11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
GRANDMOTHER'S SECRETS REVEALED!, January 7, 2000
By A Customer
This review is from: Mountain Country Cooking: A Gathering of the Best Recipes from the Smokies to the Blue Ridge (Hardcover)
I purchased this book from in a Memphis bookstore last year and was thrilled with it. It has all the traditional recipes - some of which I had long since forgotten - from my childhood in the Tennessee hills. All the recipes which I have tried so far have resulted in dishes that were like a taste of the past. I highly recommend this book to any displaced Southern mountaineer longing for a taste of home. You won't regret it!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Response to BigBuilder's Comments, January 19, 2006
This review is from: Mountain Country Cooking: A Gathering of the Best Recipes from the Smokies to the Blue Ridge (Hardcover)
BigBuilder states that Mark Sohn is "not of the hills like us." Well, I don't know how long he would have to be in Appalachia to be considered one of us; but if you will look at his web page at www.marksohn.com, you will see that he has been living in the hills of Appalachia for 30 years.
And more than that, he taught Appalachian Studies classes at Pikeville College for ten years. Every semester he taught these classes, he had his students bring in traditional Appalachian foods for a dinner.
He has eaten our food for 30 years, and on top of that he is a chef. He also writes columns about food for his local newspaper and was an Appalachian television chef every week for eleven years.
If being here 30 years and having such high credentials don't make Mark Sohn qualified to write a cookbook about our food, then what would? Just being born here? I was born here and have lived most of my life here, and I could never do what Mark Sohn has done. I learn from him. I enjoy reading his cookbooks because they help me to understand my own culture.
BigBuilder's comments were not considered helpful by other Amazon readers. If you look at the other entries you will see that people have found the comments of others to be far more helpful than they have BigBuilder's. He has a right to his opinion, of course; but if not being "of the hills like us" means Mark Sohn can't write about anything having to do with our area, then where are we supposed to get books on the stars or the moon or Jupiter or Mars, or even the oceans or caves or deserts right here on earth? Nobody is "of the seas" or "of the caves" or "of Mars" to tell us about what they are like.
And I personally enjoyed the healthy alternatives. Some people want the food but they just can't eat it the way the rest of us can. They deserve an alternative, and Mark Sohn has been considerate enough to take the time to test low-fat and low-salt alternatives and give them to those who need them. I appreciate that.
One more point: This book is a James Beard Foundation cookbook of the year nominee for 1997, and I highly recommend it and hope you will buy it and find out for yourself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Comments and Response to Billy Turnbull, January 26, 2006
This review is from: Mountain Country Cooking: A Gathering of the Best Recipes from the Smokies to the Blue Ridge (Hardcover)
I have tried many of Sohn's recipes and I have never found them bland. I am delighted to say that I believe you will enjoy this book and you will come back again and again to try the recipes. I recall having dinner at Sohn's house once and asking his permission to remain at his table when he had to go teach a class. He graciously allowed me to stay, asking only that I lock up when I left. I am not a big eater. I have generally tended to eat in order to live. But I was ravenous at Mark Sohn's table because the food he presented was incredibly delicious.
Now, I would like to make a few brief comments on the review of Billy Turnbull. He states that this book is a contrived presentation by a man from Oregon who steals recipes from the people of Appalachia. He goes on to say that the recipes are bland. Either he is saying that Sohn's recipes are not the same as those in the Appalachian Mountains (and therefore couldn't be stolen) or he is saying that the recipes of those who live in Appalachia are bland.
First of all, the recipes have been handed down from one generation to another. We share with one another in the mountains of Appalachia and are happy to enrich the lives of our neighbors and friends by allowing them the privilege of enjoying the foods we grew up on--whether our neighbors and friends are from Oregon, as Sohn is, or across the next hill. Mark Sohn had the right--and indeed we should be grateful to him for it--to collect these recipes for us. He has given credit in his book where credit is due. He has not pretended to make up these recipes.
Please don't be turned away by one or two bad reviews. You will not regret buying this book, and I am confident that you will keep it close to your kitchen where you can enjoy Sohn's recipes for many years to come.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No