I bought this Motorola BDA-S1 and the PCT amp to try head to head. BTW, the PCT amp is also sold as a Channel Master product. The specifications of the PCT and Motorola amps are so similar that it seemed likely that they both contain the same integrated circuit.
PCT 1-PORT BI-DIRECTIONAL CABLE TV HDTV AMPLIFIER SIGNAL BOOSTER WITH PASSIVE RETURN PATHThis BDA-S1 certainly has the more impressive enclosure with its large, heavy and black enclosure worthy of "Tim, the tool man Taylor." However, nothing is inside of either product except one integrated circuit chip, so neither product is really superior to the other in that regard. The enclosure on the PCT is perfectly adequate.
Swapping out the Motorola and PCT amps a few times, I found that they performed identically on all stations, whether strong, extremely weak, or middle of the road. Both amps cleaned up the glitches on all of the stations that I expected to receive in pristine condition. Both amps allowed me to add one low power analog station that I couldn't receive without an amp. Neither amp caused any degradation to the quality of any station. Both amps produced identical signal strengths on all channels as measured by the on-screen signal strength meter of my plasma.
The short story is that I've given the PCT amp five stars. This Motorola BDA-S1 gets four stars for delivering the same excellent performance but at a higher price.
Read on if you're interested in the conditions of the comparison. If not, you're done.
I dropped Comcast as of June 1 in favor of broadcast HDTV and Netflix streaming. My antenna farm is located in the loft of a detached garage. Currently, my UHF antenna is the primary antenna, augmented by two VHF antennas that only receive one channel each.
WINEGARD HD9095P UHF High-Gain 39-Element HDTV AntennaAntennacraft Y5-7-13
Winegard YA-1713 High Band VHF HDTV AntennaThere's a lot of wiring loss before the signal gets to the TV. The two VHF antennas are joined in a
Monster Standard RF Splitters For CATV Signals MKII - 2 Way RF Splitter, the output of that is joined with the UHF in a Blonder-Tongue ZUVSJ, followed by 125 feet of RG6 quad shield through the detached garage, then underground to the basement of my house, and then on to the plasma. As the system has grown, I found that I needed to add an antenna amp.
The detached garage doesn't have electricity, so each amp was used in remotely powered mode. The amp being tested was placed just after the Blonder-Tongue ZUVSJ in the garage using a one foot jumper. Neither amp includes a power inserter, so the remote power was provided by using a Pico-Macom HLSJ as a power inserter from inside the basement of the house. I have 100 feet of quad shield between the power inserter and the amp. During the testing, I also had 25 feet of quad shield from the power inserter to the plasma.
Finally, pay no attention to the geniuses who insist that products like the PCT and BDA-S1 signal amplifiers cannot be used with broadcast HDTV signals. A good RF amp is a good RF amp. Both products cover the entire broadcast TV spectrum and then some, and both have an input noise figure of about 2.5 db. Both products deliver exceptional performance as antenna amps, exactly as their specifications would suggest. True, neither product is packaged for direct exposure to precipitation, but that's an entirely different matter from saying that they only work on cable TV. There is a lot of really bad advice in these customer reviews.