From Publishers Weekly
Thirteen-year-old Jenny Newhall is a normal adolescent: bright, big-hearted and snappish to her adoptive mother. Jenny's birth mother, teenager Linda Emery, hid her pregnancy and disappeared from her home in Massachusetts, leaving grieving relatives to assume she had been killed. Now, when Linda shows up unannounced on the Newhall's doorstep on Mother's Day, skeletons clatter from closets all over town, and soon Linda's bloodied body turns up in a dumpster. Suspicion points to Jenny's adoptive father, Greg, who evades arrest and goes underground, trying to unravel clues that could make his family whole again. The police investigation headed by laconic loner Walter Ference exposes infidelity, sexual extortion and the key to an earlier murder. MacDonald, an Edgar award nominee for The Unforgiven , digs with relish into the town's secrets and its stockpile of hot emotions--betrayal, rejection, anger, jealousy and unrequited lust--pushing the buttons that titillate readers but failing to cohere into a focused narrative. The suspense she generates is disappointingly stop-and-go, loosening its hold too quickly after each revelation and falling away into mundane details.
Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Karen Newhall's Mother's Day is upset when her adopted daughter Jenny's birth mother appears on her doorstep. But her whole life is capsized two days later when the woman is found murdered and Karen's husband, Greg, is the prime suspect--because, he admits, he had an extramarital affair with the victim 14 years earlier and Jenny is actually his real daughter. The news of the affair devastates Karen, and when Greg escapes from police custody, she begins to wonder if he also lied about the murder. MacDonald supplies plenty of suspects in her large cast of characters and then provides a satisfying, albeit predictable, ending. She has written several mass-market best sellers, including No Way Home (Dell, 1990), and this new entry will be welcomed by her fans. Recommended. Previewed in Prepub Alert, LJ 11/1/93.
- Rebecca House Stankowski, Purdue Univ. Calumet Lib., Hammond, Ind.Copyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.