Customer Reviews

Misguided Roses

5 star:		(49)
4 star:		(13)
3 star:		(6)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

I only came across this CD because I remembered a line from "I'll Be" and wanted to find out what song it was from. When I came across Edwin McCain, the first thing that popped into my mind was, "Who is he?" I had never heard of him before. However, after listening to some of the samples listed on Amazon and reading a couple reviews, I went ahead and bought "Misguided Roses." Let me tell you, it's not something I've regretted. Being a woodwind player of flute, alto and soprano saxophone and recently clarinet, I am very interested in the instrumentation that Edwin McCain uses in his songs. "I'll Be" has an interesting saxophone melody (which you most likely would not have noticed on the radio). In addition, "Darwin's Children" (a song that you will completely fall in love with if you are a fan of "I'll Be") uses baritone saxophone as a main feature of the song. The woodwind voice adds a certain quality to the music that you won't get in other rock bands. "Misguided Roses" is a CD that is good for long car drives, or anywhere, for that matter. When you're listening to Edwin McCain, there's no need to keep on skipping tracks - this CD is good the whole way through. And unlike some muisician[s] ..., Edwin McCain wrote all of the songs on the CD himself, adding a certain respect to his work. "Misguided Roses" is a CD that everyone should have! I definitely reccomend it. Like me, you wont regret buying it.

I was appalled when I read some of the reviews of this incredible album. Most people bought it because of the song "I'll Be" but didn't like the rest of the album. Why not? Because EVERY song on the album has a different taste? Because EVERY song has a new and captivating flavor? I bought this album when I thirteen and it was exactly what I needed to get me through the year. He says all the right things, but it's more subliminal than straight-forward. Edwin McCain's music is a lot like poetry and his songs make you think, which I cannot say for many other performers out there. Not only does this album give hope and inspiration into the world, but it's a great listen while driving, jogging, or just relaxing. There's a song on here to fit every mood you could possibly be in. So when I say "more like 500 stars," I mean more like 500 stars!

I had never heard of Edwin McCain until I heard the song "I'll Be" on the radio a little while ago. I fell in love with it and would sing it throughout the day. Still though, I didn't know who was the brilliant singer. It wasn't until I saw the soundtrack for "A Cinderella Story" that I finally found out who sang this! I HAD to have the CD! I must say, although my favorite song is still probably "I'll Be", I love all of the songs on this CD. (Now I have more songs to sing throughout the day!!) Each song is different--and beautiful--in its own way. If you like "I'll Be", I'm sure you'll like the CD!

Edwin McCain stepped up the acoustic rock formula for his "Misguided Roses" album, provide a soul-filled album that stands out. His songs are more than just lyrics, but are more stories set to music. The band provides a great vehicle to carry the songs. With Larry Chaney playing lead, Dave Harrison on drums, Craig Shields picking up everything else from horns to keyboards, and Scott Bannevich on the bottom provide the upbeat music on this release.

The album begins in a great groove with "See the Sky Again" with a great opening riff from Chaney shortly followed by McCain's gruff voice. Chaney and McCain play off of each other well with vocals and guitar, and acoustic and electric guitars, building to a powerful end. Another great tune is "Cleveland Park" a much more laid back song relying on arpeggio chords from the acoustic guitar double with a strummed rhythm. "I'll Be" is the ballad of the album, and McCain croons well. "How Strange It Seems" has a good baseline from Bannevich, and a bluesy feel from Chaney. The same formula works again on "Darwin's Children", but I like McCain's voice better here, plus there's a good sax work from Shields here as well. Add in the cover of James Taylor's "(I've Got to) Stop Thinkin' `Bout That" and you have a pretty good album here.

McCain and crew have a lot of talent, and lay down some great music. I think McCain is one of the better bands in this genre of music, and they are fun to listen to. Definitely worth the price of the disk, and worth a listen.

I only came across this CD because I remembered a line from "I'll Be" and wanted to find out what song it was from. When I came across Edwin McCain, the first thing that popped into my mind was, "Who is he?" I had never heard of him before. However, after listening to some of the samples listed on Amazon and reading a couple reviews, I went ahead and bought "Misguided Roses." Let me tell you, it's not something I've regretted. Being a woodwind player of flute, alto and soprano saxophone and recently clarinet, I am very interested in the instrumentation that Edwin McCain uses in his songs. "I'll Be" has an interesting saxophone melody (which you most likely would not have noticed on the radio). In addition, "Darwin's Children" (a song that you will completely fall in love with if you are a fan of "I'll Be") uses baritone saxophone as a main feature of the song. The woodwind voice adds a certain quality to the music that you won't get in other rock bands. "Misguided Roses" is a CD that is good for long car drives, or anywhere, for that matter. When you're listening to Edwin McCain, there's no need to keep on skipping tracks - this CD is good the whole way through. And unlike some muisician wannabes, Edwin McCain wrote all of the songs on the CD himself, adding a certain respect to his work. "Misguided Roses" is a CD that everyone should have! I definitely reccomend it. Like me, you wont regret buying it.

I can't believe I had never heard of this band before "I'll Be" hit the radio waves. Edwin McCain is incredibly talented both musically and vocally. Misguided Roses includes a wonderful blend of acoustic/electric guitar and saxophone to create a very unique sound. Edwin's voice is unlike anyone else's I've ever heard...strong and soulful with a raspy, breathy edge that makes you feel like he's giving you a piece of his heart with every note he sings. Other songs that should be released as singles include "See the Sky Again", "Cleveland Park" and "Darwin's Children". You must buy this CD. It's worth every penny!

One of the best cd I have ever bought a must have for any music fan Edwin McCain is a wealth of talent on both the writing and performing sides of his career.His music is a refreshing change to the everyday radio.Best songs are How strange it seems and Darwins children.BUY THIS CD!!!!!!!!

It is refreshing to hear music that does not sound generic or regurgitated. Great songwriting and arranging. "I'll Be." has to be one of the greatest hook up songs that I have ever heard. It puts the Backstreet Boys to shame. You have to give respect to a band that has been touring for the last nine years,& plays constantly, roughly about 300 nights a year.

"Misguided Roses" is a wonderful mix of music. If you don't already like Jazz, Rock, Blues, and Gospel, Edwin and his band will turn you into a fan. "Misguided Roses" is a CD that you can listen to all the way through, so if you think that "I'll Be" is the only good song on "Misguided Roses," you're wrong...Edwin's best songs are never played on the radio. If you liked "Honor Among Thieves," you'll love "Misguided Roses." And if you're a new fan, I would recommend both CD's, because you haven't heard music until you've heard Edwin McCain!

Edwin McCain is a great songwriter, and he has the voice and the band to back it up.

One of my favorite lines from any of his songs is from "I'll Be":

"The strands in your eyes that color them wonderful stop me and steal my breath. Like emeralds from mountains, thrust towards the sky, never revealing their depths."

Edwin McCain is a very underappreciated artist. I don't understand why he isn't more popular. Maybe he is too hard to pigeonhole. He's not just folk. He's not just blues. He's not just soul. He's not just rock. He's not just pop. He's all of these things in a perfect blend. Whatever you want to call him, he's worth a listen if you like mature music with a cohesive range of styles and moods.

If you like this album, I would also highly recommend his album "Honor Among Thieves".