Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Grand Master in Top Form, November 14, 2007
This review is from: The Metatemporal Detective (Hardcover)
I have read and reread virtually every word of fiction Michael Moorcock has written over the course of his long career, and my favorite stories of all of them are to be found in this book. A member of the extended Von Bek/Beck/Begg family which has featured in so much of Moorcock's output the last few decades, Sir Seaton Begg is a metatemporal detective, and from his rooms at Sporting Club Square he ranges all over the multiverse solving crimes. His frequent nemesis and bête noire (and distant relation) is Monsieur Zodiac, himself a variant not only of the Count Ulric von Bek of the Dreamthief's Daughter trilogy, but also of Elric of Melnibone himself, and his sidekick is Taffy Sinclair, who may or may not be British novelist Iain Sinclair. Some of the stories are somewhat steampunk in flavoring, complete with airships naturally, and most are technically alternate histories, but taken as a whole cover they too large a range to be confined by a single subgenre. They are simply "fantasy," and leave it at that.
The Metatemporal Detective collects stories that originally appeared in venues as far afield as the Michael Chabon-edited McSweeney's Mammoth Treasury of Thrilling Tales, New Statesman, and Tales of the Shadowmen (and variations on some of the stories were central to the comic book miniseries Michael Moorcock's Multiverse, as well). This is the only place to get them all together, though, and the only place to read the original "The Flaneur des Arcades de l'Opera," for that matter.
This collection represent nothing more or less than a grand master of fantasy working in top form, writing the kinds of stories it amuses him to write. Highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Probably Not for the Uninitiated, March 13, 2009
This review is from: The Metatemporal Detective (Hardcover)
While I am of course quite aware of the works of Moorcock, I've somehow managed to not actually read any of them save for a few short stories here and there. I do have a vague understanding about his particular treatment of the multiverse and the Eternal Champion, but I certainly am not steeped in the nuances of his oeuvre. I am then not exactly the target audience for this collection.
Here we have the adventures of Sir Seaton Begg as he tackles his great nemesis, relative, and frenemy Monsieur Zenith across time and space. It took me awhile to figure out that we're dealing with variants of these characters from one story to the next--while most settings share some similarities (no United States, no internal combustion engines or oil production, lots of electric-powered trains and zeppelins, and plenty of Hitler), they differ in certain details, and in only two or three stories is there any suggestion of continuity. Pretty much these are standalone tales featuring a bunch of different guys called Begg and Zenith (who are usually aware of, and skilled in traveling to, parallel dimensions), scattered across the multiverse on their own individual tracks of history. At the same time, each Begg and Zenith also seems to be the *only* incarnation around--there's never an overt suggestion that there's a Begg from Earth-2 and a different one from Earth-616, and while they acknowledge the existence of other worlds, they never speculate about other versions of themselves. It's all very quantum.
As a sometime resident of both Central Texas and France, Moorcock does a nice job capturing the atmosphere and distinguishing details of these locales when he sets stories there. But when it comes to characters, Begg and Zenith and their supporting casts are very much (by design?) merely archetypes. The reader rarely gets the vaguest hint about their thoughts or personalities. Similarly, events typically unfold as if preordained, and often it seems as if the outcomes would've been the same regardless of what anyone did. It's as if Moorcock envisions a particular spectacle he wishes to depict at the climax and a particular style he wants to emulate (he excels at banging out excitable prose in the manner of a Boy's Own tale), and then just arranges the pieces to move mechanically toward the end. Often the import of what is taking place is buried in the minds of Begg and Zenith, who only grudgingly provide the reader with a tidbit or two about what it all means. (I assume that Moorcockians get about 117% more meaning out of these stories than the layperson.)
These short stories are fine as stylistic exercises (and for Moorcock to revisit characters over the years and to earn a paycheck in contributing to various anthologies), but they certainly are not very gripping and there's some degree of repetition. I also could've done with less Hitler. And I'm a little tired of how often British genre writers express their hatred of Thatcher and Bush (although Reagan was spared this time). Often I think that they were traumatized as lads when Thatcher evidently confiscated their puppies and took away their candy and personally cancelled "Doctor Who". Fortunately literature gives them avenues for revenge.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
for the Moorcock mob, December 2, 2007
This review is from: The Metatemporal Detective (Hardcover)
The eleven tales that make up this fascinating (for fans of the Moorcock multiverse) short story collection are predominately written in the last fifteen years with two of them from 1966 They all obviously involve adventures of The Metatemporal Detective on worlds similar yet dissimilar to ours. Although the hero's name slightly varies but for the most part he is British Home Office Metatemporal Investigation Department agent Seaton Begg; his prime adversary is Count Zenith the Albino (Elric by any other name?) although Hitler is an opponent/client in "The Case of the Nazi Canary". His sidekick is MID pathologist Dr. Taffy Sinclair
The satirical entries are fun especially as the skins of politicians better be thick with characters like George Putz, Dicky Shiner and Wolfy Paulowitz (see "The Mystery of the Texas Twister"). However, they are also often difficult to follow with obscure references in a pseudo historical setting on an alternate world. Mr. Moorcock also pays tribute to pulp fiction magazine detective Sexton Blake (never read) and the 1966 tales seem to have served as a prototype for Elric. This is definitely for the Moorcock mob, but not a good entry point for newcomers.
Harriet Klausner
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
