Most Helpful Customer Reviews
195 of 219 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Pull To Go Back To Visit Old Friends Will Make This Book A Must Read -- But Beware Of The Disappointment From Doing So!, October 9, 2010
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Having enjoyed all of Lehane's books and being a particulary big fan of the Kenzie-Gennaro mysteries (especially Gone, Baby, Gone), I couldn't wait to read Moonlight Mile to catch up on the lives of my old friends. I'm sure most other readers who are big fans of Lehane's books and of this series will feel compelled to read this sequel to Gone, Baby, Gone, which takes place twelve years later. However, let me forewarn you that after reading this book you are likely to feel disappointed and a bit sorry to have gone back to visit Patrick, Angie, Bubba and Amanda (the girl who was an integral part of Gone, Baby, Gone).
My disappointment with Moonlight Mile has nothing to do with Lehane's plot concept, which is a good one. The plot invloves Kenzie and Gennaro, haunted by the past, revisiting the case that troubled them the most, following a twelve-year trail of secrets and lies. Believing that this time will be different, they vow to make good on their promise to find Amanda, who has once again disappeared. This vow leads them down a path that could cost them their lives.
My disappointment stems from what, until this book, I thought was an impossibility; which is that Lehane -- who has proven to be a master in creating rich, complex "real world" characters and dialogue that sounds "fresh from the street," -- could write a book in which some characters seem paper-thin and unbelievable, and which speak in a way that, while glib and, at times witty, doesn't ring true at all. This is especially true about the character of sixteen-year old Amanda, as well as of Lehane's Russian mob characters, which are virtually cartoonish. Further, the characters of Angie and Bubba, who have been favorites of mine throughout this series, don't come across as compelling or even particulary interesting in Moonlight Mile.
I hope this review is helpful in cautioning fans of this series that going back in time to revisit old friends might not always be the best move.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
130 of 160 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Great and Fitting Finish to the Series, September 21, 2010
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
It was my great pleasure to receive Moonlight Mile to do an early review. It has been eleven years since Patrick and Angie have graced the book world, but even though we haven't seen them in a long time, they are welcomed back into our lives.
While Moonlight Mile is the direct sequel to Prayers for Rain, the last Patrick and Angie book, it is more closely related to 1997's Gone Baby Gone. As long time fans will remember, that book ended with Patrick Kenzie making the impossible decision to take a young four year old girl away from her loving kidnappers and give her back to her derelict mother. An action that almost permanently destroyed the relationship between Kenzie and his long time love Angela Gennaro.
Flash forward twelve years and things have drastically changed for Patrick and Angie. For one, Angie is now married to Patrick and they have a precocious four year old daughter of their own named Gabby. Their PI firm has been shuttered mostly because Patrick and Angie can't take the violence that has followed them. Patrick works on a contractor basis with a big PI firm doing mostly corporate and high dollar client work, hoping to get hired on as a full time benefitted employee. Meanwhile, Angie is finishing up a grad degree to work with special needs students.
Their tenuous existence is shattered when Bea McCready calls Patrick in the middle of the night to inform him that her niece is missing again. Now 16 years old, she had become hard from being put back with her derelict mother. After Patrick is assaulted and robbed by criminals involved with Helene McCready (Amanda's derelict mother), he launches himself headlong into the newest disappearance, finding a long sad trial of violence and broken lives. To give away more would rob you of a great reading experience.
It is good to see Patrick and Angie return, even if it is clear this is their final ride. It is also good to see Lehane be funny again. As a writer, he is a master of hilarious dialogue, even in difficult situations. That humor was sorely missing from Mystic River, Shutter Island and The Given Day, the three books he has released in the preceding 11 years.
Much like Gone Baby Gone, the story revolves around morality and what it means. Patrick is faced with the fact that Amanda McCready would likely have been better off with her kidnappers than with her mother Helene. Other characters are forced to make similar choices between what is right as a general rule and what is right for a situation.
It is also a meditation on love. Kenzie's love for Angie, Gabby and even his psychotic best friend Bubba (who is sadly underused in this story) is explored and plays a vital role in every decision made.
If this is it for Patrick and Angie and they don't get pulled into another case down the line (and I don't think they will), I don't think they could leave us in a better way. Highly recommended, five stars and by far the best book of the year.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
OK - but not up to Lehan's standards, November 16, 2010
Very quick read - but did not live up to expectations I have for all of Lehane's work. Seems like he said to himself (or someone said to him) "let's do a sequel to 'Gone Baby Gone' - but we only have 'x' days to do it, so make it quick!". Seemed rushed and not well thought out. If it's possible, it was good and disappointing at the same time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|