From School Library Journal
Grade 2-4–Using a wooden block for a writer's block and twisted metaphors to describe puzzling punctuation, the kids of W. T. Melon Elementary School endure wacky takeoffs of third-grade situations in order to reap some thinly veiled lessons on good behavior. Paul comes down with a case of Mouth Moths, little pink insects that live in children's Adam's apples, and the only cure to keep the lemon-flavored bugs from flying out of his mouth seems to be to raise his hand. Zachary, who has probably never heard of The Old Gray Mare, rides a wild gray chair in order to tame his restlessness and inability to sit still at his desk. Test-taking can be particularly stressful without the addition of a trench-coat-wearing shadow from the Iowa Test Site that appears in the closet near Loren. Other strange men who appear only to the children include Anta Claus from Antarctica, who checks for students' names on his can't list, singling out those who never try. While most of the ideas here are clever, early-chapter-book readers are likely to get lost in the language. Illustrations of the teacher and the custodian in the sporadic spot art are so much alike that kids will wonder if they are actually the same person in different clothes. Students will choose to stay away from this classroom at the end of the hall, as should librarians with limited budgets.
–Cheryl Ashton, Amherst Public Library, OH Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
The third entry in Evans' classroom-tales collection presents more zany, mysterious happenings in the "classroom at the end of the hall." Some third-graders are having a hard time. Paul, who can't stop blurting things out, discovers that he has icky "mouth moths"; Zachary has difficulty staying seated until his chair suddenly becomes a bucking bronco. While creatively presenting familiar challenges, the nine stories are both entertaining and supportive. Small, witty cartoons add punch to the selections.
Shelle RosenfeldCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved