42 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Step Into My Parlor, Said the Spider to the Fly, July 30, 2007
This review is from: The Mexican Mafia (Hardcover)
I'm not sure what Publishers Weekly wanted from Tony Rafael's debut book, The Mexican Mafia. It seems they don't know either. If they're looking for an academic work, a courtroom drama, or a "just the facts, m'am" retelling, they won't find it here. This book isn't an in-depth biography of District Attorney Anthony Manzella, either. Instead, this is a guided tour of the sticky, tangled, messy, dangerous webs of the Mexican Mafia--La Eme--a prison-born, and prison-based group of top-level gang members who set policy and practice for many Hispanic Southern California gangsters on the street.
In this part of the spider web are the multiple murder and conspiracy trials of eight gangsters from the Avenues sets in Highland Park, CA, a suburb of Los Angeles. Rafael uses theses trials as the setting for examining how the intertwining of law enforcement policy, politics, street gangs, the justice system, public perception and the mainstream media in Southern California have all played a part in the establishment and rise of La Eme. By picking apart the events of these trials, giving us the back stories, the histories, and the voices of the players, both big and small, Rafael guides us to the center of the web, where many of the Carnales, the "brothers," who make up La Eme's power brokers, sit in their cells in prisons across California and the United States. It's the flow of gangsters and these Emeros' orders, money and drugs, rules and penalties for behavior and misbehavior, from Pelican Bay, the SuperMax in Florence, CO, and the Los Angeles County jails to the streets of California and back to prison that has maintained the secrecy, power and control of the Mexican Mafia over the street level gangs that spread all over Southern California. It's this flow of orders that rests at the heart of these trials--that these murders and many other crimes are committed on the street level by Eme-controlled gang members, on the orders of these Carnales.
This book doesn't tie things up in a neat and tidy bow. It can't, because it's just a small glimpse of a much larger, ongoing problem. It isn't a quick and easy read either, but it is riveting, even compelling, in how raw, far-reaching, and unchecked the Eme's activities are. Rafael pulls no "politically correct" punches in looking at how political power plays, racial hatred, public funding of gang intervention programs, failures of law enforcement and more, have all helped to hide and inadvertently support this organization. Some parts of the book are largely repetitive, going over the same testimony of a handful of people over the course of several trials, and it may take some re-reading to follow the back stories and histories involved, and keep track of the many people and their associates, but this is a book well-worth reading. Like watching a spider consuming the fly it catches, it made me a little nauseous, but I couldn't tear my eyes away.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
43 of 50 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A fair and insightful glimpse into the power & influence of 'M', August 20, 2007
This review is from: The Mexican Mafia (Hardcover)
I am impelled to begin my review of Tony's book with a brief response to Rob Thomas (the 1st of Mr. Rafael's reviewers- see below):
Mr. Thomas complains that the 'worst' part of Rafael's work is its 'right wing slant'.
Perhaps Thomas would have been happier with a decidedly 'liberal' slant on the book, in which Rafael blamed the gang epidemic (and the pervasive influence of the 'M') on Bush and Cheney.....or the absence of affirmative action programs??
Perhaps instead of holding parents (and individuals) responsible for their own bad choices, Tony should have elected to blame the government (or better yet, the 'white man') for the success of gangsterism?? That way, he would have almost certainly been guaranteed a lectureship at UCLA!
Mr. Thomas further laments Rafael's book cover, declaring it to have 'Mexican Immigration Xenophobia' written all over it.
This is laughable!
Here Thomas again betrays his own (obviously) liberal worldview. (Perhaps Mr. Rafael should have used a Swedish flag on the cover, in order to avoid the ever-present possibility of offending the PC thought police?)
By the way, Mr. Thomas, since the book's cover also portays the image of a 9mm Baretta (an Italian-made firearm), does it follow that Rafael's intention was to disparage the Italians too?
You're right, Mr. Thomas. The 'M' IS an American-born organization (particularly a California-born organization). But I haven't heard of any 'Emeros' lately waving the American flag or quoting the Federalist Papers. Have you?
Call me crazy, but the charter members of 'M' named themselves 'La Mafia Mexicana' (their designation, not ours). Many of them sport tattoes which read 'Cien por ciento Mexicano' or 'Orgulloso Mexicano', etc.
Moreover, along with most rank-and-file Surenos, many 'Emeros' portray themselves as Aztec warriors, who are carrying on their Mexican heritage.
Perhaps simply stating the obvious ought to be avoided in the interest of not sounding 'Xenophobic' to those who interpret EVERYTHING through the politically-correct (and always RACE-CONSCIOUS) lenses of a liberal political ideology??
Anyway, onward toward my actual review of Tony's book...
The book was enjoyable and educational, and it provides the reader with a fair understanding of the relationship between the 'M' and street gangs in California.
I applaud the way in which Tony takes his readers into the courtroom, and into the seldom-seen world of police (and DA) investigations.
Although (as mentioned) much of the material is meticulously-detailed and, in some cases, repetitious (after all, the book covers not one, but several different, although related, criminal trials), it was certainly not a major detraction from the overall enjoyment of the book.
One interesting fact from the book that I was previously unaware of:
Following the 'American Me' executions, Edward James Olmos was taxed $50k by the 'M', in order to get himself out of the hat. (As Mr. Rafael suggests, it's too bad that the other 'green-lighted' consultants didn't have the cash to get themselves off the list too)
The book also provides at least one chapter of historical background for 'M', discussing the influence of 1st and 2nd generation "Emeros" such as Cheyenne Cadena and Joe Morgan. (This is a good chapter for those who are relatively new in studying the subject)
My only real disappointment with the book is that I had hoped for some detailed, biographical discussion regarding some of the present-day 'leaders' and 'drop outs' in the 'M'. (The former would include 'carnales' like Alfie Sosa, Tupi Hernandez, Huero Shy and 'Champ', while the latter would include, most notably, "Boxer" Enriquez)
Since Mundo's CD-Rom "From Altar Boy to Hitman" covered the late-1950's through the early 80's, I had hoped that Mr. Rafael's book would, in a manner of speaking, pick up the story where Mundo left off. (Another book begs to be written from the perspective of someone like "Boxer" Enriquez, in order to provide an insider's perspective on "M in the 21st century")
However, to be fair, Tony Rafael explicitly states that he was not seeking to provide a biographical sketch of one or two high-ranking 'Carnales'. Rather, his work is written primarily from the perspective of law enforcement, and as an investigative reporter.
In conclusion, Mr. Rafael has performed a public service by writing his book. As Gava Joe (in his wisdom) rightly points out, this book is important "for anyone concerned about the fate of our children".
Well said, Gava Joe.
Buy Tony's book.......right wing slant notwithstanding.
With respect,
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No