Customer Reviews

The Miracle of the First Poinsettia

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I like this book because of the main character, Juanita. She is very brave because even though she thinks all the people would stare at her because she is bringing weeds to the baby Jesus she goes into the church. Another reason I like the story is when she goes into the church the weeds turn into flowers and this is a great surprise.

While I have this 'companion' book to the Miracle of the Poinsettia by Brian Cavanaugh (published 2001), I find the Oppenheim Spanish translation rather stilted and far more difficult, even for the very fluent young child to follow. Also, the illustrations are dark and a bit gloomy in comparison to the luminous and richly colorful images of Cavanaugh's version. I have given several of these books as gifts -- with a lukewarm response. Whereas the Cavanugh book has been received by many many friends, teachers and co-workers with a sense of awe for the illustrations, story and mystery it excudes. I would urge a reading of both versions. See for yourselves!

A really different Christmas book. It is the retelling of an old story in picture book form. This would go along well with learning about how Christmas is celebrated in Mexico. It is a great story too. It also opens up a chance to talk about gift giving and the importance of keeping perspective. I would recommend it for all ages.