Customer Reviews

Military Small Arms of the 20th Century

5 star:		(8)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(4)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

The first edition of this book, published in 1973, was also one of the first gun books I ever owned. I must have consulted it innumerable times since then - and yet I remember vividly that even at that distant time, as a boy, I felt vaguely disappointed whenever I closed it and had to put it back onto the shelf. This work has been quite a commercial success, and I am now reviewing the (previous and out-of-print) 6th edition from 1991; the 7th edition 2000 will have to be reviewed separately, in order to determine whether it will indeed offer more than a few singular additions and omissions, given how little the basic format and style have evolved or improved from the first to the sixth edition through eighteen years.

Weeks and Hogg have set out to give a fairly brief, comprehensive overview of the 20th century's military small arms. The book is divided into five main subjects groups: pistols (meaning handguns in general and thus including revolvers), 71 pp.; bolt action rifles, 52 pp.; automatic rifles (comprising semi-auto and full-auto rifles alike), 56 pp.; submachineguns: 69 pp.; machineguns, 74 pp.; anti-tank rifles, 6 pp. Within each section, the entries are listed by country and then by year of military acceptance.

The book is illustrated throughout with black-and-white photographs and some drawings; it averages two illustrations per page. The quality of these images ranks between average and - frequently - very low (these latter are mostly blotted and dark, occasionally too light); pictures have definitely deteriorated since the first edition, not improved. Furthermore, arms are not infrequently photographed from an unbecoming angle which makes identification and comparison with others difficult. A number of images (mostly in the "pistols" section) are too large and give away valuable space unnecessarily.

A bibliography (even a small basic one, which would help a novice) is lacking totally; equally absent are short introductory sections which would acquaint the - often uninitiated - reader with the development of small arms in the 20th century and with the basic principles of firearms operation (such sections were still present in the 1st edition, though of questionable quality). For a layman or a young student, both of which are most likely to consult this book, the many short name-dropping textual references to "delayed blowback", "toggle action", "primary extraction" will thus remain cryptical in spite of the brief explanatory glossary on pp. 339-344; clarifying drawings lack almost totally.

As previous reviewers of another edition have noted (in a rather charitable and tactful way), the athors' choice of entries is ill-balanced and lacks judgement. The book is literally teeming with many quaint and little-used prototypes and experimental guns which were never accepted into military service, while important and mass-produced first-line firearms, which have shaped military and general history, are often treated just briefly, and are not infrequently misrepresented. The authors lack even a basic sense of historical weight distribution, and the unhappy reader is thus covered under a deluge of incoherent and irrelevant information factoids. E.g., the mushrooming irrelevant subvariants of the Canadian Ross rifles, or manifold Dutch Mannlicher carbine submodels are listed in tiring detail over pages, while most important small arms as the German MG 42 and StGew 44, or the Belgian FN-Browning GP 35 (Highpower), or the Soviet AK 47 Kalashnikov are brushed off in a terse paragraph.

Furthermore, the accompanying texts are very unreliable; errors abound and mostly have not been corrected. While any general comprehensive work is bound to show some flaws and occasional shortcomings - as every reviewer will fairly allow for -, its quality is infinitely lower than Edward C(linton) Ezell's "Small Arms of the World" (12th ed. 1983) or John Walter's "Military Bolt Action Rifles of the World" (2nd ed. 1998), let alone a thorough technical treatise as Frank De Haas' fine, though thematically much more limited "Bolt Action Rifles" (3rd ed. 1995). The authors mix technical tidbits of little interest with general rumours, tired old wives' tales and sweeping judgements devoid of actual experience. The targeted readership is highly likely to be misinformed and misled by such a book with boldly claims to be an "encyclopedia" - but it is not even an enchiridion, not even a comprehensive basic reference text for a first approach. Even the smallest school and communal libraries would do their readers a disservice if they contemplate this book as a basic part of the (necessarily limited) gunbooks section; they should rather opt for Ezell (see above), if only one work could be acquired.

This book contains some very useful and interesting information. However, it falls far short of being comprehensive. Although the title is "Miltary Small Arms..." the work contains entries for firearms never adopted by any military, and omits significant military-issue firearms (e.g., the Canadian and British Inglis High Power, the US M4 and M4A1 Carbines, the Colt Model M General Officer's Pistols in .32 & .380, etc.).

The book is still a worthwhile purchase, though one is left wondering why certain obscure firearms were included while too many standard issue firearms were omitted.

I have had this book for a number of years and, although the research is excellent, it does indeed have substantial typo's and reference errors as if the material was compiled by a staff editor who knows nothing about firearms and has not taken the trouble to make simple corrections. Many firearms are omitted and some included, however revolutionary and ground-breaking they are not always representative of the whole. Furthermore, the entire category of combat shotguns has not even been addressed but anti-materiel rifles have, which are undeniably interesting but only a small part of the whole. The organization is good as are the photographs but I would have made a number of editing corrections as a previous reviewer has noted (I have written in the corrections in my own volume). I rely upon this volume for information but often double check the facts through other sources as the glaring errors reduces my confidence in this as a comprehensive reference. As a reference book writer myself, I have written to the publisher offering to edit an 8th edition should such a thing be in the works but of course there is no profit margin for a slightly corrected version of a popular volume. My edition is so heavily thumbed and used that I will likely acquire another and not balk at the price but would gladly pay more for an accurate reference.

For those with a passing interest or an obsession with guns, it may be wise to buy other books before this one. It contains well written write up that includes the history of the weapon, firearms efficiently cataloged by categories according to their countries with a well designed table of contents of an easier time of searching for the firearm and several photographs to entertain the passive reader. I'd also like to add that the index at the back was a very effective way of finding a particular gun and the introductory articles were well turned-out. Although it could have been better with more detailed cutaway photographs of the weapons and the articles could have used some additions beyond the weapons history. It also could have included weapons manufactured by up and coming manufacturers like Arms Corporation of the Philippines that imports well made firearms to the States and other countries. Not a top priority buy in the long list of firearm reference but a must nonetheless.

Ian Hogg, one of the most knowledgable arms experts in the world, continues to update and refine this definitive work in this 6th edition. More than a technical reference or photo album, the text reveals fascinating historical data and trivia on military weapons from around the world, shedding light on how, and sometimes why, military weapons evolved. The layout makes locating a particular weapon quick and easy, and Hogg's style makes reading enjoyable.

This is truly the first and last book when it comes to 20th century small arms. Ian Hogg does it again as he categorizes weapons by type then country. Every gun is included from WWI to 1990.

This book is black and white but the photos are good, and he has some for some very rare guns.

Each gun is accompanied by a photo and a chart laying out the facts. Each gun also contains a few paragraphs of history and review as to how it should be placed in history. For example the MG42 is rightfully hailed as the best machine gun of WWII, while the M16 is ridiculed as reason we lost Vietnam.

I'm read a lot of gun books and this one is the best because of Hogg's writing, and the fact that it is the most comprehensive I've ever seen. He doesn't just include his favorite guns but every gun ever used in 20th century combat.

The HK G11 cover is also impressive.

This is a thorough introduction to the world of personal military firearms. In it, the authors describe each and every pistol, revolver, rifle, machine gun, and sub-machine gun produced for military use by every country in the world during this century. The text is sprinkled with historical notes, giving readers a sense of each weapon's place in history. Descriptions are fairly detailed, including calibers, rates of fire , muzzle velocities, and a concise explanation of each weapon's firing action. This book is the best place to begin learning seriously about military small arms, their uses, and their historical significance.

Very happy with this book & it had all the information I needed on the rifles I have.

after reading this book I have a much better understanding of ballistic physics and modern weaponry. I hope everyone can find the time to read this book. Jacoby Ellsbury would be proud. Especially because he is perhaps the greatest baseball player ever.

I've always enjoyed Mr. Hogg's books. His writing is informative and I find myself refering back to his books time and time again. Though I have a few small quibbles with this edition, some models are left out etc. , for the most part I found it to be a comprehensive and beautifully illustrated reference book. But what I especially like about Ian Hogg is that he's actually rather witty. Hardly what one would expect from a technical reference work, such as this. I've been wanting a copy of this book for many years and I don't regret having spent the money to buy this , the last edition of this series.Hopefully everyone agrees with me.