Customer Reviews

The Middle East for Dummies

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

This book serves its purpose well. The author presents the history and culture of the Middle East by laying out the facts, and weaving in editorial comments to enhance understanding of the facts. Reading this book will allow anyone to have a basic, but strong understanding of the region. I disagree strongly that this book is biased; quite to the contrary, it is one of the few English language books about the Middle East that presents the facts and the the persepctive of all sides truly evenly.

The Middle East for Dummies gives a fairly even-handed overview of the Middle East region - its people, history, traditions as well as political and religious conflicts. The writer has actually travelled to the region and spent time with many ordinary people there. Reading this book really made me think about the fact that people are just people everywhere. I learned a lot about the diversity of cultures and people within the Middle East and got a solid understanding of how the political conflict in the region developed. The writer gives both sides of the story, which is really refreshing for such a charged up subject. If you want to really learn something, this is a great book. I'd also beware of other reviewers here; look at their profiles and see how biased they are. I normally don't write reviews, but when I saw the quality of reviews on books on this subject, I really felt I should write something.

I bought this book as sort of a starting point to read other books about the current Middle East mess, and found it to be quite informative; provides a number of maps and pictures to show the layout of the region's past, and brings the reader up to date (though it's ever-changing) on the turmoil going on there now. The Middle East for Dummies, however, is not just Bullets Over Baghdad; it contains information about it's colorful culture throughout the years, and serves well as a reference guide, whether, as other posts state, it is biased or not.

This is a great book to get your feet wet. It introdues this historical characters both current players and past. Given this context it is a great spring board for other texts into researching the Middle East and interesting religious, cultural and political concepts in the Middle East.

If I were to add anything to the reviews here a really well devleoped bibliography would have been helpful. That's almost alays a great further reading sections that empowers the reader to dive into what ever particular subject material is of interest to them.

I have been doing a lot of Middle East Research and often find this a great place to start when looking into something as a resource. It was a very fast and easy read. If you're deploying to the Middle East for a military operation and want some insight and understanding into the culture, the clanish mentality of the tribes there, buy this book. It will be very helpful.

The relevant history of the Middle East spans several thousand years. This book tries to cover that entire history in about 370 pages. This is a daunting task, but the author pulls this off reasonably well.

This book is written in the standard Dummies format. If you have read any of the other the other books in the Dummies series, then you already know that the Dummies books usually contain humor mixed with the main subject matter. As this book was published in the context of the post-9/11 world and the U.S. invasion of Iraq, humor is a tall order. Once again, the author succeeds admirably. There are a few tongue-in-cheek remarks, but not too many.

The coverage of the ancient Middle East is limited. This was probably necessary because of space limitations. Nevertheless, you will finish this book with at least a basic idea of who the ancient Egyptians, the Babylonians, and the Sumerians (etc., etc.) were. Here the Middle East for Dummies provides a good foundation for further reading of a more in-depth text, like "Ancient Mesopotamia: Portrait of a Dead Civilization" ISBN 0226631877 by Oppenheim. (I highly recommend this book if you want to take a deep dive into the ancient Middle East.)

The birth of Islam, the original Islamic conquests, and the Crusades are rolled into a chapter entitled "The Medieval Middle East." This chapter may disappoint some readers, not through any fault of the author, but because there is so much compressed into one chapter. The Crusades are a topic that most readers will probably want to read about in-depth, but they are covered in only two pages. (Consider Karen Armstrong's "Holy War" ISBN: 0385721404 for a detailed though somewhat politically correct account of the Crusades.)

The book succeeds in giving a succinct portrait of each of the major countries in the modern Middle East, and the history that shaped each country since the early twentieth century. The chapters on the modern Middle East include descriptions of the major wars in the region.

One of the most useful sections of the book is Chapter 25 (Ten Key Militant Groups). Here you get the history not only of Al-Qaeda, Hamas, and Hezbollah, but also lesser known groups that are active in Pakistan, Egypt, and Turkey.

Davis also includes short descriptions of the multiple religious sects in the Middle East (not just the Shias and the Sunnis, but also the Copts, the Jacobites, and the various permutations of Judaism.)

If you are new to the history of the Middle East, this is not a bad place to start.

Review by Edward Trimnell, author of "Understanding the Middle East: History, Religion, and the Clash of Cultures" (ISBN: 0974833061)

The book was just what I was looking for.It covered a wide range in simple terms and was easy to use.

For someone who is as poorly informed as me, I can see that there is a lot that is valuable inside this book, but gosh, about halfway through, it just got overwhelming.

SO MUCH is unfamiliar, I might as well be reading about life on another planet.

Making it thru all the difficult names and locations (whose names are always changing) and geography and passions and movements and goals and perspectives and history is HARD!

Not to mention the fact that there is constantly so much violence and I have very, very little understanding of the social and political structures around which these many, many events take place.

Before I finished, I looked for a CHILDREN'S BOOK to start me off with a more BASIC understanding of day-to-day life in the Middle East.

So far, I've been very disappointed to discover that there really aren't any.

I'm sure that's going to change, one day.

Meanwhile, I'll retain this book as a reference and maybe I'll go back and try to re-read some of it again.

And yes, it did explain some things that I really didn't understand at all. But I can only barely remember what they are, at the moment.

It's a good book by a knowlegeable author but I'm (hopefully) looking forward to an even better (and SIMPLER) one.

(sometimes 'dummies' really are 'dummies', y'know)

I usually read topics like this with great enthusiasm. This book is a long hard forced march through very rough terrain, often going in circles. It reads like forty years wandering in the wilderness (no maps, no GPS, no pillars of fire or smoke).

Pros: Minimal editorializing and bias. Seems mostly fact based. Does a fair job of covering the history and modern day tensions of such a large and volatile region. I did come away more informed. It did provide a fair baseline of knowledge I can build on. I expect it will make a better reference manual than text.

Cons:
Published in 2003, it is disappointingly out of date. I missed this when I purchased.
Poorly organized. I had to create my own cast list, scorecard and timeline to keep track of the players. The publisher should have included these study aids. Yes, it is very complex, but the way it is delivered is more confusing than clarifying.
The author seems to know his stuff, but his editor let him leave in some very infantile attempts at clever word play..."Kurds in the way"... "adding the "bubbles" to Syria's Baath" ... "A painful route canal (Suez,that is)" ... give the reader a break. I guess that's why they call the series, "for Dummies."

Somewhat disappointing and frustrating. I wish I had shopped around more.

Great product I'd recommend for anyone who wants to learn about the Middle East without frustrations of searching out multiple resources for the basic summary of that area.

Whether it was just my burning desire to learn more about the Middle East or not, this is probably THE best 'For Dummies' or 'Idiot's Guides' out today. Highly recommended if you need to make sense of what's going on and how it got there. I can't praise it enough. I only wished that the area map illustrations had been of a better quality---a great buy at a great price, nonetheless. Get it.