From School Library Journal
Grade 1-3-A rural town nestled in the Rockies receives the same treatment that the Geiserts accorded to two previous locales in Prairie Town (1998) and River Town (1999, both Houghton). From the first snowfall through a calendar year and back to winter again, careful observers can follow small-town life through both annual celebrations and the mundane comings and goings of residents and visitors. A chimney fire, a family with an unlucky blue car, and a bank robbery are a few of the threads that weave their way through the fabric of daily life; a blizzard, the Fourth of July and Heritage Days supply seasonal diversions. The final page summarizes events and encourages readers to follow specific subplots. Thoughtful viewers can discover that while mining, heavy snows, and hikers are unique to the mountains, much of what goes on day-to-day is common to all communities. Etchings enhanced with watercolors provide sweeping panoramas, often on double-page spreads; perspectives include bird's-eye views as well as above and belowground cross sections. The present-tense text occasionally provides helpful explanations for the already-informative pictures but is often simply a redundant one-sentence commentary. Libraries owning the other Geisert books will want to purchase this for a compare-and-contrast exercise in community life, although the many intricate details prohibit group sharing. For other collections, it's a secondary purchase.
Carol Ann Wilson, Westfield Memorial Library, NJ Copyright 2000 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Continuing the quiet, detailed depiction of towns in different geographic settings they began in
Prairie Town (1998) and
River Town , the Geiserts show life over the course of a year in a community nestled in the mountains. There are car accidents on slippery roads, bank robbers using old mining tunnels to steal from a vault, a Fourth of July parade, and myriad other vignettes for careful eyes to look at. The text is brief, just one or two lines per page, and pleasant if occasionally stiff. This time Arthur Geisert gets a chance to use his etchings to depict night scenes, and he sharply contrasts the hazy, gray night with the crisp, bright details of the snow-covered town in the morning light. The final page includes clues to other things to look for in the pictures; children are sure to stumble across lots of little stories along the way.
Susan Dove Lempke