Customer Reviews

Minyan: Ten Principles for Living a Life of Integrity

5 star:		(4)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

This is an extremely interesting meditation on by a man who is passionately committed to living a life which is both solidly grounded in Jewish thought and tradition, and at the same time approaches the transcendent through mysticism. Fortunately, Judaism has had threads of mystical tradition for centuries, and this book provides detailed instructions on how to incorporate these techniques into your life.

However, this is not primarily a how-to book, but rather is the nearly poetic expression of deep comtemplation and experience of an encounter with the transcendent through the medium of Jewish prayer, ethics and ritual.

The prose clearly reflects the passion Rabbi Shapiro brings to his subject, so the book is an appealing reading experience. It is also a book which nearly cries out for rereading and serious thought. You do not have to be Jewish, or agree with everything the author says in order to find great value in this book. If nothing else, it is a case study in making traditional religion meaningful for contemporary people.

Shapiro is a Jewish liberal Rabbi and an award winning poet/essayist...Shapiro holds to the belief that anyone can become spiritually enlightened and in order to assist an individual to reach this goal he has developed a ten-fold method called Minyan. But his is not the traditonal Minyan from Rabbinic law, a quorum of ten Jews, the minimum necessary for the performance of any religious service. His Minyan refers to the practice of meditation, repetition, inspirational reading, attention, generosity, kindness, dream interpretation, ethical consumption, self-perfection, and Sabbath. The maim of Minyuan is to attain d'vekut, oneness with God, seeing both Being and Emptiness as expressions of God, of becomming conscious of both the relative and the absolute. The key to spiritual awakening is "Chabad," the temporary annihilation of your sense of separateness.

Although Shapiro's method hinges on the esoteric and breaks away from conventional Jewish thought, the underlying value of his message is one of universal application, with no embedded dogmatism, a source of inspiration for people of all faiths.

Rabbi Rami Shapiro is one of the most informed and responsible liberal-Jewish rabbis writing today. He is always worth a read, and this book is no exception even though I disagree with large portions of it.

His opening chapters in particular are excellent; he presents what he calls "The Teaching" (a carefully nuanced version of quasi-Hasidic panentheism) succinctly and intelligibly. From there, he builds to a list of ten practices adapted from Jewish tradition and designed to increase one's awareness of Rabbi Shapiro's panentheistic G-d.

I won't detail my agreements and disagreements here; let it suffice to say that I have some significant ones of each (particularly regarding what I see as important errors in the ethical and economic foundations of "eco-kashrut"). But Rabbi Shapiro's graceful prose and thoughtful ruminations will provoke you to explorations of your own whether you end up agreeing with him or not. What Rabbi Shapiro is clearly _most_ concerned about is that Jews care about being Jews. His stimulating work will undoubtedly promote that aim.

I'm not Jewish, but my wife is, and she suggested that I read this book. I must say that I am glad she did. What pleased me the most about "Minyan" was the way that Rami focused on spiritual principles and not dogma. I personally feel that there are spiritual truths that are manifest in all beliefs, and any book that shows how to incorporate those principles into daily life is a book that I find rewarding. This book is not only well written, but it offers practical suggestions for individuals seeking to foster spiritual development in their lives, regardless of religious affiliation.

The beginning of this book is a wide-ranging thought-provoking philosophical discussin. The really interesting part for me was the ten principles section, which suggests daily actions to realize spiritual goals. This book has the best plain English description of tzedakah I have ever read. It does come off at times a bit cultish, but overall a very good book.

Rabbi Rami's flowing and easily readable style gives a succint and easy to understand explanation of a mystical theology that is applicable to all. He challenges us to accept responsibilty for our lives and, in doing so, to gain direct access to our spiritual selves. His suggestions make sense and can be implemented in small steps. The translations of sacred texts are exceptionally beautiful and inspirational. I recommend this book to all seekers-- especially those who are looking for a Jewish perspective that would be tolerated and welcomed in eccumenical circles. Although the forms are Jewish, the message is universal.

Rabbi Rami Shapiro's Minyan is a well written account of how to practice "non-dual" Judaism. This idea is that God is "not something or someone living somewhere out there in time and space... God is the One who manifests as all things in time and space. God is not something you pray to, but rather the greater reality to which you awake."

Shapiro's book is quite specific about the pathway that may be right for the seeker of this type of Jewish mystical and philosophical view, life and practice. There is a mix of practical suggestions and theological speculation that compliment each other well. The book is deeply Jewish and concentrates on a type of non-kabbalistic mysticism we find in Abraham Abulafia as well as a healthy dose of Chabad inspired thought. There is an emphasis on meditation, practice and community commitment.

Minyan is a excellent guide book for anyone seeking to find a new pathway in Judaism that respects the old; as well as anyone who seeks the old in the garb of the new.

This book presents views of core elements of Judasim (e.g. mitzvoth, kashrut) from the perspective of today's knowledge, adding new life & meaning to them for enlightened individuals, and proceeds to offer suggestions on how to incorporate these consciously into our daily lives.