6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Heart and soul, August 27, 2007
I am not much for short stories. Wow, was I favorably impressed with the collection of stories in Robin Romm's The Mother Garden. These stories are like a tender touch to a black eye. Without flinching, Ms. Romm looks closely at what it means to be human. Loss sure, but that is not, to my mind, the meditation here. Rather, its a close up exam of life's relentless hope in the midst of the inexplicable hardships that come our way. Romm gives many of her characters an off beat voice and just enough magic to sharpen the focus. These stories are redeeming, fun and poignant. After reading this book, I sent copies to several friends and family members all living in different parts of the country. Every person responded with an unusual degree of gushing thanks. In one way or another they all conveyed the same message: the book is different, insightful, and makes it so easy to touch those broken and bruised places we all tend to protect while longing to have them touched with a healing hand.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Poignant, funny, completely absorbing., October 9, 2007
The surreal abuts the all-too-familiar in Robin Romm's exemplary collection of stories, where mothers take root (at least for a while) and an egg or a goldfish stands in for the fragile emotions at play. While death and illness are recurring themes, Romm deftly avoids bathos, finding her niche in the push and pull between horror, sadness, humor, and sex. There is nothing glib about Romm's magical scenarios; rather, by placing the outre alongside the commonplace, she unflinchingly illuminates both.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Strong, poetic writing, April 6, 2008
Robin Romm penned a collection of short stories with characters essentially dealing with loss and dysfunction with their parents/parenthood in her book, The Mother Garden. Romm began to write these stories while in graduate school at San Francisco State University, when she was dealing with the loss of her mother. This no doubt, inspired the rest of the stories, which all have similar themes.
Romm said in writing the stories it was never the goal to figure those deep themes out, but "it's the process." She must have really tried it to figure it out, from multiple angles, to explain the wide array of similar-sounding stories. Whether it was a resentful daughter of a woman dying of cancer, a resentful daughter of a woman who buries herself alive in her own weight, or even a father resentful of his wife and daughter: there was definitely resentment all around, seething quietly in a corner, underlying a lot of stories. However, despite the similarities of the pieces, she still manages to hang on to the reader by her deft language and striking word choice. Her endings rarely give the characters any answers or resolution, but Romm wants it that way. "I don't like it when a reader puts the book down and says `Ah,' and that's it," she says. Instead, she opts for a more open-ended approach, one where the story is open to unlimited possibilities, and it is up to the reader to decide what unfolds for these protagonists.
What is interesting about the protagonists is the gender of the main characters. While the majority is woman, two stories "Celia's Fish" and "The Egg Game," are told in men's perspective. Romm, when asked if her writing process was any different for writing a man's voice, shrugged off the question. "It's the same," she says. "I just try to imagine the man's perspective. But I suppose it is easier writing a woman's experience." Apparently, she is very natural capturing men's actions and motivations, because she does so so brilliantly, such as in the "Game," in which a man deals with impending fatherhood and commitment to his wife. Impressive still in the story, is how not only does she write from a man's perspective, but also from another race entirely.
I felt the weakest story in the collection was the title story, "The Mother Garden." I felt that it was a bit confusing, as there were never any clear or explanatory lines drawn for the reader as to how much magical realism is taking place. Romm noted that she felt more literary freedom when dealing with heavy issues such as death and grief, when she went for fairy tale-like feel or absurdity. The mother garden concept itself was intriguing, but I felt wasn't executed effectively. It seemed awkward almost, or forced, having Claire recruit these women to stand in a garden. The story straddled the line between realism and absurdity, and if it leaned more towards one way or another, it would have worked better. The highlight for me was reading the distinct dialogue of the, albeit one-dimensional, mother characters.
In the end, I appreciate the craft of Garden, but would like to see more variety in her content. Some places could have been more developed or worked on for better cohesion, but for the most part Romm is a great observer of the world and an expert on expression. In many instances she took my breath away with her simple, elegant and honest prose that it is enough to make me a fan.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
