41 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Intro - very newbie friendly, October 16, 2006
This review is from: Moving to Ubuntu Linux (Paperback)
I received 3 Ubuntu titles and thought it might be useful to compare them. Ubuntu is a fairly recent Linux distribution that strives to be usable out of the box, with strong support. It has deep pockets and a thriving community behind it. I admire a lot of the design choices that went into Ubuntu, such as limiting the use of the all-powerful root account, which can get people into trouble. The bare-bones server install is the cleanest Linux server I've seen - *no* open ports, minimal services. Just enough to log in at a console and then install what you want. On the other hand, if you want a LAMP server (Linux, Apache, MySQL, and PHP - the most popular combination on the internet), that's a one button install! Brilliant!
I think all three books are pretty good, and your choice will depend on your technical level and religious ferver. If you are uncomfortable with computers, I think _Moving to Ubuntu_ is your best choice. If you are somewhat comfortable and into the philosophy behind Ubuntu, _the Official Ubuntu book_ is your best choice. If you are unintimidated by the topic, _Ubuntu Unleashed_ has the most detailed technical coverage. You can get a free, fully-functional installation and livecd just for asking, or downloading. The only thing I don't like is the iptables firewall. A "linux for everyone" needs an easier firewall to deal with. (I love pf, written for OpenBSD and now showing up on other systems.)
This is the most approachable of the three books. Gagne has an enthusiastic, conversational, even narrative approach to the material. The audience is people stuck using Windows desktops because they don't know any Linux nerds willing to help them. I think it's a terrific book, and it showed me some cool things to do on the desktop. I use Linux mainly for servers.
It covers productivity apps very well. About my only quibble: he introduces GAIM, for chatting on various systems, and then introduces another tool for IRC, which GAIM handles just fine. The multimedia coverage is the best of the three books. The section on games is good as well, and I like his approach of getting a teenage nephew to recommend the best Linux games.
Like Ubuntu Unleashed, this book has a lot of material lifted from earlier works. I don't think that's a bad thing if the material lifted is generic. In this case, Gagne uses material from the slightly earlier _Moving to Linux_, which mostly used on one (non-Ubuntu) distro and mentioned some differences. Unlike _Ubuntu Unleashed_, the material was applied carefully. They even updated some things that didn't have to be, like an illustration in _MTL_ that had a graphic with a logo reading, "Welcome to Linux". In _MTU_ they cared enough to change it to "Welcome to Ubuntu". The chapters on Open Office are the same - and that's appropriate because Open Office IS the same. The GIMP is the same. So I think it's appropriate for the chapters to be the same.
Gagne pays some attention to the Ubuntu community ethos, but he's mostly concerned with showing someone unfamiliar with the system how to do the things they are most likely to want to do.
A good book, GREAT for newbies.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wow! If you're interesed in Linux this is the book for you., November 30, 2006
This review is from: Moving to Ubuntu Linux (Paperback)
I don't quite know where to begin with this book except to say "Wow!" Marcel Gagné has captured the spirit of Ubuntu in this book. This is quite possibly the best beginner's book I've ever read. Marcel's style of writing is enough to capture even a techno neophyte such as my wife. Not to say my wife's incapable of using technology but she's resistant. I guess you could say, from all of the years I've been working on something and she's said "Are you coming to bed?" and I reply "Yea, in just a second" then four hours later I attempt to slip into bed unnoticed, that she's developed a distain for anything related to technology.
After reading the first two chapters of this book I handed the book to my wife and said "Here read this" she took the book and reluctantly began to read. After chapter one she was hooked! The next day I ended up handing her a laptop and using this book she fully installed Ubuntu Linux 6.06 by herself. Let me tell you this is huge now here's what she had to say...
"Marcel Gagné has an amazing way of bringing you into the Ubuntu world with humor and knowledge without the boredom of the typical user's manual
This book has easy to understand terms even for the inexperienced user. Step-by-Step directions provide a seamless move to Ubuntu Linux without the need to remove your existing operating system giving the reader the ability to try Ubuntu Linux fear free. Quick tips and user support information are also included.
I was most impressed by the wealth of information included in this book from the large community support groups that exists for Linux users to using windows based products and features hassle free. The ease of use was surprising to me. No complicated acronyms or programming codes just straight forward how to.
Moving to Ubuntu Linux has provided the reader with a virus and bug free operating system with all the extras we use everyday. I would recommend this book to anyone who has ever had a PC crash or has gotten the blue screen of death both professional and new users alike."
Another satisfied computer user.
Best,
Steve
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very good for linux newbies, April 5, 2007
This review is from: Moving to Ubuntu Linux (Paperback)
Great information for setting up Ubuntu for a Linux newbie. I would get the latest version of the os though, the one in the book is out of date. Since it's a free download this is no big deal. I'm now a happy dual booting user, and use Linux 90% of the time.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
