14 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Time, Change, Loss and Memory, June 4, 2003
From his village in China, Chen Pan, aged twenty, is tricked into indentured servitude, shipped across the oceans to Cuba, and for the next few years he will work as a slave cutting sugar cane. The year is 1857. Time rolls on. Chen Pan has children, grand-children, great grand-children. The story moves easily between the generations, between China and Cuba and the United States and Viet Nam, returning in the end to Chen Pan, now eighty years old, 1917.
There is no tightly crafted plot here, no suspense, no dramatic surprises. The book is a series of scenes, vignettes, from the lives of this remarkable family, their times, the countries where they live, social change, their loves and their losses, brief moments of optimism and joy, against a background of growing old, suffering, sorrow and clinging to memory.
It is a beautifully written, exquisite memoir. Author Garcia evokes wonderful portraits of times and places and creates engaging characters, using simple and lucid language. Once you pick up this book you will never want to put it down, for you will become part of the Chen family forever. This is a masterpiece and I can't recommend it too highly. Reviewed by Louis N. Gruber
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting idea, terrible end result, February 4, 2008
I generally prefer reading reviews than writing them, but when something excites or upsets me I want to share it with the world. Garcia creates interesting outlines of characters and, in my opinion, utterly fails to deliver them to the reader. I have to write a response paper on this and all I want to say is that she has no clue what she is doing and that it should be used as kindling. It's obvious that she can write, and some of the passages are beautiful and engaging, but overall the characters don't come to life and I am kept wondering - what on earth was the point of this book? Blah.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Garcia, Explore a Saga for this, February 7, 2007
I love Christina Garcia and looked so forward to reading this book which may be why I am so let down. Typically I am able to get the entire picture from a novel, even if it is not plot driven - which this one had absolutely no plot, no character growth and no reason to continue reading. The concept is excellent, finding the descendents from one country (China) and tracing them through three eras and three countries (China, Cuba, and America)! Definitely a concept worth exploring maybe more in a saga type novel, not a 251 page novel where you have no time to explore the characters and their connections to one another. Not to take anything away from Garcia - Dreaming in Cuban was set up similar to this, but you had more time with each character and came to love and show concern for what happened to them. Here, you just didn't care because you didn't really know the characters. The linear patterns for all three characters went like this, born, shifted location, something big happens, death or in Chen Pan's case immortality. The something big that happened was also so slight that you barely knew something happened overall. There were no problems, just daily life adjusting the characters, again no reason to read. This is just my opinion and I may be missing the big picture on this one, but I typically don't.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No