Customer Reviews

Money Can Buy Happiness: How to Spend to Get the Life You Want

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(0)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

When I ordered this book, I was half expecting instructions on how to hire a personal concierge. But I've read the author on MSN.com and knew she writes more on dealing with debt than servants.

This is really the next step after all the recent books on research regarding happiness (such as The Science of Happiness) - applied happiness. Dunleavey uses an investment motif which helps get across the point that it is important to get parts of all happiness areas (like diversifying your portfolio) and also it makes seem less selfish.

This book is not just about spending money. Some things don't always cost money, such as building good friendships and family relationships though when it does (such as traveling to see family) it is money well spent. And the book makes clear that saving money so that you don't lose sleep at night worrying about debt or retirement is very important.

Much of the same ground is covered in Get a Life: You Don't Need a Million to Retire Well from the happiness in retirement angle. And the book recommends Your Money or Your Life for the savings angle.

If you have not already read all these books, then get this one. It is an easy read with lots of real-life examples. It'll help re-orient your spending of both money and time to that which will maximize your enjoyment of life.

I've read MP's MSN columns for years but never understood how someone who is in debt can write about getting out of it. But she is an interesting writer so that's why I bought the book. It's not full of earth shattering information, but it's kind of nice, sweet good-to-know stuff. Won't change your life, well maybe a little, but it will make you think and perhaps point you in the right direction.

This author really puts the "personal" in personal finance. Dunleavey helps readers figure out what's most important to them and then helps them figure where they can cut back so they can spend more money doing what they love.This is an uplifting book that tells readers how to have a nice life on a tight budget. Yes, money can buy happiness!

The first thing I liked before even starting is that it's on kindle -- I could take it on my trip without lugging another book. Then the approach of auditing my use of money in terms of it's affect on happiness seems appealing. The bright surprise here was the idea of looking at our invaluable gift of time in a similar vein -- what a good geeky/practical way to think about it.

The author MP Dunleavy has learned her valuable lesson plan through personal experience. The book is an easy and enjoyable read full of good common sense strategies to analyze your current situation and discover ways to structure your budget goals to enjoy life the way you find most enjoyable and important. I would highly recommend this book even if you aren't in a financial crisis but just want to take a fresh look at your own habits and goals.

Updated to improve helpfulness 2/13/09

I am a recovering debt addict and I am always on the look out for resources that help me develop better habits. The author M.P. Dunleavey takes a I'm-one-of-you/we're-in-this-together approach to personal finance, therefore I thought this book might be useful, but I was wrong.

In retrospect, where this book began to go wrong was in the title. The author claims she is going to guide you on "how to spend". For example in chapter 6 called "Put Your Money Where Your Health Is", you'd think this advice would be the most thoughtful, yet I found most of these tips empty, useless, wasteful, and out of touch. A couple are:


* "Sometimes it's a better investment to spend out of pocket to see a doctor whom you like and trust and who spends time with you."


*"It's worth investing in a more deluxe gym..."


The suggestion about paying out of pocket to find a doctor you "like", though well meaning, ignores the realities of the average American. The sad fact is that we have a national health care crisis and millions of Americans lack fundamental access to health care services, let alone the ability to "shop" around for a doctor. If you can afford paying out of pocket every time you visit your physician, good for you!

Also, I don't know what "more deluxe gym" means, other than MORE EXPENSIVE. Unfortunately, this is how the whole book reads, less about making tough choices and more about justifying excess and waste as long as it's "convenient" or makes you "happy".

Even the so-called "60% solution" that is supposed to pave the way for you to start buying "happiness" is ill conceived. You need to divide your gross income (pretax) into 5 categories:


60% - Should only be used to cover "basic living costs"
10% - Retirement
10% - Long term savings
10% - Short term savings
10% - "fun, frivolous, spontaneous expenses" she says don't even bother keeping track of this cause it's suppose to be "guilt-free"


Using the author's own figures and estimates this plan sounds like a disaster. Dunleavey says, that if you make about $48,000 a year (pretax of course) your basic living costs should be 60% of an average $4,000 a month, which would be $2,400. She also estimates that federal, state, and local taxes will be about 1/3 to 1/2 of $2,400.

Ultimately leaving you about $1,200 to $1,600 to provide for your basic living costs which she lists as:


Taxes (which I already covered)
Mortgage/rent (don't forget property taxes, home owner's insurance)
Health care costs (premiums, co-pays, prescriptions, don't forget the out of pocket cost for a doctor you "like")
Car payments
Car insurance
Gas
Home phone
Cell phone
Heat
Electricity
Water
Food
Tuition
Childcare
Charitable giving
Other (assuming you have any money left)


I believe by her own standards this is a pretty crappy system. She is advocating meeting your basic needs by living at about the federal poverty level for a household of 2 which is about $14,570 in 2009. An improbable feat for an individual, impossible challenge if you threw a spouse and a child into the mix. I really doubt that on such a plan anyone would feel "happiness" or "guilt-free" to have spent $4,800 (10% of 48k) unaccounted for "frivolous" money at the end of the year.

Obviously, I felt this book was awful before our current economic crisis and I certainly don't think you should waste your money now. If you are like me you don't have 20 bucks of "frivolous" money. This author is completely oblivious.

In conclusion, Dunleavey's "buy happiness" theory lacks substance and is just another gimmick. I am a working mother and I strongly feel you don't have to be an MBA or PhD to wrangle your personal finances. It is accurate to say that this author's main audience is women and I frequently found this book too dumbed down on the subject of personal finance that it will leave you falling back on excuses and justifying excess instead of feeling empowered or challenged to do better.