Most Helpful Customer Reviews
55 of 61 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
This one is a good summer read, May 25, 2005
Frank Peretti has written some really remarkable books, including "This Present Darkness", and his writing style is always enjoyable to read. That said, this book is not as deep nor profound as some of his other works, but because it is a book that is fun to read and hard to put down, I recommend it as the kind of light reading we like to enjoy in the summer months at the beach.
The book starts with a couple out for a long trek in the wilderness, with the husband pushing his shy wife, who has a stuttering problem, out to strengthen and test her. The book never really explains how this wilderness trek is supposed to do this, but it's a believable premise anyway. The two are attacked by creatures in the forest they think are bears, or perhaps "Bigfoot"?
Now, when the book starts out by creating a situation about "Bigfoot" I was very unsure of where it would go. Typical for Peretti though, all is not what it seems. The wife, "Beck", is captured by these creatures and the rest of the book centers on her rescue, as well as some discoveries of how these creatures came to be.
The writing is good, not great, but as I mentioned it flows along and the story unfolds in a way that keeps you engaged. There are some bigger issues tackled here, but not to the extent of his other work. In fact, for those who may read the book for its "Christian" content, there just isn't much there.
Overall, a good effort and a fun light read, although not up to his best work.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
72 of 83 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Detailed complexity, yet simple "big picture", May 17, 2005
I wanted desperately to love this book...as I have all the other Peretti books geared for adults. Instead, it was likeable. The tremendously detailed descriptions of setting harken to a writing era long gone--one that I frankly do not enjoy. The author is a master a description--writing with vibrancy and clarity. However, like many TV-generation readers, I get a feel for a book's backdrop, and fill in the blanks myself. Thus, during particularly wordy passages, I found myself skimming through.
The professional reviewers were correct to fault Monster's overly crowded field of supporting characters. I read this book in spurts (preschoolers in the house), and found myself occasionally wondering who I was reading about. This factor was particularly disappointing when the turncoats were revealed. I had figured for some time that there were bad guys in the mix of rescuers, and frankly did not care much which ones they were--since there were so many to choose from.
The plot could be very simple, or extremely complicated--depending on whether the reader tries to keep all the details clear, or simply concentrates on how the story is flowing. Either way, there was some disappointment. The details were overwhelming, but the overarching plot seemed to amount to Beck spending a long time being moved about the woods, while rescuing kept getting thwarted.
Yes, there was a fair amount of tension, there were some twists, some surprises. However, the most interesting character was Beck--the woman captured by some interesting creatures. She uses intuitive "intercultural" communication skills to figure out how to survive and even work her new "family."
On Evolution--a saving grace of this work is that Peretti mainly tackled one issue--do mutations work? Scientists committed to the theory might scoff at the simplistic and perhaps paranoid approach the author seems to take. Committed Creationists will be disappointed if they were looking for a persuasive tract. However for the vast majority of readers--myself included--the simple reality that mutations bring drawbacks, rather than improvements, offers a powerful question mark to Darwin's doctrine.
Bottom-line: This is a decent read, but not Peretti's best. Comparisons to The Oath are apt. Peretti does better when he tackles spiritual warfare, or faulty Christian practice. I recommend the two Darkness books and the Visitation, by the same author, instead of Monster.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very good read, April 20, 2005
I must say first...I am not necessarily a fan of Christian fiction. Nothing against it, just not something I read. So when I picked this book up, and then got home I was a tad wary to find that Peretti is somewhat known for jsut that. But I was surprised. I didn't find that book waxing poetic about the evils of evolution or being completely against the theory itself.
One of the supporting characters Mike Capella, is/was a biologist who was against the theory of evolution. (Unless, I read it wrong) but more importantly he was against tampering with what is already here. And I beleive that was the heart of the book. I do think that FP has his own beliefs inserted in the book, and why not, he is the author, and he makes a compelling argument.
I must say that the monster in the book isn't the real monster here, but then I suppose that was the point. The book can get a little wordy, but I enjoyed the premise of the book very much.
A few, even the author himself, sited Crichton as an inspiration, ok, but I must say I find Peretti's writing style simply and that isn't a bad thing here. Crichton can be a bit verbose, almost like he is trying to make a deep, thought provoking book when all you want to read about is the monster. For the most part Peretti did just that, and in a book like this, that is what I want.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|