25 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I recommend it, June 15, 2001
I have watched this video a bunch of times and have always thoroughly enjoyed it. I don't have any idea what the other reviewers are hearing when they call this 'smooth jazz'!!! I mean, listen to Bob Berg's solos for crying out loud. And Miles'. And Scofield's. These guys are clearly burning their butts off. If your idea of "Jazz" is only acoustic-straightahead-retrobebop then don't buy this. But if you're into "Music" in the broader sense that doesn't pigeonhole you into stylistic categories, then buy this. It's great music.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An essential mid-80's addition to Miles Davis' legacy!, July 15, 2000
This highly recommended June 28, 1985 Montreal concert--previously issued in Japan--helps reopen the case for recognizing much of the music of Miles' final years as a reiteration of his trademark strengths, albeit perhaps without a stunning creative landmark on the order of KIND OF BLUE or BITCHES BREW. Maybe LIVE IN MONTREAL is that mid-80's signpost--if not, it's very close! The level of inspiration, commitment to excellence, and turning the future into the present is what you would expect of Miles at any point in his career!
Davis' acumen for picking talented, individualistic sidepersons is glaringly evident on this Montreal date. John Scofield is of course a premier electric guitarist who makes very distinctive contributions, while reedman Bob Berg is a similiarly inspired soloist. Synthman Robert Irving III is the playmaker who doesn't shoot the ball much (i.e., no solos) but dishes out assist after assist to the overall group sound, via subtle textures that sometimes achieve the spirit if not the letter of the orchestrated Gil Evans sound that Miles seemed to desire after 1983. Darryl Jones puts those ping-ponging, thumb-popping notes in just a little bit better place than most other bassists. Vincent Wilburn Jr. provides a full sound and solid beats, thankfully without forgetting that his is a supporting role, and percussionist Steve Thornton also plays what is needed, where it is needed.
Included are expansive versions of the two most notable ballads of this era (HUMAN NATURE, TIME AFTER TIME), while the funk/r&b/soul idiom is covered via D-Train's SOMETHING'S ON YOUR MIND. Don't be concerned if you're not a fan of the then-current YOU'RE UNDER ARREST or DECOY albums which provded the bulk of the material for this tour: they were merely blueprints for the passionate live renditions heard here.
By TIME AFTER TIME, CODE M.D., and a Spain-sketched reworking of JEAN PIERRE, Miles Davis' playing is in a ZONE, absolutely burning with a passion he rarely surpassed--before or after! Davis' solos are marked by extended length, great endurance, and confidence in all ranges of his horn. Unless you absolutely cannot stand electric instrumentation and contemporary pop-culture music influencing a jazz-rooted perspective, LIVE IN MONTREAL is a must-have!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
22 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This music is burning...and Miles is astounding, February 7, 2001
If anybody needed more proof that Wynton Marsalis, Stanley Crouch and Peter Watrous are full of s... about Miles not playing challenging great music at the highest level in the 80ties, this DVD will show a Miles who once again has the cream of the crop sidemen in his band, with Scofield playing one of the greatest solos you'll ever hear on the first track! Miles, however, is particularly inspiring even around such fantastic musicians he remains the center of attention, his solos have that otherworldly "where did that come from" mystique yet totally logic that is the realm of the true greats. This is timeless jazzmusic on the highest level, even if Ken Burns and Wynton can't recognize that.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No