Author of the very useful directory Musicals! ( LJ 6/15/84) and of the discography Braodway on Record (Greenwood, 1987), Lynch defines movie musicals as feature-length films where musical pieces relate to the plot. Consequently, he excludes concert documentaries, dance films , and filmed operas. He lists commercially marketed recordings alphabetically , appending to each its own lists of technical credits (composer, lyricist, musical director), casts, and musical numbers with performers. A chronological list of the films is also presented, as are two indexes: one for performer and one for technical credits. The great omission is a song index; for that, users are referred to other sources. For larger collections, this would be a worthy supplement; for those finding Broadway on Record useful, a companion.
- Bonnie Jo Dopp, District of Columbia P.L.Copyright 1989 Reed Business Information, Inc.
“Lynch, New York Public Library music curator and author of Musicals! and Broadway on Record, offers this cinema companion to his Broadway discography. He retains the format, listing 666 film musicals alphabetically by title. Each entry includes the film's production company; release year; original label and number, recording format; major composer, lyricist, and conductor, cast members who perform on the recording; and notes (e.g., dubbed vocals). The volume closes with a film chronology, performer index, and technical staff index. Lynch cites Jack Raymond's Show Music on Record, Clive Hirschhorn's Hollywood Musical (1981), and Stanley Green's Encyclopedia of the Musical Film as references, although he provides more data per recording. Overall, Lynch puts forth a curious amalgamation, including Valley of the Dolls and I'll Cry Tomorrow while excluding Private Buckeroo and This Is Spinal Tap. Broadening the range of works would make this a first-rate directory. . . . Recommended for general academic library collections that emphasize the performing arts.”–
Choice“This accurate and straightforward discography covers 60 years' worth of motion picture musicals that have been recorded commercially and are currently available. There have been numerous musicals filmed and recorded more than once--such as four renditions of The Threepenny Opera and three each of The Jazz Singer, St. Louis Blues, and The Desert Song. These multiple recordings are among the 666 different albums included here. The discography consists of an alphabetical list of recordings, each of which notes the film company and the year of release for the film on which the record is based. Each entry also includes the record company; record number; credits for music, lyrics, and musical direction; the cast members; and a list of songs and the name(s) of the cast singing each song. (Dubbers are also mentioned.) If the song was not in the film on which the record is based, it is so noted. Spoken dialogue, when it appears on a record, is also noted. A chronology of films, an alphabetical performer index, and a technical credits index are appended. . . . A companion volume to the author's previous Broadway on Record, this discography is suggested for libraries that found the earlier volume useful--performing arts libraries, most academic libraries supporting programs in film or music, and large public libraries.”–
Reference Books Bulletin“Movie Musicals on Record is a discography of the songs used in movie musicals and the singers who performed them on commercially available albums. Covering the 60 years from The Jazz Singer (1927) to Three Amigos (1987), more than 600 albums are covered as well as more than 6,000 songs. This useful reference book includes the identification of singers who dubbed the voices of stars and all the composers and lyricists involved in Hollywood's factory-like production of musicals in the 1930s and 1940s. There are indices by performer and technology used. Lynch is a retired librarian who obviously loves to compile helpful lists.”–
CAST/Communication Booknotes“One way of bringing a successful stage musical show to a large audience is to create a film version of it. Richard Chigley Lynch observes this logical progression by creating this companion volume to his Broadway on Record (Greenwood, 1987). A total of 666 recordings of movie musicals are analyzed in entries that list record labels and numbers (with references to reissues and available compact discs), songwriters, musical directors, cast members, other performers (such as Marni Nixon, who provided Natalie Wood's singing voice in West Side Story but did not appear in the film), and musical numbers with their performers. Occasional notes provide additional information of interest such as the availability of additional soundtrack cuts or the inclusion of spoken dialogue on the recording. The large number of entries make this book fairly complete. Lynch's working definition of a movie musical requires that "musical numbers must actually be performed in the film and must in some way be concerned with the film's plot" (Introduction). It generally doesn't include films with fewer than three musical numbers, dance and opera films, short films, and foreign films that were not popular in America. "Generally" is the operative word here as Purple Rain, 10, and many Astaire/Rogers films are included, while Eddie and the Cruisers, Flashdance and Footloose were left out. In addition to the basic discography, Lynch provides a chronology of films and indexes to performers and technicians (songwriters/musical directors). Claiming that an index to the 6,500 song titles would be unwieldy, the author refers us to Clive Hirschorn's The Hollywood Musical (Crown, 1981) and Nat Shapiro and Bruce Pollack's Popular Music, 1920-1979 (Gale, 1985). Richard Lewine and Alfred Simon's Songs of the Theater (H.=tW. Wilson, 1984) largely does the trick, too. None of these volumes quite duplicate the scope and content of Movie Musicals on Record, thus allowing Lynch's book to contribute uniquely to public and academic library performing arts reference literature.--Donald W. Maxwell, Audio-visual Librarian, Carmel Clay Public Library, Carmel, Indiana.”–
RQ