on October 2, 2004
I don't think that there's ever been a greatest hits album in the history of the music business that didn't rile up a couple of fans. Motley Crue, who was known as much for their off stage antics as their on stage ones, weighs in with this 17-track package, and it's mostly the good stuff in here. There are some songs on here that most other reviewers thought didn't belong, but I happen to like "Without You" and "Afraid." There are a few clunkers on here, like "Glitter" and the re-tooled and nu-metal-ed "Shout at the Devil," but overall it's pretty hard to pick up a greatest hits package and just HATE it. Even the two new tracks ("Bitter Pill" and "Enslaved") are great additions to the Crue legacy.
Just a few more nitpicking moments: First off, the track order is somewhat flawed. The songs are grouped together pretty well, though "Glitter" falls in between two of the Crue's heaviest cuts - "Wild Side" and "Dr. Feelgood." Also, the transition from "Without You" to "Smokin' in the Boys Room" is jarring to say the least. Finally, someone should have spent a little more time on the artwork. It looks rushed.
If you're really into Motley Crue, I'd recommend picking this one up for the two unreleased songs. If you're not REALLY into Motley Crue, this does a good job of collecting the essential songs (except "Live Wire"). Personally, I've got a bunch of Motley Crue records, but I throw this one on when I'm feeling lazy.
Greatest hits? Mostly. Worth the admission price? Definitely.
on May 26, 2004
Does The Darkness have you curious about 80s metal? You think that you will get a feel for what we went through in the 80s by buying this Greatest Hits? This CD is far short of the best of Motley Crue. It doesn't even include Too Young To Fall In Love and it messes up the original Shout At The Devil. Obviously a record exec put these songs together.
Think about the big bands today. Normally they come out with a raw album (sorry, I'm old) that grabs the attention of real music lovers. An underground buzz starts, then the record company gets a hold of the band and sees dollar signs. MTV steals the their souls from the artists and kills everything about the music. The art dies and the band becomes a "sell-out". For most people, their favorite album of a band is the first one they heard. This isn't always the case but it is very true of 80s metal. The hits you hear on 80s stations are rearly the songs that got us off.
If you REALLY want to know what it was like for 80s metal fans and why it blew up, you can't just download individual hits. The list below is a good start of CDs to pick up for beginners. These may not be the most selling albums of these bands, but they are the raw stuff that made us love them:
Motley Crue: Shout At The Devil (Pure, hard, real. No other MC album comes close)
Ratt: Out of the Cellar (Again, blew us away when it came out)
Van Halan: 1984 (Has some hits but the fillers are amazing)
Twisted Sister: Stay Hungry (Once you listen to this a couple of times, "We're not Going to Take it" & "I Wanna Rock" will be your least favorites. Check out "The Price")
Def Leppard: Pyromania (Every teenager owned this in 1983.Blows Hysteria away)
Metallica: Master of Puppets (They have a lot of good music but this is the one that got the world's attention)
Queensryche: Operation Mindcrime (The most underrated metal CD of the decade. Even Rolling Stone raved about this one.)
Bon Jovi: Slippery When Wet (Bon Jovi may seem like cheese, but this was the sent metal into mainstream)
GNR: Appetite for Destruction (If you don't know about this one you must be from another planet)
Iron Maiden: Number of the Beast (These guys never sold out)
Judas Priest: Screaming for Vengence (European metal at its finest)
So if you really want to get into this stuff, don't buy Greatest Hits CDs or you will never understand what it was like to be a metal fan in the 80s. (One exception is Poison, their hits are good but their fillers on every album suck. Greatest Hits would be best for them.) Good Luck.
on July 23, 2006
Well this is coming from a big crue head, and all I can say is if you are a really big crue fan that wants to collect all the crues albums get this one. But if not, and your a new fan looking for a greatest hits collection, please! go for Red White and Crue, it has way more songs only for a little more. Besides this disc is missing some of the most essential tracks from the crue like Live Wire and All in the name of..., Anarchy In the U.K., Piece of your action, Too Young to fall in love, and without you. Besides Red White and Crue has all of the missing tracks of this disc, and 90 percent of the good new songs of this cd.
For the majority of the eighties, the world belonged to Motley Crue, and they did their best to rock it. They also did their best to all but do themselves in. Behind all the drug OD's, celebrity girlfriends, car crashes and head-on's with the law, Motley Crue never lost sight of one thing. They were a rock and roll party band and the party, as long as they were holding it, was always going to be loud and crazy.
"Motley Crue: Greatest Hits" rises above the tabloid fodder and argues eloquently -- then again, maybe eloquent is not a Motley Crue term -- that the Crue were every bit as important as Guns and Roses during the rock wars of the eighties. These were songs written for strip joints and home grown debauchery. "Girls Girls Girls" slides by on a greasy guitar hook that just screams pole dancing, and the notorious video backed that image up to the hilt. "Shout At The Devil" shoves a middle finger at any authority figure to stand in its way, and who else but Motley Crue could turn a near death experience into a song as incredible as "Kickstart My Heart?"
Crue tunes stole shamelessly and brilliantly. "Kickstart" could have popped out from a Sweet or Slade book of riffs, and there are times when Vince Neil shows a debt to Robin Zander of Cheap Trick (especially on "Same Old Situation" and the underrated "Glitter"). They spotted a party tune ("Smoking In The Boys Room") from years away and turned it into their breakout hit. And like all perpetual adolescents, they maintained a boy's club mentality that fostered songs like "Wild Side" and "Don't Go Away."
They also had their hearts on the leather jacketed sleeve side as well. "Home Sweet Home" was the Crue's "Senior Prom" moment. This song and video became so insanely popular that MTV had to forcibly shelve it from the request shows. Like Poison's "Every Rose Has Its Thorn," it breathed life into the oft spun notion that every bad boy has his soft spot.
If you can look at the other dimensions of Motley Crue, you'll see that the band was more than just tabloid gossip with big hair, even if the band did little to stop that reputation. This group of highschool misfits (listen to how plain biologically young they sound in "Too Fast For Love"!) forged a bond that all the fights and girl problems couldn't mar. "Greatest Hits" proves there is a lot to be said about chemistry, and I'm not talking about the kind you find in a hypo. BTW: If you want a good read about rock as an asylum built for four, grab "The Dirt," the Motley Crue story.
on December 4, 2004
I suppose this album gives radio listeners a sufficient dose of the "X-games soundtrack"-style rock by which they know the Crue, and I suppose those who desire a vicarious participation in the Vh-1 version of the eighties may enjoy this collection. However, for a fan who sees an intricate game of subversion at work in Vince Neil's lyrics, the greatest hits album feels like a bit of a sell-out. "All in the Name of...," for example, is one of the great criticisms of the self-aggrandizing eighties rock bands, and it is conspicuously absent from the collection, as is "Porno Star," a scathing indictment of the commodification of the sexual other predicated by the alterity of Internet communication. "Dr. Feelgood," and more subtly "Girls, Girls, Girls," is the closest thing we get to these fierce social commentaries here.
"Greatest Hits" albums can be the most popular tunes, or the truly "greatest" songs of a band's catalog. Sadly, this album follows the latter paradigm. Certainly, Vince Neil is not possessed of the same socio-political fervor as Bono ("Sunday Bloody Sunday") or Brett Michaels ("Something to Believe In"), but he deserves his due.
on February 28, 2004
The Crue to me has always been a band that makes some great bad ass music but I was never big enough on 'em prior to recently to actually buy a CD. However, I decided the Greatest Hits was an essential disk to have and WOW it sure is. Sure, it's missing some great stuff..."Too Young to Fall in Love", "Shout at the Devil" (original) amongst many other great songs they did are not to be found on here. It's also got it's songs that really don't belong on here such as "Glitter" and "Shout at The Devil" (remake). However, other than if I could swap those 2 songs for the other 2 I listed, I'd say this is perfect. Great quality, and the booklet has some great words from the band members. The two new songs on here, "Bitter Pill" and "Enslaved" are amazing and two of the best on the CD, I wasn't expecting that. Bottom line is there's no better single disc of Motley Crue out there, buy it! It personally has left me wanting more which drove me to buy the Greatest Hits DVD a few hours ago. I'm actually gonna check that out right now and probably review it later on here, so look out for my review of that as well!
on March 30, 2005
Motley Crue is my favorite band. I'm a 15 year old girl and all my friends say "Isn't this band, like, old?" but Motley Crue rox. My brother got me really into this band, that's where it happened. The songs on this CD are all awesome. The guys are absolutley amazing. Vince Neil has a great rock voice and Tommy Lee totally kicks butt on the drums. Nikki and Mick also rock. The best songs are "Bitter Pill" "Kickstart My Heart" "Girls, Girls, Girls" and "Smokin' In The Boys Room". All of these songs belong on the greatest hits CD, although I wish "Too Young To Fall In Love" were on here. It definitley deserves to be. This CD is awesome. The Motley reunion concert was here recently and I am so sorry I missed it. Buy this CD!!!!
on August 29, 2006
Okay, hair metal gets it's share of knocks and t'maters by metal snobs, but guys this is toe tapping stuff that still stirs Metaldiva's soul.
There are several of the favorite tracks over the bands' modestly long, admittedly choppy career. However, there are quite a few that were really good and funny like "She Goes Down" from "Dr. Feelgood" for example, that did not make the cut and others like the new "Bitter Pill" and "Enslaved" that never piqued my interest. It's all there from their heyday and all the guys pitched in, if separately and apart from each other, with letters and messages to us and each other.
Motley Crue is living proof that if your band has an excellent drummer-Tommy Lee and talented bassist-Mick Mars and creative guitarist-Nikki Sixx, it doesn't matter what your singer sounds like, you can have a hit making band. However, loving Vince Neil as I do, no one can argue that his former stage presence and his vocals were well matched with the music as a whole. They are also an inspiration to their fans that have fallen into drugs and despair, by going through their separate recoveries and rebirths. All of us watching are hopeful for positive progress with Mick's illness. After all this time on the scene bands like this and their members feel like extended family and you just want to wish them the best.
After this last tour they all seemed to scatter and go on with other endeavors, but the new tour with Aerosmith ought to be a hoot. They all sweat a little more and there's more of them to love, but they are still rockin'.
I have to wonder about more great music we may missed out on and never got written because of all the interpersonal issues and private tragedies that ultimately caused them to fall apart. We will never know, but this is the ultimate snapshot of a better days in which we all received the great gift of their artistic talents,if only for a brief time.
Metaldiva Sez: Great addition to any hair metal collection. It is short and left many great hits out, but is still great to listen to and remember when our hair was blown 4 inches higher than our heads. Great music from a great time in this genre..Get it home today..
I've listened to this album at least three times before reviewing. Artistic freedom with 17 tracks leaping from the disc, takes every fan to the jumping off point to better things. The musicians excel displaying on every cue from start to finish, the tunes that shot straight to the top all under one roof. For example "GIRLS, GIRLS, GIRLS, typical Motley Crue creativity and you know what...you're completely hooked.
Some stand outs are ~ "HOME SWEET, HOME", this alternative ballad gives the listener a real treat, with tight harmony as lyrical genius prevails. The hit single of "PRIMAL SCREAM", takes the group into a frenzy direction, it's so heavy and it rocks to the ceiling. But the highlight by far is "DR. FEELGOOD", the gleam from heavy metal shines through with a contagious beat and tempo, meeting raw energy head on, this is what we've all wanted from the git go!
Total Time: 73:54 on 17 Tracks ~ Hip-O Records 440-067-635-2 ~ (3/04/2003)
on April 18, 2007
Don't get me wrong. I love Motley Crue, but this CD didn't do them justice. I bought it because I was longing to hear "Home Sweet Home", but I should have saved my money and just downloaded the song instead. This CD is not horrible, just not great. In hind sight,I just should have purchased the "Theatre of Pain" album instead.