Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
"A Merrybegot...a child sacred to nature.", August 17, 2005
This review is from: The Minister's Daughter (Aesop Accolades (Awards)) (Hardcover)
Early in 17th century England, the country is beset by civil war, the old religion at odds with the Puritanism that is sweeping the land. The old ways smack of superstition and an untoward reverence for pagan feasts and celebrations. The Puritans want none of the trappings of such a religion, sure that Satan has a hand in excessive merrymaking and frolicking on Sundays. In one small village Nell, the village cunning woman's granddaughter and Grace, the minister's daughter, are about to act out the scourge that will spread throughout the country, an accusation of witchcraft that sets off a firestorm of hangings of the accused.
Grace is carefully observed by her strict Puritan father, but she is young and headstrong, running off with a young man on the first day of May, the birthday reserved for Merrybegots, children that are sacred to nature. Grace views the consequences of her actions as impossible, begging the plain Nell for help. As the village cunning woman's protégé, Nell is trained in the healing arts, learning all she can before the old woman's mind shatters completely. Nell herself is a Merrybegot, born from the May Day celebrations. She informs Grace that she cannot help her and a feud is born, one in which Grace holds all the power in a class-conscious society. Desperate to avoid her father's ire, Grace begins throwing fits to avoid anyone learning her secret, drawing her less-attractive sister, Patience, into the infernal chaos that develops. Over time, to avoid the reality of her impulsive judgment come to fruition, Grace accuses Nell of witchcraft. And who will doubt a minister's daughter?
The author cleverly weaves history, fiction and magic into an engrossing tale of witchcraft, Puritanism, superstition and the unnamable fears of an ignorant public who believe in God and magic spells in the same measure, Nell symbolizing everything female and uncontrollable in a patriarchal belief system. This fiction is a perfect introduction to a fascinating period in English history, where both God and Satan walk the streets, larger than life, more powerful than incantations. In the throes of hysteria, a small village turns on one of their own, suddenly mistrustful and superstitious, looking to the minister's daughter for answers. Those provided, though quenching the villagers' thirst for blame, only serve to ignite a conflagration that will leap from across continents, settled finally in Salem, in the New World. Luan Gaines/2005.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A story that is both historically resonant and genuinely magical, June 28, 2005
This review is from: The Minister's Daughter (Aesop Accolades (Awards)) (Hardcover)
In the year 1645, England was torn in two, caught between the warring factions of the Royalists and the Parliamentarians. The people, particularly those who still lived in rural areas, were also torn between the old ways (those of pagan ritual and superstition) and the new ways (those of rationality, order, and a particularly austere form of Christianity). Julie Hearn's tremendous new novel, THE MINISTER'S DAUGHTER, vividly embodies these conflicts in the deeply personal story of two young women from opposite sides of the divide.
Nell is the granddaughter of the local cunning woman. Nell herself is a Merrybegot, a child conceived on Mayday, one of the most magical festivals of the year. Part healer, part midwife, part wise woman, Nell's grandmother feels the change in the air and, fearing for her own sanity as well as for her ability to continue practicing her arts in the changing political and religious environment, eagerly apprentices Nell to her craft. Soon enough, Nell is ministering not only to laboring human women and to flatulent men but also to piskies and other magical creatures, one of whom recognizes her as a chosen Merrybegot and rewards her with a gift more precious than anything she could have imagined.
Grace, on the other hand, is the older daughter of the village's Puritan minister. Virtuous, devout and submissive, Grace is nothing like wild, bold Nell. Smitten with a handsome local boy, Grace soon finds herself pregnant with her own Merrybegot. Desperate to hide her pregnancy from her authoritarian father, she convinces her naïve younger sister Patience that her condition is the result of witchcraft practiced by Nell and her grandmother. Soon the villagers, torn between loyalty to the past and fear of the unknown, don't know whom to trust.
In THE MINISTER'S DAUGHTER, Julie Hearn masterfully condenses so many of the vast political and religious conflicts of the day into what seems on the surface to be a very small story about one girl's unwanted pregnancy and its unforeseen consequences. At the same time, she manages to craft a tale that is both historically resonant and genuinely magical, peopled as it is with real-life historical characters such as Charles II as well as by piskies (pixies). These magical creatures are not just your average diaphanous fairies, though; like much of the magic in the novel, their influences are far-reaching and, although they provide comic elements, their concerns are great. Nell herself acknowledges the power of the supernatural the first time she attempts to perform significant magic after her grandmother's death: "This is a trip of the most terrifying kind, so weird yet so utterly believable that to suffer it is to know yourself at the mercy of whatever devils your mind cares to spit in your face."
The narrative structure of the book also contributes to its effectiveness. The bulk of the novel is narrated in a third-person present tense voice set in 1645 but carrying an oddly prescient tone, often prophesying events that will happen to minor characters months or even years in the future. Interjected with these chapters, though, is the voice of Grace's younger sister Patience. In 1692 Salem, Massachusetts, Patience narrates the events of 1645 through the lens of the Salem witch trials and her own tragic miscomprehension of those earlier days, in a tone that grows increasingly hateful until it reaches the chilling climax.
THE MINISTER'S DAUGHTER is Julie Hearn's first novel to be published in the United States. If this superb tale is any indication of her talents, readers soon will be clamoring to read much more from this accomplished writer.
--- Reviewed by Norah Piehl
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
I had absolutely no idea this was YA fiction! Terrific work., March 26, 2006
This review is from: The Minister's Daughter (Aesop Accolades (Awards)) (Hardcover)
I read a lot of YA fiction, but when I picked this one up, I didn't notice that it was a "teen read," and there is no reason for it to have an age-limited audience.
Hearn's novel (her first to be published in the United States) can be viewed as a prelude to the well-known witch hysteria of colonial Salem, MA. The Minister's Daughter is set in 1645 England, during the English Civil War. When the minister's daughters start speaking in tongues and spitting pins, all while the elder daughter's belly grows suspiciously larger, suspicion falls on the village healers. The healers, or cunning women, are a grandmother and her granddaughter, Nell, who fix herbal remedies for the village in exchange for donations of food and supplies.
The story of the countryside witch hysteria is told from both the healer girl Nell's point of view and from a retrospective confessional by the younger of the minister's daughters. Nell's world is filled with miniature troublemakers/watchers in the form of piskies, as well as interactions with faeries. She is desperately trying to learn the spells and potions of her grandmother as the elderly lady's mental agility starts to decline. The minister's younger daughter, Patience, is naive in the ways of the world and often deemed slow by the villagers. Patience doesn't fully catch on to the strange ministrations going on in her own house until it is much too late.
Hearn's novel closes with an informative author's note and suggested reading about the reality of the English royalty, the famed witch hunter Matthew Hopkins, the folklore of the English countryside, and the hysteria of the time. Prepare to be transported several centuries back, to a magical and mad place, by this touching novel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|