From School Library Journal
Starred Review. Grade 5 Up–Picking up where
Fall 1152 (Archaia, 2007) left off,
Winter 1152 follows the darkening adventures of the brave troops of the Mouse Guard as they battle the elements, predators, and even other mice in order to secure their way of life. The high-quality artwork found in the first volume carries over into this one. The narrative, familiar to anyone with even a passing knowledge of Tolkien, is fast paced and compelling, if overly reliant on exposition. Due to the rich history and detailed setting of the Mouse Guard world, readers will want to pick up the first volume before tackling this one. Comparisons to Brian Jacques's Redwall (Philomel) are unavoidable and deserved, but Petersen's artwork and concise storytelling set
Mouse Guard apart. Combining a tale of action, romance, comedy, and tragedy with the graphic-novel format results in a top-notch work with wide appeal.
–Douglas P. Davey, Halton Hills Public Library, Ontario, Canada Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
The autumnal tones of Fall 1152 (2007) shift to blinding flurries of white and gray as winter descends on the harsh world of the Mouse Territories. Though the plot is slight, the steely determinism of the Mouse Guard warriors wielding wicked weaponry in dangerous environs lends to the story the gravity of a heroic epic. But the primary strength of this Eisner Award–winning series lies in its majestic visualization of intricately rendered settings and arresting perspective shifts. There’s darkness and violence aplenty in this miniature world, tempered by no small measure of triumph. Grades 5-8. --Ian Chipman