43 of 43 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Hikers for the Price, November 29, 2008
This review is from: Merrell Men's Moab Mid Gore-Tex XCR (Apparel)
I've done a lot of hiking and backpacking, but I've never made an investment in really "good" hiking boots. Finally I decided it was time when I decided to go on a four day backpacking trip on the Appalachian trail last October. I couldn't afford the higher end boots ($160-250), so I settled on these as it was a brand I knew and they were the cheapest I could find with GORE-TEX and Vibram.
Now, EVERYONE, knows that you never, ever, ever go on a backpacking trip with new boots. Ever. I knew this, so I ordered these well in advance. Unfortunately ShoeMall (whom I ordered from) took a really long time to ship them, and they came less than a day before I had to leave. I didn't really have any choice but to wear them, so I splurged on some Smartwool socks (HIGHLY recommended--backpacking with them is a totally new experience) to try to alleviate the blisters.
Well, I never expected what I got. These boots were very, very comfortable. I have high arches and under-pronate--how they would work for people with other types of feet I can't say, but I suspect it wouldn't much matter.
The boots have good ankle support--not super, but good--and that was all I needed. I'm young and have strong ankles, and I'd rather have less weight than more support. I did sort of twist my foot once on the trip, but I was fine. People who need a lot of support might look elsewhere. This isn't a shortcoming of the product--it's just a characteristic.
The grip is excellent. That's to be expected, they have Vibram. I did slip a few times, but it was on really wet rocks, and it may have been, as my friend put it, a user issue.
As for the waterproofing, well, you could spend $300 and you wouldn't find a more waterproof boot. It rained the first and second days, and I never felt the tiniest drop of dampness. At one point I literally submerged my foot in a river to see if any water would get in. Nada.
Overall these boots have everything I want. They may not be perfect for everyone, but if you don't have special needs (like extra support), this is the best bang you'll ever get for your buck. As I said, I took these on a four day backpacking trip on the Appalachian trail without ever wearing them before. I had a 30 pound pack. On the last day I hiked 17 miles--lots of up and down. I didn't get any blisters. None. At the end of the last day I was starting to get a small hotspot on one foot, but that was all. I'm not suggesting you take these backpacking without breaking them in, but these are as comfortable as you'll get. Just make sure you invest in some good wool hiking socks as well.
Update: I've now had the boots for over a year and a half. I've hiked parts of the Appalachian trail, the high country above Zion Canyon, the grabens of Canyonlands NP, and the Grand Canyon. At the Grand Canyon I hiked from the south rim to the river and back in a day. It's a tad under 20 miles, with 5000 vertical feet of descent on the way down, and that same 5000 coming back up. When I got back up to the top my whole body ached--except my feet. These boots are light, supportive, and 100% waterproof. I've hiked hundreds of miles in them and they're still in great shape with no real signs of wear.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Don't Let Them Stay Clean Very Long, GO OUT AND USE THEM!, August 10, 2009
This review is from: Merrell Men's Moab Mid Gore-Tex XCR (Apparel)
Length:: 1:38 Mins
I went on a five (5) mile hike in Taconic State Park (NY, about four [4] miles from the MA border) most of this hike was up a fairly steep hill (not quite climbing on hands and knees but still pretty steep) through various terrain. There was a lot of mud because it had recently rained and there were also a few streams here and there like in the video. These boots conquered all, they performed marvelously during the whole hike. I really thought I'd have trouble when it came to wet rocks, but they pulled through. The only time I had trouble crossing rocks was when they were covered with algae, because although they gripped to the algae very well, the algae didn't stay on the rock every time.
As far as how they feel, right off the shelf they felt incredible. They've got to be some of the most comfortable things I've ever worn.
I HIGHLY recommend them to anyone really. You don't have to be a hiker to enjoy these.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No