57 of 58 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Cast Member says there's no Magic, July 20, 2009
This review is from: Mouse Trap: Memoir of a Disneyland Cast Member (Paperback)
I worked for Disneyland for 3 years in 1994, 1995, & 1996, right in the same timeframe as Mr. Yee here, but I'm horribly disappointed in his book.
When your halfway thru a book about DL of all things, and you catch yourself saying "well I hope it picks up in the 2nd half," you know you're in trouble. And for having worked at DL for over 10 years, I was aghast at Mr. Yee's drought of amusing ancedotes, personal observation, or heartfelt feeling. Having worked myself in Outdoor Vending for a mere 3 years, I could fill one chapter with more entertaining stories than Mr. Yee did in his entire book, but lets talk specifics:
Simply, Mr. Yee doesnt know how to write a memoir. His previous books are recitations of Disneyland fact, and this book reads exactly the same. For example, he waxes long and obsessively about procedures: procedures for changing costume, procedures for turning in money, procedures for checking in, etc etc etc. This stuff is not entertaining or amusing even when you're THERE, let alone as a non-DL employee. There are no punchlines to these procedures, no amusing asides, no "and then there was this ONE day..." nothing but flat delivery of bare fact, reduced to its most flavorless recitation of events. My man, thats not a memoir, its a Tech Manual. Such information would be helpful in the hand of a new hire, and I might encourage DL to distribute new copies of this book to its new hires for exactly that purpose. But for capturing Disneyland magic- its all dead on arrival.
Mr Yee's editing style depends on a lot on bare fact. Even when he eventually (1/2 way thru the book) gets around to his personal experiences, its easily summarized with "this happened and then this happened and then this happened" with zero observation or introspection into those events in his day in a life. There's no FEELING. There's little connection to why such and such makes Disneyland a unique place to work, and no reason why we're supposed to care one way or the other. (Its like being asked to look at a black and white photo of fireworks and then assuming we already know how colorful they are. There's a great deal of "you had to be there" going on here).
Yee's foundational problem is that his ancedotes just arent all that funny. Part of that is an unfair complaint, as he worked in an unentertaining part of the park, the foods division. The part of the book where he gets around to describing bad guest behavior (the part that singlehandedly defines and elevates David Keonig's Mouse Tales) is easily interchangeable with any restaurant anywhere in the country. The chapters where he talks about working backstage suffer from the aforementioned "I did this and then I did this" syndrome, delivered with zero color, suspense, or flavor. And a part that may define this book, where he says "the most oddball thing I ever did was deliver desks to a bosses house..." made me gasp. (My man, I've worked at Disneyland too. I've seen oddball. I've heard oddball. I've DONE oddball. And brother, that is definitely NOT oddball.)
What then, was I hoping for?
Well how many things are totally UNIQUE to this place? Why did Mr. Yee quit after working there so long? Why did he then come back to work a different division? (That entire process occurs in under a sentence).
Why did Mr. Yee quit again? After you work for someplace for a decade, you CANNOT simply say "well something else came up." Dude this was a decade out of your life and you just up and quit? Thats what a memoir is for, to REVEAL your feelings, to give up the dirty secrets, to wax poetic for pages at a time on your motivations and future dreams. When I read "I quit" to be frank I felt cheated.
Ditto for the heavily hyped (on the back cover) observations about 9/11, which end up being a page and a half TWO PAGES FROM THE END OF THE BOOK.
So lets put it this way:
Mr Yee, were you there for the 40th Anniversary Cast Photo in Main Street, 1995? I certainly was. Remember the cheers? The screams? The thousands upon thousands of friends and soul mates all packed together into one perfect moment of camaraderie? Captured forever on film? I have that photo on my wall and will cherish it forever. THATS what we want to read about. THATS where the Disney magic was. I certainly have an ancedote or two from that day. That you had nothing to say at all was extremely disappointing. Either you werent there (aghast), or you attended and felt absolutely nothing (MORE aghast).
Now I've read Mr. Yee's 101 DL facts book, and thats competent enough. Stick with that. As a castmember hoping to recover old memories from a place I hold in a special place in my heart, this book offered nothing. Maybe I just worked in a more interesting department (indeed, for as a member of ODV I was shunted to every conceivable area of the park on a daily basis, and was the first Ambassador to the World that many guests met), but if I regret even buying a book then there's not much left to defend.
I'm sure Mr. Yee is a nice enough fellow, and as we worked there at the same time there's every chance we ran into each other. But this isnt his best work and people looking for captured Disney magic wont find it here.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The happiest place on earth just got... boring., July 5, 2008
This review is from: Mouse Trap: Memoir of a Disneyland Cast Member (Paperback)
Mousetrap is definitely an informative tale. The problem is it just isn't a very exciting one. It's not the authors fault entirely. He wasn't a captain of The Jungle Cruise or a driver of The Monorail. Just a manager and crew member at a New Orleans Square restaurant for most of his DL stay, so most of his writing is on his experience there. He writes in details about his experience becoming a Disneyland "Cast member" and all the classes, policies, procedures, and day to day operations at the park we don't get to see. This is all well and good but by the time I was half way through this book I felt exhausted and, sadly, bored. A detailed explanation of every backstage area of the park, no matter how boring or mundane it was? Spending page after page after page talking about uniform and locker procedures? It was a chore to read, and there just weren't enough interesting facts or new information about the behind the scenes workings of DL to keep me that interested. I'd recommend it for hardcore DL fans only. Interesting idea for a book but too many facts drag it down and make it lose the Disney magic.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Auto-bore-ography of a restaurant cast member., August 17, 2008
This review is from: Mouse Trap: Memoir of a Disneyland Cast Member (Paperback)
It actually pains me to actually write a bad review on this item because Yee is so enthusiastic about telling his story. However, I actually felt cheated out of three days of my life, that I spent reading this book.(I continued reading it out of sheer morbid curiousity) I have Yee's other two books and found them to be very entertaining and informative. I expected more of the same. I was looking very forward to this book and actually pre-purchased it. Kevin Yee makes an honest effort in this book; I just think that perhaps he's not a very exciting person. He was a lead in a New Orleans Square restaurant. The book is centered on his microcosm of Disneyland. I'm not sure there could be a more boring area of Disneyland to chronicle than the restaurant division. The book describes mundane details of the behind the scenes areas, none of which is exciting. (I don't really care how you go about exchanging pants at the costuming counter.) Yee also uses so many codes and acronyms, that I felt I needed a decoder ring. I expected hidden secrets of Disneyland, or maybe some behind the scenes dirt. (Something like the book Mouse Tales. Which is a worthwhile purchase) What I got was to see what Kevin Yee's timecard looks like, and what a performance review looks like. Yee actually kept all of these items and pictures them in his book. (kind of weird) This is more Yee's auto-bore-ography than it is about Disneyland. It was a huge disappointment. In the final chapter of the book, Yee even states "There are thousands of CMs and former CMs that have more interesting anecdotes than I do, and I hope this book inspires them to record their stories as well." It's almost as if Yee knows that the book is terrible and this is his way of apologizing. I wouldn't waste my time with this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No