Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The enlightening history of the use and abuse of money, July 14, 2008
This review is from: Money and Man: A Survey of Monetary Experience (Hardcover)
This book makes abundantly clear that what we are experiencing today is the exact same situation that has been inflicted over and over again throughout history on the most advanced and powerful civilizations. "Money and Man" is a survey of the history of money, which is in turn the history of the manipulation of money by rulers and governments for the purpose of defrauding and impoverishing its citizens. Groseclose surveys the great civilizations, including the Greek, Roman, and Byzantine empires, and then turns to the history of money, credit and banking in Europe starting with the Middle Ages. Throughout this history, it was only Greece and Byzantium that managed, for the most part, to resist the temptation to debase their money. All other civilizations, and especially western European nations right up into modern times, were continually afflicted with ever-depreciating money, manipulated and debased by their rulers for their own advantage and ambition. In the west, the economy has slowly but surely shifted from a system based on capital and productivity to a system based on debt. This is borne out in what Groseclose presents of the history of European banking, inflation, managed money and debt. In both the history and in his explanations Groseclose does a masterful job of drawing out the forces, motivations and illusions that are behind the use and abuse of money. The thesis that becomes clear is that the central problem surrounding the issue of money is a moral problem, and that mankind has almost never been able to exercise the moral restraint needed to maintain honest money. The consequences have been universally disastrous, and our inability to learn from history is likely to continue to bring economic crises upon us like the one that is currently unfolding. If this history teaches anything at all, it is that governments can under no circumstances be trusted to provide an honest and stable money for its citizens. As Groseclose summarizes at the end of the book, "Inescapably we are brought to the conclusion that our money system will not achieve the stability and strength necessary to enable it to support the vast and complicated structure of modern economy until the moral dimension of the question is faced. Whether, as a practical matter, a money system is based on debt, as at present, upon the good faith and credit of the sovereignty creating it, or whether money should be intrinsic, a metallic coinage or a metallic reserve freely available to note holders, the ultimate answer is a moral response." If you're having trouble finding it, this book is also available as a free PDF file at the von Mises Institute.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
The enlightening history of the use and abuse of money, July 14, 2008
This book makes abundantly clear that what we are experiencing today is the exact same situation that has been inflicted over and over again throughout history on the most advanced and powerful civilizations. "Money and Man" is a survey of the history of money, which is in turn the history of the manipulation of money by rulers and governments for the purpose of defrauding and impoverishing its citizens. Groseclose surveys the great civilizations, including the Greek, Roman, and Byzantine empires, and then turns to the history of money, credit and banking in Europe starting with the Middle Ages. Throughout this history, it was only Greece and Byzantium that managed, for the most part, to resist the temptation to debase their money. All other civilizations, and especially western European nations right up into modern times, were continually afflicted with ever-depreciating money, manipulated and debased by their rulers for their own advantage and ambition. In the west, the economy has slowly but surely shifted from a system based on capital and productivity to a system based on debt. This is borne out in what Groseclose presents of the history of European banking, inflation, managed money and debt. In both the history and in his explanations Groseclose does a masterful job of drawing out the forces, motivations and illusions that are behind the use and abuse of money. The thesis that becomes clear is that the central problem surrounding the issue of money is a moral problem, and that mankind has almost never been able to exercise the moral restraint needed to maintain honest money. The consequences have been universally disastrous, and our inability to learn from history is likely to continue to bring economic crises upon us like the one that is currently unfolding. If this history teaches anything at all, it is that governments can under no circumstances be trusted to provide an honest and stable money for its citizens. As Groseclose summarizes at the end of the book, "Inescapably we are brought to the conclusion that our money system will not achieve the stability and strength necessary to enable it to support the vast and complicated structure of modern economy until the moral dimension of the question is faced. Whether, as a practical matter, a money system is based on debt, as at present, upon the good faith and credit of the sovereignty creating it, or whether money should be intrinsic, a metallic coinage or a metallic reserve freely available to note holders, the ultimate answer is a moral response." If you're having trouble finding it, this book is also available as a free PDF file at the von Mises Institute.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Good review on the history of money, November 28, 2007
Very good review of mans experience with money, what types of things have been used as money and what the base attributes of a substance must have in order to make it useful as money plus a history of humans experience with banking, government control of money supply, how money can be subjected to monetary controls and or debased (to fund wars / political agendas) etc . Goes all back in history to the Byzantine empire and links us along through all the major banking/money evolutions to current day. Money is important enough that we all blindly work for it everyday, how is it we know so little about something we depend on so much? Very interesting read. I also recommend Americas Money machine, a look at the federal reserve by the same author.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|