Most Helpful Customer Reviews
67 of 74 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not Exactly Market Wizards, October 17, 2007
This review is from: Millionaire Traders: How Everyday People Are Beating Wall Street at Its Own Game (Hardcover)
Read this book, but be careful. The research and documentation are questionable.
Millionaire Traders tries to replicate Jack Schwager's "Market Wizards". It does not. Read Market Wizards first. It is thorough, well researched, and the traders in it are first rate.
There is some useful information. The traders interviewed trade a variety of instruments (not just FX as one reviewer claimed). It is interesting to see how others got into trading and how they chose their markets.
The following are what I consider the downsides of this book:
1. There is no indication of how these people were chosen. Unlike Schwager's book, the author's do not tell how they chose these 12 traders to represent successful individual traders. There is also no indication that the authors verified that these traders were successful. It appears that they just took their word at face value.
2. Some of the traders represented as being highly successful individual traders are "mentoring" and running blogs and chat rooms. A real red flag. It does not necessarily mean that they are not successful traders, but anyone who has been around long enough knows that a lot of "experts" selling their trading knowledge do so because they can't make money trading. Some are very good, but for every good one there are 10 con artists.
3. Some of the resources touted as having been instrumental in their development are worthless.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
25 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointed, December 27, 2007
This review is from: Millionaire Traders: How Everyday People Are Beating Wall Street at Its Own Game (Hardcover)
I just finished reading Millionaire Traders and was generally disappointed in the book.
First, I found the sloppy editing, obvious grammar mistakes and numerous spelling errors highly annoying. No professionally authored and published book should have so many errors. Every page has missing or misplaced commas, misspelled words, or words simply missing from sentences.
Either the book was never copy edited, or that part of production was farmed out to a couple high school kids working summer internships.
While a few mistakes per book are acceptable and expected, mistakes on every page made the book unpleasant to read and created an unprofessional impression of the authors/publisher.
Secondly, as another reviewer mentioned, I would like to know how these particular traders were selected. Where did the authors find these people and what did the authors do, if anything, to try to verify the traders' performance claims?
As someone who plans to trade for a living at some point in the future, I was looking forward to reading each interview, but at the end of each I was left wondering who is this guy and how do I know his numbers are legit?
By interviewing professional traders, Jack Schwager in Market Wizards bypassed this problem, but by focusing on "Everyday People", the authors need to do more to establish credibility.
Finally, it seemed like the book was heavily skewed toward Forex traders. Even though traders of other instruments were featured, it just seemed to lean on Forex a lot, but this might be more impression than fact.
Overall, as I read the book I couldn't help but think this was a slam-bam-thank-you-type imitation of Schwager's two books, only superficially and sloppily written, then rushed through production to meet an arbitrary publishing deadline.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
52 of 60 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Everyday market wizards, September 27, 2007
This review is from: Millionaire Traders: How Everyday People Are Beating Wall Street at Its Own Game (Hardcover)
Ok, I will start with a run-down of the things I liked best about this book.
-Every trader profiled is very different than the others. Telling me there are hundreds of ways to make money trading.
-Every trader knows his strengths and weaknesses and focuses on what he is good at. The basic centuries old advice "Know Thyself" rings true again. Are you better trading long or short? Fast hits, or more long term? Trade your style for success.
-Every trader says "don't lose money". Come on, who doesn't know that? But it turns out it is probably one of the most violated trading rules out there, one every successful trader follows. As the book states, protect yourself, No Capital, No Trading, No Life.
-You are not smarter than the market. Trade what is happening at this moment, not what you want or hope to happen.
-Stay away from companies with debt. If you are going long, that's a great piece of advice! While other companies that carry debt also move up, those without it move up more reliably.
-Trend is continuous, but turn only happens once.
-If you have to make money, you never will. All of these traders trade to do it right. If you do it right each time you will make money as an added benefit. If you violate your rules the market will punish you.
-Focus on a few stocks, futures, or currencies. You can't trade everything, so you need to become an expert and specialize somewhere.
The traders profiled target different markets. Stocks, futures, and Forex. There is a good assortment here so you should be able to find at least one trader that resonates with your trading style. While every one of them trades differently they all have figured out a system that they stick to. Some have daily profit targets, others don't. Some of the targets are large, others seem very small, like one trader that shoots for ten pips a day. That's a pretty easy target in my opinion, but if you make it a large trade you can achieve a pretty high reward.
One comment in the book really clicked for me. It pretty much summed up in one sentence why I enjoy trading so much. The sentence was "Trading is one of the only professions that punishes you for non-performance". It also rewards you instantly for good performance. There are many jobs in this world where you can skate by and do mediocre work and get away with it. But in trading there is no place to hide. Your P/L will tell you immediately if you have done good or bad. What other career can give you that instantaneous feedback?
Most of these traders paper-trade to ensure their systems work. One trader will triple his paper account before trying the system live. That's dedication to your craft. I have found that I cannot paper-trade too long, maybe I am impatient? That's one reason I like Forex because I can trade very small amounts and actually use real money to do a pseudo-paper-trade. The amount of risk is very tiny, but psychologically I am more focused because I understand its actual money on the line. Then once I have achieved a long enough test sample the only change I have to make is the trade size.
If you trade or are planning on starting, I highly recommend this book. I think there is knowledge here for everyone, no matter what your skill level is.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|