79 of 81 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating milieu and characters, but too slow, June 11, 2004
In early sixteenth century Italy, seven-year-old Bianca de Nevada lives happily with her widowed father. But when a caravan arrives at her home in Montefiore, bearing the famous Cesare and Lucrezia Borgia, her life is turned upside down. Her father sent away, Bianca is left in the hands of Lucrezia, who plans the girl's murder. Escaping into the woods, Bianca soon discovers a group of seven magical dwarfs...
I am rather of two minds with this book. On the one hand, the author does an excellent job of retelling the story of Snow White, placing it in Renaissance Italy, peopled with fascinating characters. On the other hand, the story starts out slow, and never seems to pick up the pace. Indeed, the story seems to drag along from start to end as if the author had a great idea for a story, but couldn't think up all of the details it needed. He obviously knows a great deal about Renaissance Italy, but he cannot combine the two elements of his story into the really fascinating story that it should be.
Overall, I found the book to be good, at times even very good, but it is not the great story it should be. I give it a guarded recommendation.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
72 of 74 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
What A Strange Dream, June 22, 2005
What I admire about the Gregory Maguire books I've read so far is his subtle way of entwining the fantastic with the mundane in such a way that it is completely believable. His books are strange dreams in which stags can be gondoliers and rocks can speak and walk.
I read two of Maguire's books before attempting Mirror, Mirror, and it took two aborted attempts at this book in question before I got past the first few chapters of laborious, slow description of Montefiore and Vicente de Nevada's behaviour. Twice, in disgust, I closed Mirror, Mirror and vowed never to return to its grindingly slow narrative. Snow White was one of my least favorite fairy tales, anyway.
Over the weekend, I decided I'd give this book another shot. It's not a thick, cumbersome book, and the illustrations are pretty, and I remembered that although I was hooked on Wicked from the first word, it took some real effort on my part to become engaged in Confessions of an Ugly Stepsister. So I ground my way through the description of Montefiore and Bianca and Vicente and the two most prominent players in the supporting cast of crazies, Primavera Vecchia and Fra Ludovico. This time I found the descriptions less cumbersome and full of things to look at, especially with Primavera Vecchia, whose first name means "spring" and her last name means "old" and she herself is older than dirt. She is larger than life and at the same time completely human, approachable.
Before I knew it, Maguire and his band of characters had me hooked. The Borgias showed up, bringing with them danger so real it could be tasted. I worried for the population of Montefiore. I forgot I was reading a Snow White tale, and was surprised by the hunter in the woods, the strange stone beasts, the sacred poisoned apple. I was surprised to find myself at the end, because it is not a typical fairy tale ending with chirping birds and singing, dancing dwarves.
I recommend this book to anyone who wants to be told a story. Gregory Maguire is a consummate storyteller. One moment the storyteller is like a camera, reporting the comings and goings of Montefiore and its tenants. The next, the storyteller is Bianca, old Primavera, Fra Ludovico, dangerous Lucrezia, a stone beast, and idiot gooseboy. The sliding consciousness would be confusing if Maguire weren't such a master of giving each character his or her own distinct syntax, mood, voice, and posture within the narrative.
This story is worth the time it takes to let it unfold.The three-hundred pages did not even last me the weekend. So once the first few chapters are read, the story picks up and takes off. It's up to you to let it take you with it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
33 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wonderful, October 15, 2003
By A Customer
Gregory is back and it is wonderful!!! It had to be after that awful dribble LOST came out 2 years ago. I bought this book yesterday (I still had faith in GM) and I could put it down until I finished it. It held me in thrall and I just couldn't read it fast enough.The only complaint..it wasn't long enough!!! I don't want to give any of it away but this Snow White is no Disney cartoon. And man oh man these dwarfs are very strange and there's one extra one that we never knew about(?!). Get this book and have a wonderful time reading it. Gregory is back and its so good to have him back writing something great once again!!!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No