From Publishers Weekly
Erlbruch's (
The Big Question) bumbling, earnest young bear wakes up from hibernation with a single thought on his mind: fatherhood (that is, after he eats). He lounges casually among the birches, "thinking happily about how he might become a big strong papa bear." But then he realizes that he doesn't know how, and turns in a flash from a competent, devil-may-care prospective father into a dope. "Can somebody tell me how one goes about having a bear cub?" he yells into the forest (a hunter lurks nearby). He finds explanations offered by other animals to be cryptic. The magpie says, "You lay an egg, and you brood it," but of course the bear can't, although he tries, squatting and looking expectantly at his rear. The stork is no help, either. This humorous lead-up gives every sign that the narrative will reveal exactly what it is that papa and mama bears do to make cubs, but Erlbruch retreats at the final moment. A "pretty girl bear" appears and takes the bear off to "a soft place in a glade, in the middle of some long, some very long, grass," and... the book ends right there. Comedy works best if the reader knows something the hero doesn't, and children who don't know how little bears are made may well remain mystified. But the bear's too-big waistline, fuzzy brown coat and long snout seem remarkably human, and older readers in search of a little romance will be charmed. All ages.
(Nov.) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 2–Tongue-in-cheek and filled with innuendo, Erlbruch's story parodies the euphemistic approach to the age-old question of where babies come from. In the springtime, awaking from hibernation, a young bear's fancy turns to…fatherhood. The lumpy, congenial creature has a problem, though. …he just couldn't figure out what you have to do to become a papa bear. Various animals tease him: Babies, my dear, grow in turnip fields; You spread some sugar on the windowsill and wait for the stork. Some children will jeer at all of this. Others, however, will be left in the dark by the vague, suggestive conclusion. The bear remembers a story his mother often told him about a miracle cloud where bear cubs play before coming into the world. Suddenly a pretty female enters the picture, and in a seductive conversation promises, If you give me your hand, next spring we could have some marvelous bear cubs. And so, they went to look for a soft place in the middle of some long, some very long, grass. Aw-shucks. Erlbruch's cartoon drawings of the affable bear and other animal denizens are quite comical and there are some funny lines. Libraries would have to figure out the most likely audience for this goofy romance.
–Margaret Bush, Simmons College, Boston Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
