So, really, I don't see how you could rate this lower than five stars. It's solid, well made, and it holds a razor blade at an appropriate level. The materials are rust resistant, the threads are spaced enough in the tube to make screwing the head on or off easy and fast.
It's plenty heavy, so you won't forget it's there when you're shaving, and can, in fact, use the weight of the razor to shave for you. You just sort of guide it along.
I've seen a few reviews of this and other razors complaining that the handle is too short. I don't see how--I have big hands, and it feels fine, though this is my first safety razor, and I've never used one with a longer handle. Also, since this is my first safety razor, I have no basis of comparison for models that are somehow adjustable. I'm not sure I understand how that would work, exactly, but I seem to be shaving just fine with this one, and in fact, am sold on giving up cartridge razors entirely.
One thing that I didn't realize with this razor when I bought it: shaving is no longer a quick thing. Using this razor makes shaving into a daily ritual--one that I love, and here's the things you should be aware of if this is your first:
1. You have to shave twice. The second job is just a once over the face again to get that super, baby-skin-soft close shave, which is worth it, but be aware, it takes a little more time.
2. Using canned shaving cream with a safety razor is a travesty. Shaving soap is cheap and lasts forever, and, even better, it's soooo much more luxurious and functional than the canned stuff. However, this adds a couple more things you need to order--a brush and the shaving soap.
3. You can't just wet your face, glop on the cream and go. You really do need to shower first or soak your beard in a hot towel for a few minutes first. It's worth it, and needed, to soften up your beard. Unless you have very soft facial hair to begin with, in which case you may be able to avoid this step. If I don't shower first, the safety razor shreds my face.
4. You now have to consider what blades to buy. Not all blades are equal. In addition, different blades have different levels of difficulty in shaving. The Merkur blade that came with it is a low-level difficulty. It was super easy, and painless--a great first impression. I bought some derby blades, when I ordered the razor, and when I switched, my face looked like I had measles, and the styptic pencil was like fire on my face. I'm doing better now, but you can't just load and go--you have to think about pressure, and angle.
5. Along those lines, you really have to pay attention to the grain of your beard. I have a sort of cow-lick in my beard, so I have to shave one side upwards, one side downwards, and side to side in the middle. If you go against the grain, the razor will hurt you.
Strangely, in spite of these things, I have found I love shaving with this razor. It's a challenge sort of, the soap I bought smells and feels amazing, and the end result of shaving is easily the closest shave I've ever had. It's like there's now a way to make shaving a truly manly activity, complete with blood-loss and skill development. On the other hand, my wife found it works well on her legs also, and will be purchasing one for herself. Forget those cartridge razors. What a rip-off! I never knew.
Oh yeah. the 15 replacement blades I bought cost six bucks. Derby makes a 100 blade pack that costs ten dollars. I didn't buy it because I wanted to try them before I loaded my medicine cabinet with them. Next time, I'm buying the bulk pack--which will last all year.