Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
AuthorZone.Com Book Review, August 1, 2003
This review is from: A Mouth Full of Shell (Paperback)
Betsy Craig began her career in the little Kansas town Spring Water where as a young reporter she quickly learned that small town mentality and the 'good old boy' syndrome was alive, well and going to cause her trouble. Betsy's boss Bob Parker is unreasonable in his firing of Betsy because a local rowdy muttered a swear word into the open mic during an interview. Parker tells Betsy that were she a man the incident would never have taken place. When Betsy seeks legal recourse she finds herself facing a brick wall and decides to leave Kansas for the opportunities she hopes will be greater in Pennsylvania. Fourteen years pass and Dr Craig, Professor at Mountain View University is up for tenure. Betsy has taught journalism and broadcasting at the school for six years, has begun a growing relationship with the Dean of English, Todd Baker and feels her life is on a positive track. She is aghast when the retention Committee turn down her tenure because her immediate boss Dr Steve Harding has not sent a letter supporting tenure for Betsy. Betsy is dismayed to learn that Steve's supervisor Dean Chambers is determined to get rid of her and has put pressure on Steve to withhold his support for her. Betsy suspects that her relationship with Todd may be part of the underlying cause for what has happened. Chambers' secretary is a woman who would like to continue the relationship she and Todd enjoyed prior to Betsy. As if this were not enough Betsy is soon scrutinized because of attention she receives from ROTC director Mike Kelly. Mountain View is a borough steeped in its heritage. Many of the citizens have lived in the area for generations and make themselves part of every segment of the Community. The town is controlled by The Founders and Betsy is not welcomed by several of the more puissant of the present day family members. From the outright maneuvering of Anna to machination of supposed friend Steve Harding Betsy learns that she is being forced out. Back in Kansas she chose to leave and find another job. At that time Betsy decided that life is like a hard boiled egg. At times we must just eat a little shell along with the good stuff. Here in Pennsylvania she decides to stay and fight. Betsy is a might wary: her last foray against discrimination was not a success. Gives the reader a glimpse into the lives of many small communities run by the descendants of the founders where rumor mongering, willful incompetents and downright ugly people hold sway over others. We are led to realize that the fine line between victim and victor may be mighty thin. Filled with intense imagery and absorbing characters sure to keep the reader turning pages A Mouth Full of Shell is a well wrought work showing some of the problems to be encountered by a determined woman in a male dominated, tight knit world. Writer Gotsch has produced characters who are well developed, often not very likeable and very convincing. Betsy has to be tough, she is a sympathetic character the reader can empathize with as she struggles to take charge of her own life. A Mouth Full of Shell will grip the reader from the first line and carry along on a worrisome ride to the final paragraph as we grapple with the unfairness often facing Betsy. It is not a book for everyone, those who do not care for a feminist viewpoint, or think that 'good old boy rule' is best will not care for the work. Discerning readers who do enjoy a well wrought tale filled with a bit of social message, nicely crafted settings and characters, vibrant dialogue at times hard hitting and gritty and a strong woman who does win in the end will find the book to their taste. Reviewed by: molly martin
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
AuthorZone.Com Book Review, August 1, 2003
This review is from: A Mouth Full of Shell (Paperback)
Betsy Craig began her career in the little Kansas town Spring Water where as a young reporter she quickly learned that small town mentality and the 'good old boy' syndrome was alive, well and going to cause her trouble. Betsy's boss Bob Parker is unreasonable in his firing of Betsy because a local rowdy muttered a swear word into the open mic during an interview. Parker tells Betsy that were she a man the incident would never have taken place. When Betsy seeks legal recourse she finds herself facing a brick wall and decides to leave Kansas for the opportunities she hopes will be greater in Pennsylvania. Fourteen years pass and Dr Craig, Professor at Mountain View University is up for tenure. Betsy has taught journalism and broadcasting at the school for six years, has begun a growing relationship with the Dean of English, Todd Baker and feels her life is on a positive track. She is aghast when the retention Committee turn down her tenure because her immediate boss Dr Steve Harding has not sent a letter supporting tenure for Betsy. Betsy is dismayed to learn that Steve's supervisor Dean Chambers is determined to get rid of her and has put pressure on Steve to withhold his support for her. Betsy suspects that her relationship with Todd may be part of the underlying cause for what has happened. Chambers' secretary is a woman who would like to continue the relationship she and Todd enjoyed prior to Betsy. As if this were not enough Betsy is soon scrutinized because of attention she receives from ROTC director Mike Kelly. Mountain View is a borough steeped in its heritage. Many of the citizens have lived in the area for generations and make themselves part of every segment of the Community. The town is controlled by The Founders and Betsy is not welcomed by several of the more puissant of the present day family members. From the outright maneuvering of Anna to machination of supposed friend Steve Harding Betsy learns that she is being forced out. Back in Kansas she chose to leave and find another job. At that time Betsy decided that life is like a hard boiled egg. At times we must just eat a little shell along with the good stuff. Here in Pennsylvania she decides to stay and fight. Betsy is a might wary: her last foray against discrimination was not a success. Gives the reader a glimpse into the lives of many small communities run by the descendants of the founders where rumor mongering, willful incompetents and downright ugly people hold sway over others. We are led to realize that the fine line between victim and victor may be mighty thin. Filled with intense imagery and absorbing characters sure to keep the reader turning pages A Mouth Full of Shell is a well wrought work showing some of the problems to be encountered by a determined woman in a male dominated, tight knit world. Writer Gotsch has produced characters who are well developed, often not very likeable and very convincing. Betsy has to be tough, she is a sympathetic character the reader can empathize with as she struggles to take charge of her own life. A Mouth Full of Shell will grip the reader from the first line and carry along on a worrisome ride to the final paragraph as we grapple with the unfairness often facing Betsy. It is not a book for everyone, those who do not care for a feminist viewpoint, or think that 'good old boy rule' is best will not care for the work. Discerning readers who do enjoy a well wrought tale filled with a bit of social message, nicely crafted settings and characters, vibrant dialogue at times hard hitting and gritty and a strong woman who does win in the end will find the book to their taste. Reviewed by: molly martin
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
MIDWEST BOOK REVIEW, April 18, 2003
This review is from: A Mouth Full of Shell (Paperback)
"A Mouth Full Of Shell" starts out with Betsy Craig's life 14 years earlier in the town of Spring Water, Kansas. Betsy was a young reporter working a story for a sports event, when the unthinkable happens. A hard nosed troublemaker speaks the fearful F word in the microphone for all the world to hear. Betsy's boss, Bob Parker, fires her, deciding that because she was a woman, she was not capable of handling the job, citing that if she were a man, this would have never happened. Betsy tries to take legal action, but finds the odds are against her. She leaves to pursue her career elsewhere. The story takes up with Betsy living in Mountain View, Pennsylvania. She is now Dr. Craig and a Professor at the Mountain View University. Betsy is up for tenure and this is where her problems begin as she awaits her letter from the Communication Personnel Committee.
Mountain View is a town that is bundled in heritage. Its people have been there for generations and make their presence known in all aspects of the Community. From Professors, to Judges and right down the line; the town is controlled by the Founders. Betsy is not seen as a welcome addition to their Community by several of the more powerful family members. One, in particular is Anna, who has a deep dislike for Betsy and who will stop at nothing to see her driven out of town. All good stories need an evil figure, and Anna fits this bill quite nicely. Of course those who Betsy thinks are friends may not be as favorable to her as she hopes. Let's take Dr. Steve Harding and his wife Ellen. Betsy had counted on his vote for her tenure, so why has he reneged? Certainly he could not be in cohorts with Dean Chambers in wanting Betsy gone. Could he? And if so why? And what was he promised in return? Ellen seems nice enough and appears to like Betsy, or does she? Perhaps her future and her comforts are more important than doing what is right concerning Betsy. The plot thickens! Ms. Gotsch weaves into her story a love life for Betsy, although there is question just whom she will end up with, right to the end of the story. I'm still wondering! Will it be the handsome Todd Baker, who is both a Professor and colleague of hers? Of course, if she should choose to be with him, she will have to deal with the troublesome Susie Kugel, who also has her sites on Todd.
Or perhaps the distinguished ROTC Instructor Mike Kelly... indeed she seems to have caught his fancy. But just who is the secret military man that Betsy turned down that night and what did he teach her about love and life? You'll have to read this novel to find out. I'll tell you this much, Betsy does not run away from this fight. But is she able to win against an entire town? Or will she have to abandon her dreams and again seek employment elsewhere? A Mouth Full Of Shell is a good read, especially for women.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
