Customer Reviews

A Modern Reader's Guide to Dante's the Divine Comedy

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

For the reader tackling Dante for the very first time, this might be the best book currently available. Though targeted at first time readers, this can also be helpful for those who need to review all the seemingly endless names the permeated the COMEDY on a second reading. There are three primary reasons that I so strongly recommend Gallagher's guide. First, it is geared to make Dante as accessible as possible without in any way trivializing or tritely popularizing the text. Second, for Gallagher reading Dante is not merely a question of spiritual devotion or literary adoration, but flat out fun. Reading Dante is and ought to be recognized as above all else flat out fun. Gallagher's enthusiasm and enjoyment of Dante pours out at every point. Third, although not geared to scholars, the book nonetheless was obviously written with an exceptional knowledge of the scholarly studies of the work, which is to say: the book is academically quite solid.

The book is arranged both simply and logically. First, after a foreword recommending the work by the most recent dean of Dante studies in the United States, John Freccero, and a preface by the author himself, Gallagher starts off with a series of questions that he anticipates any novice reader might have in approaching the text for the first time. By eliminating the connecting narrative and structure that this information would need if presented in essay form, Gallagher is able to compress a significant amount of helpful information in a very small amount of space. He then proceeds to provide a canto-by-canto commentary for each part of the COMEDY. He first discusses the action of each canto, and then makes a series of random comments on various aspects of the canto. The book concludes with a brief but helpful discussion of Dante's other surviving works and a bibliography.

For anyone wanting to read Dante for the first time, I recommend Gallagher's reader's guide above all other beginner's tools. Dante is not, as is often supposed, an especially difficult writer (with the caveat that there is much in Dante that remains impenetrable or mysterious for even lifelong scholars), but there are many mistakes that one starting off in Dante can easily make that can complicate reading him. There is also a confusing array of political characters, and while this in the long run is less of a problem than a beginner might imagine, Gallagher will serve as a reliable guide who will help the neophyte avoid many hazards and will point out many of the glories of Dante's great work.

Joseph Gallagher, a retired Catholic priest and professor, who has taught at such venerable institutions as John Hopkins, Notre Dame, Loyola, and Oxford presents on an easy-to-understand guide through the intricacies of Dante's imaginative work. Written in a conversational style that anyone can understand, this expert tutor of many students for over 50 years explains each of the characters canto by canto. The outline at the beginning is a great help. While it is not as analytical as that of Erich Auerbach's "Mimesis", this book is a valuable addition. It should prove indispensable for those who need a companion guide; the homeschooler's library should contain this erudite explanation.

I picked up a copy based on the reviews, but I was shocked by what I found. This is a summary of the various cantos and nothing more.

If you need something to cram for a test and you haven't read the assigned cantos yet, then this may be for you.

On the other hand, if you're in need of a serious introduction (not to mention some kind of knowledgeable annotation), then go to a book with footnotes (Hollander, Singleton, Durling, Musa).

A few years ago I read the prose translation of the Divine Comedy by John D. Sinclair. From the Inferno onward, I became both immersed and bewildered by the allusions, allegories and elements of Dante's masterpiece. By the time I got to see Beatrice in the Paradiso, I really felt more confused than awed.

I didn't absorb as much as I wanted to. The notes provided by Sinclair were concise but I really didn't have a context nor a deeper understanding of Dante's world. All I can say, is I wish I had this book with me at the time.

Gallagher begins with an Introduction, a "question and answer" section set up like an interview concerning Dante's background. The questions are straightforwards as are the answers. Then he takes on the three canticles, going Canto by Canto, exploring extra information (should it be needed) in the Notes following each substantial but brief exposition. Gallagher knows his Divine Comedy, he enlightens the reader by comparing passages, shedding light on the various themes, motifs and the Italian wordplay Dante incorporated (like Shakespeare, Dante was influential in creating his nation's modern vernacular). And of course he provides information on the fiction/non-fictional figures throughout the work.

I don't think there will ever be a specific, absolute interpretation of The Divine Comedy. Nor will there ever be a perfect way to tackle the text. Reading the Comedia of Dante is all about exploration but I think having Gallagher along as a guide is your best bet. He also has a nice bibliography at the end so you can take that next step. It would make Virgil proud.

Dante is difficult to read, and I found this guide to be extremely useful. I also used the Cliff's notes, which were fine, and which supplemented Freccero's guide. My feeling is that most readers of Dante will benefit from all the help they can acquire, and having the Modern Reader's Guide is virtually essential!
What helped more than anything, was having The Teaching Company's course on Dante. This made a huge difference.

As a daily reader at the Universalis web site, I was intrigued when one day they had a succinct and inviting overview of Dante and his life. Having always known of the "Divine Comedy" but at an arms length, I went to our library and pulled what appeared to be a helpful translation, but also found Fr. Gallagher's guide. By good fortune, I started reading the guide first, and how pleased I am. It is so good that I continue to read it frequently. My hope is when I master the wealth of information in his guide; I can then go to Dante directly and revel in the beauty of his poetry.

This book is an excellent layman's companion to the Divine Comedy. Through his writing, Gallagher functions as a modern-day Virgil, guiding the reader through all 100 cantos of Dante's magnum opus. Gallagher peels away the obscure references, intricate politics, and esoteric philosophy of Dante's work to reveal the Divine Comedy's enduring core. Gallagher also allows the reader to take in centuries of reaction to Dante by pointing out allusions to the work in the writings of Chaucer, Pound, Shelley, and others. Especially enlightening are the short descriptions and commentary (1-4 pages) of Dante's lesser works, such as the "De Monarchia," "De Vulgari Eloquentia," and his poems. These help prevent Dante from becoming a one hit wonder and situate his Divine Comedy in a better context.

There are a few shortcomings. Gallagher foolishly believes that in "Inferno," Dante is "clearing the record" about literally breaking a baptismal font in Florence's Baptistry in order to save a child. (The event is obviously purely symbolic and refers to his criticism of the Catholic Church.) Gallagher also gets too involved in trying to link some of the symbols to real people/events (like the She-Leopard of Canto I) that do not have any counterpart in reality. But I am nit-picking in this matter, and think that these problems do little to detract from the overall enjoyable experience of Gallagher's book.

I would recommend this text to anyone who is tackling the Divine Comedy for the first time or to any non-scholar who is visiting it again. It's highly readable and clearer than most commentaries.

With apologies, I must state the simple truth: Philip Hawkins, Dante: a Brief History Dante: A Brief History (Blackwell Brief Histories of Religion) is the best introduction to Commedia in english. Gallagher is no slouch and this is no put down:Hawkins is just better. I admit that may be prejudiced by the fact that when I started my own book on Inferno Dante's Journey: A Field Guide to the Infernal RegionsI used Gallagher first and discarded it because it was light on detail, and found Dante: a Brief History a big help, and Hawkins other book Dantes Testaments: Essays in Scriptural Imagination (Figurae: Reading Medieval Culture) even more so, but a think Hawkins' book is as well organized as Gallagher's, as engaging and has the advantage on depth.

Gallagher's review was immensely helpful to me. I am a college graduate in literature but this was my first reading of [[ASIN:0764804944 A Modern Reader's Guide to Dante's the Divine Comedy]. He analyzes each Canto and his book can be used side-by-side with your translation of choice. Sometimes I would read his analyses more than once, then return to Dante with renewed comprehension.

I highly recommend Gallagher's Guide to the uninitiated high school to college graduate: he takes you deeply into the text and decodes the individuals with whom Dante floods the Comedy, characters famous to Dante's contempories but unfamiliar to the contemporary reader. The book is accessible and helpful.

This is exactly what I was looking for, a simple tour that I could read in my free time. I also bought a book with the Dore Illustrations of the Divine Comedy. A perfect way to go through the Comedy without actually reading it. Recommended for all of those who won't read the poetic translations but want to educate themselves with this important work of art.