15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The long wait is over..., September 19, 2006
This review is from: Modern Physical Organic Chemistry (Hardcover)
Phys. Org. Chem. has always been one of my favorite subjects. As I continued to study chemistry during high school, college and grad school, I began to realise that phys org chem represents not so much a separate field as a philosophy and approach; to treat chemical and biological systems from the perspective of structure, conformation, and reactivity which are after all the most fundamental aspects of any such system. I realized that phys org chem is a truly interdisciplinary framework, and any one who has a solid background in it can be a good computational chemist, synthetic organic chemist, and/or bioorganic/biochemist.
Unfortunately, all the classic phys org books until now have been of the 'pure' kind, focusing on mechanism and reactivity, but not discussing the interdisciplinary nature of the topic, especially for biological systems and materials. The wait is over: Modern Physical Organic Chemistry by Dennis Dougherty and Eric Anslyn has completely and satisfactorily reinvented the phys org chem textbook. Now one can look to a wholesome treatment of phys org as a multidisciplinary, fundamental, and exciting approach to both chemistry and biology. The book is worth its price, and covers the gamut of topics, including basic ones like mechanisms and bonding, but also is interspersed with lots of boxes and discussions explaining the applications of basic phys org concepts to host guest systems, proteins and nucleic acids, strained molecules, and materials science. Fantastic reference. It should make you a well-rounded chemist, which is a requirement in today's era of interdisciplinary and collaborative research.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Modern Physical Organic Chemistry, October 3, 2005
This review is from: Modern Physical Organic Chemistry (Hardcover)
The book by Anslyn and Daugherty is terrific! I recommend it enthusiastically. It fills a large void in the modern day curriculum, and does so brilliantly. I am grateful to the authors for having done so.
Impressively, the text is sophisticated yet readable, both for those of us who have
studied organic chemistry for many years, and most importantly, for students. I've
spoken with a number of students who echo this sentiment. Furthermore, the text is
thoroughly enjoyable to read and is full of wonderful insights. There are very few
chemistry books I've read where I was anxious to see what was coming next. Anslyn and Dougherty's book is one of them.
It is clear that the authors have taken a great deal of care to express their thoughts
carefully, clearly, and concisely. In addition, they have expertly communicated the
interconnections between physical organic chemistry and all other phases of chemistry, including bioorganic and materials chemistry, and have shown that the tools of the physical organic chemist permeate each of the contemporary sub-disciplines.
The publishers, too, are to be congratulated for taking the time and exercising the
care needed to put together a beautifully formatted rendering of the ideas expressed by the authors. In addition, the binding is strong, well constructed, and gives every indication that it will hold up over many years of repeated use.
"Modern Physical Organic Chemistry" is an important and prized addition to my library. I am certain that it will find its place as one of the most important books in the field that has ever been written. Enjoy!
Dan Little
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finally, no more "Lousy and Ridiculous" for chemistry graduate students, January 22, 2006
This review is from: Modern Physical Organic Chemistry (Hardcover)
As a recent grad of an org chem graduate program who had to suffer through the nearly 20 year old text "Mechanism and Theory in Organic Chemistry" by Lowry and Richardson, this book by Anslyn and Dougherty is a fabulous update that is easy to read and great asset to any chemistry student. I agree with the other reviewers that the problem sets are challenging, the text is clearly written, and the material relates well back to current research issues. If you are a graduate student considering getting another reference to help you through your organic chemistry graduate program, get this book before you try "Advanced Organic Chemistry: Structure and Mechanisms" by Carey and Sundberg. I expect that "Modern Physcial Organic Chemistry" will become a staple to most chemist's shelves similar to that of a CRC Handbook or "Advanced Organic Chemistry" by March.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No