Most Helpful Customer Reviews
25 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Heavy Trip, April 20, 2003
First published in 1953, this book was the progenitor of the modern 'hard' SF sub-genre. Using only the known science of the day, it imagined a world so wildly different from our everyday experience that it dazzles the mind, showing just how wild the universe really can be. The world is Mesklin, a very large planet that rotates on its axis in just eighteen minutes, leading to gravitational forces of 700 gravities at the poles, and just 3 gees at the equator. But this is just the first of the items that make the world unique: its average temperature is a toasty -160 degrees Celsius; a methane/ammonia atmospheric composition that at these temperatures act much like water on Earth - phasing between solid, liquid, and gaseous forms; a wildly ecliptic orbit and planetary axial tilt that has strange consequences for the weather. Now add an intelligent native life form that is fifteen inches long and just three inches tall, looking very much like an overgrown millipede with pinchers, an Earth probe stranded at one of the poles that Terran scientists would very much like to retrieve for the data it contains about high gravity environments, and you have the ingredients for a great scientific adventure story. Clement, a high school science teacher for much of his life, writes very much in the mold of a much earlier SF writer, Jules Verne. As such, the emphasis is on the science, the puzzles and oddities extreme conditions can present, rather than on character or thematic messages. Every detail of this world was very carefully worked out, right down to why the native inhabitants would 'see' their world as a hollow flattened bowl, complete with accurate maps, and would reject almost out of hand the idea that the surface they could see was really the outside of a sphere. In fact, a good bit of the charm of this book is the portrayed alien mind-set, showing just how much environment shapes the way people look at things. This also applies to the Earth scientists, who have great trouble at times seeing how the extreme conditions lead to important technological conclusions, such as why a canoe is not a viable shape for an ocean-going vessel at super-high gravities. The plot is pretty much a series of adventures occasioned by various scientific oddities as the Mesklinite party travels across the world from equator to pole in search of the Earthling's probe, with little in the way of character development or any deeper meanings. There is some severe dating of some of the technology used: slide rules, film recordings, environmental suit mechanical linkages, etc. There is one item here that was quite a bit ahead of its time - the use of a water bed as a method for staying in high-gee environments for extended periods of time (but was Clement aware of Heinlein's description of the water bed in Beyond This Horizon, written in 1941?). But the dating does not seriously detract from the main focus of the novel, which is Mesklin itself, just as timelessly incredible as the day this first saw print. Recommended for those who enjoy the scientific puzzle, those who still see the universe as an incredibly varied, complex, and beautiful composition, where scientific fact really is much stranger than fiction. --- Reviewed by Patrick Shepherd (hyperpat)
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An enjoyable read with a sense of wonder, September 14, 2001
PROS: Plausible science, truly interesting world CONS: Writing style is a bit stiff BOTTOM LINE: Enjoyable, classic, hard sci-fi. BRIEF SYNOPSIS: Humans enlist the aid of natives to retrieve a lost space probe on the high-gravity world of Mesklin. The real appeal of MOG is the planet Mesklin. Clement, who has a scientific background, builds an interesting and believable M&M-shaped world where gravity varies from 3g at the "Rim" (equator) up to 700g at the poles. The native Mesklinites, foot-long caterpillar-like creatures with pincers, are equally interesting as they deal with parts of their planet that have been previously unexplored. The story really conveys a sense of wonder. Don't be put off or misled by the "juvenile" label put on this book by others; it's not one. Clement wrote one juvenile novel as far as I can tell after research - Ranger Boys in Space. Even so, what would be wrong if it was a juvenile? Many of Heinlein's best-loved works were marketed as juvenile novels (for example, Starship Troopers). Just read it and enjoy! Overall, this hard SF novel was an enjoyable read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Meet the crew of the Bree., May 5, 2004
The Bree is a fine ship, crewed by brave, if slightly greedy natives of the planet of Mesklin. They must explore uncharted waters, trade with dangerous tribes and deal with strange events. And they're only fifteen-inch caterpillars! The Captain, the brave and greedy, Barlennan has promised to help the humans, aliens of enormous size, to find a rocket they lost on the planet. The rocket is full of equipment which was to run tests and then return to orbit. The problem was that the rocket, designed to handle the high gravity, couldn't handle the gravity. The humans are willing to do anything to get it back. And in the end, they just might. A great ending. GREAT book. I love the hard science, the cool alien race, the bonus article- "Whirligig World" - in which Hal Clement tells us how he came up with the amazing, fantastic planet and the life that lived on it. Lots of humor. Funny Note: I just reviewed the book, The Jupiter Theft, a few days ago. In it the aliens are from the system of Cygnus. That's the same binary system Mr. Clement was thinking about when he started to design the planet of Mesklin. He did such a good job that the Mesklinites are in Barlowe's Guide To Extraterrestrials, Aliens And Alien Societies edited by Ben Bova, and Clifford Pickover's The Science Of Aliens.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
