From School Library Journal
Grade 4-6?A dozen connected episodes, this first novel tells of a year in the life of 11-year-old orphan Milly Moore of Bentwood, MA. She lives in the funeral-parlor home of easy-going Uncle Edgar and bossy, opinionated Aunt Gloria. The book opens with Aunt Gloria's viewing following her fatal heart attack. Milly continues to hear her aunt's helpful advice as a sort of conscience, until a new viewing more to the woman's liking finally puts her spirit to rest a year later. Meanwhile, Milly's new friend uses a Weirdness Index ("A scale of one to ten. Ten is the most weird") to rate the people she meets. Many of Bentwood's residents, including Milly's grandmother who preaches religion to bikers from her Harley-Davidson, rank close to ten. The book is vaguely reminiscent of Sherwood Anderson's Winesburg, Ohio (Viking, 1987), as each chapter unveils another quirky town character. What Milly learns in the year's span is that peculiarity is often in the eye of the beholder. This awareness of each person's individuality helps the girl to understand and accept herself, and makes her able to put Aunt Gloria and her advice to rest. The somewhat heavy-handed delivery of the theme is balanced by Milly's delightful, humorous voice.?Connie Tyrrell Burns, Mahoney Middle School, South Portland, ME
Copyright 1998 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Gr. 4^-6. Milly, an orphan who lives with her uncle, the undertaker, hasn't had much luck making friends in Bentwood. To make matters worse, since she's been in town, her aunt has died. And to make matters much worse, Milly still hears Aunt Gloria giving her "helpful advice," even though her aunt's gone. But Milly's luck with friends takes a turn for the better when she meets Josie at a writing class. Together, they have a Halloween party in the mortuary for the class rejects, help a ghost find peace, and make a video starring a horse about the size of a big dog. As the subtitle implies, the book is trying for an outrageous and comic tone. It succeeds much of the time, but in other instances, Lindsay, in her debut, tries too hard--and the advice-giving Aunt Gloria virtually disappears for most of the book. Still, the book's cover will draw readers in, and once there, they will find at least some of the promised laughs.
Ilene Cooper