is one of my all time favorite reads. It is wonderfully written, the life philosophy it portrays is ideological but many times it gives you a painful feeling for what is happening to the Henderson family. The Hendersons seem to go through many hardships throughout their lives. Both husband and wife, and their two children, from the day they first interact with society they feel they are different, or even outcasts. Sydney refuses to fight back, or think badly about anybody, even his greatest "enemies" though they put him through hell. He insists to be there for them when they need help, and to be kind to them whenever their paths may cross. His son Lyle, and the narrator of the story, witnesses that his father's niceness does not pay back, "the others" continue on hurting them, and plotting for Sydney's fall. Lyle decides to be different from his father, that he will always fight back and that he is not "fearful" like his father, and nobody will ever hurt him or his family again. But as Lyle gets older, he sees that his philosophy of fighting back also does not help him in life. On the contrary events that progress always makes him think about his fathers words "He who hurts others hurts himself." It is definitely a book that most will enjoy reading, but if you are looking for a light read happy book, you might want to pass this one. It is a light read, because it's so well written but it is not a very happy book. I strongly recommend everybody to read this Canadian Giller prize winning novel from David Richard Adams.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An infuriating book I could not put down, October 17, 2001
Mr Richards is something of an unknown quantity, even in his native country, Canada. Most of his books focus on the east coast of Canada, its inhabitants and the way they are sculpted from the land and the circumstances they find themselves in. For me probably the best word that describes it is "fable." Mr Richards is trying to make a point, a very difficult one to accept. I'll leave it to the reader to decide just what that is but you will not be able to put it down. I grew so attached to the main character Sydney and his family that it felt lke a betrayal to put the book down. I was dying for some relief, some justice for this man. Mr Richards does not give in easily though and stays true to his course. He does not let the reader off lightly. There are moments of obvious sentimentality but they are forgiveable. I actually felt humbled by my own personal shortcomings and character faults as I read of the goodness of Sydney and his completely principled existance. Mr Richards has shown that he is a brilliant study of human nature. His observances will convict you of the pettiness that so many of us live our daily lives. This book is not for everyone but I wish it was. Goodness has an enduring quality while evil has its own rewards.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|