I'm sure you are reading this review because you are dying to find out if $200 is worth it to pay for a pair of ear-bud headphones. Before I begin my review, I must note that while sense of value is quite subjective, I do factor it into my reviews. This review will be long, but I wish to be thorough with such a big purchase.
My daily use headphones (both in my office and when on an airplane) right now are a pair of Audio-Technica QuietPoint ATH-ANC7b that I chose over the Bose, both for sound quality and for overall value. While the Bose might have had a slight edge in some types of sound, I couldn't stomach the cost for something I could lose or break on an airplane. I also own a cheap pair of $10 plastic earbuds bought at an airport kiosk for when I don't want the bulk of the full headphones. These were also used for my comparison.
When I first got the Earth Wind Fire box, I was literally stunned by the quality of the packaging. While I resent paying for the packaging for myself, it would make quite a nice gift and show how much you spent to the recipient. The outside box has a soft felt covering, and on the inside the headphones are beautifully presented with a leather case below them. This leather case appears to be a belt-clip, designed to hold a small MP3 player like an iPod Nano along with the earbuds. The build quality of the case is spectacular with a divided inner pouch and a magnetic closure. A case like this could easily sell for over $20 on its own. The case does have a huge Earth Wind Fire logo on it, so you'd better be a fan before you clip this on your belt.
Below the tray with the earbuds and the combo MP3 player/headphone case is a leather bag for just the headphones (with a coin-case type squeeze opening), and a set of 11 pairs of ear cups (plus an additional one pre-installed). I quickly found that the pre-installed one just did not fit my ear (it fell out), so I tried to find my right fit. Amazingly, you really do need 12 different sizes. There are 2 catch-all conical buds that work if you're in a hurry. One of these should fit, but you'll want to figure out which of the round ones is your size. Indeed, I tried all 10 round buds and only 1 wedged perfectly in my ear. Not only are they different sizes, but also different shapes. Once inside my ear, I was amazed at the noise isolation - these would be great on an airplane. I've never had a pair of earbuds that sealed out the world so well. I am concerned with losing the earbud tips - Monster has a kit of 6 replacement tips for $10 on their site, but since there is no labeling on the 12 tips, I have no idea if my size is included.
As for actual sound performance--using my iPhone4, I tried to listen to my Antonan Dvorak's Symphony No 9 in E minor, otherwise known as the New World Symphony. While the violins sounded nice initially, disappointment quickly set in as the deep brass started to boom. The Monster earbuds sounded hollow and empty, like listening to classical on AM radio! I tried my $10 cheap earbuds and they were great, as were my Audio-Technica headphones. I tried Mozart, Beethoven, Haydn, even Philip Glass - everything sounded hollow on the Monster headphones.
Thinking I must be missing something, I decided to try out some vocal music, playing Michael Buble ("Home" and a few other pieces). Here is where the headphones could shine. Indeed, there was a light snare brush during the intro I had never heard before that played crystal clear. Buble's voice was more distinct and defined than I have ever heard him. His music was a new experience in these headphones. Ditto for other male crooners like Sinatra, Bennett, and Tyrell.
As best I can tell, these headphones greatly enhance voice and the mid-range at the expense of bass response. I also played some collegiate a cappella. Suddenly I was transported back to the college quad standing under an arch listening to vocal harmonies. The voices were sharper and as advertised, sounded "live".
Country music didn't turn out as well. I decided to test a vocal-heavy artist by listening to some Taylor Swift, and I found her voice harsh and frankly unpleasant (whereas normally I enjoy her music). It seems that there is a bit too much treble response here.
My conclusion for sound quality is that the advertising is true - they really did tune these for a live sound, and perhaps one optimized for certain types of music. I tried a few other pieces and it seems that not only are these tuned for vocals, but only male vocals as female vocals sound harsh. I would say they are quite unique headphones and cool for some sounds, but not good all-around.
I also tested the iPhone integration. A tiny control on the cord controls volume, pause, and enables voice control. I was amazed at the small size of the control - many of these are bulky, but this one is almost as thin as the non-tangle cord. I tried some voice dialing and was quite pleased with the quality. It's a nice and well-executed feature of the headphones.
So how do I rate the headphones? First, you must understand what you are getting. These are not good for classical music or heavy rock. They are marginal even for some vocal albums depending on how the sound is mixed. The built quality feels stunning, but I can't help but feel much of the $200 is paying for the names Monster and Earth, Wind, and Fire.
With a heavy heart, I need to rate these 3 stars to indicate I would not purchase these myself and would have been dissatisfied if I had spent my own money here. I found the fuller performance of my $10 airport earbuds more satisfying to my ear and even my Audio-Technica active noise-cancelling headphones cost less. On the plus side they have a quality feel, a great non-tangle cord, amazing accessories, and are comfortable in my ear. But should you buy it? I am not saying you should not - read the details of my review and decide the value yourself because the headphones have a lot going for them, just not for my own taste.