From School Library Journal
Grade 5-9–Set in medieval China, each book in this series focuses on one of five young orphan monks. Each one is named after a specific animal and is learning a kung-fu-style martial art based on its characteristics. In the opening pages of
Tiger and this sequel, their secret temple is attacked by a former student who is attempting to turn himself into a dragon. Their teacher, the Grandmaster, is killed and the five scatter into the forest. This sets up a tense plot that moves quickly from fight scene to fight scene with character and plot development being filled in between battles. Eleven-year-old Malao, the Monkey, is the youngest monk and is prone to giggling and avoiding baths. Initially uncertain without his brothers by his side, he is befriended by an albino macaque who is the leader of a troop of monkeys. Human/animal interaction is a central theme of both books as is the idea of the Chosen One or, in this case, Chosen Five. While both books begin at the same moment and then follow a separate character, their stories meet at points and the second book takes readers farther along in the narrative. Mysteries abound, with many left unresolved at the end. It is important to read this series in order. Stone has done a masterful job of managing an intricate plot, developing authentic characters, and writing well-described fight scenes. An easy and worthy sell to middle-grade readers.
–Kathleen Meulen, Blakely Elementary School, Bainbridge Island, WA Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.
Gr. 5-8. The youngest of five orphaned monks who escaped the pillage of their monastery, 11-year-old Malao races through treetops, leaps amazing heights, and practices a monkey style of martial arts. Too squeamish to help brother Hok protect the corpse of their Grandmaster, Malao meets up with brothers, Lu and Seh, as they attempt to take their sacred scrolls to Shaolin Temple. Along the way, mischievous Malao encounters bandits; an army of macaques and a ferocious enemy, Tsung.
Monkey retains the intriguing kung fu elements, exotic setting, and pell-mell pace of
Tiger (2005), but heavy-handed plotting, stilted conversations, and hokey relationships make this a disappointing sequel. Avid fans will want to continue the kung fu saga, but this second of five projected installments does not measure up to the first.
Linda PerkinsCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to the
Hardcover
edition.