14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Predictable, and not in a good way, April 17, 2008
This review is from: Mozart's Ghost: A Novel (Hardcover)
We don't ask much from our romantic novels and movies. We know how they're going to end; we just want to be entertained with a few clever twists along the way. But aside from the very nice inclusion of a celebrity ghost, this by-the-numbers romance is infuriatingly predictable. And it's almost fatally hampered by the fact that Anna, a spirit medium and the main character, is insufferably, unrelentingly cranky and none too bright. She's her own worst enemy so often that it becomes hard to root for her, and even harder to see why the other characters seem to like her. The devices and complications that keep the lovers apart are uninspired, the supporting characters are nice but lightly sketched, and there's no sparkling dialogue or emotional energy to make us think that the two would-be lovers are brought together by anything except mutual loneliness. Add to that an unavoidable suspicion that the author is cynically outlining the film adaptation as she goes along, and a last page resolution that feels rushed and unsatisfying. There's nice writing here, breezy and humorous at times, but it doesn't make up for a dull ride.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
14 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
More Ghastly Than Ghostly, March 15, 2008
This review is from: Mozart's Ghost: A Novel (Hardcover)
Anna is thirty-something, solitary and a bit waspish. She has left Kalamazoo, Michigan and this novels finds her living in The Big Apple. By day she is a teacher. By night she is a medium who helps her clients connect to 'the other side' and converse with their dearly departed.
One day,late for work she leaves her apartment only to find the lobby blocked by the arrival of a giant grand piano, its owner a giant red headed pianist who is moving into her building. Later she discovers his name is Edward. Suddenly Anna finds her concentration broken by the red head's constant practicing. He has arrived in New York to intensively practice for an important piano competition. The noise interferes with her contact with 'the other side'. In addition she finds herself intruded upon by the ghost of Mozart who gloats over the brilliant performance of Edward and urges her 'to be nice to him'. Even worse the pianist seems to be everywhere, taking up her regular booth at her favorite Greek diner, impringing upon her use of the laundry room, even befriending her annoying brother who has temporarily moved in with her.
Will Anna and Edward find true love? Will Edward win the competition? You can easily guess the answers. The novel is endlessly repetitive. Anna can't sleep, she can't share her Edward plight with her drop-dead gorgeous best friend Stacy. She makes repeated trip to the basement to do her laundary, tabloid papers in hand, or makes trips to the Greek diner as the plot moves forward at a snail's pace. She endlessly ruminates about whether she should reveal her night-time profession to Edward. Should she tell him? If she does will he still love her? Not hard to figure out the end.
Along the tedious way we are treated to an assortment of cliched characters -a jolly gay principal, his mean spirted gay friend who is a clairvoyant, an exotic bi-sexual man named Tommy who is constantly flirting with Anna and trying to get her into bed, the friendly waiter at the diner, and of course the gorgeous best friend. Interspersed with these are juvenile letters that Edwards sends home to a childless couple who are financing his stay in New York while he works towards winning the competition. One cliche is piled upon another.
It takes half the novel for Edward and Anna to get together: another quarter of the novel for Anna to obsess over calling Edward after their first liasion, and the final quarter of the book to finally tell Edward her secret profession.
The fact that this dreadful mess was written by a woman who is considered a master at leading others to fulfill their creative potential makes matters even worse. Save your money and your eyesight. Don't buy this book. I wish Amazon made it possible to give this zero stars.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
An enjoyable, light read, April 6, 2008
This review is from: Mozart's Ghost: A Novel (Hardcover)
I have never read anything by Julia Cameron, but I saw a rather positive review of this book in a magazine and decided to purchase it. Being a music teacher, I was interested to see how Mozart was portrayed. I have to say the book was a nice, quick read - and it was enjoyable. I have to disagree with a review I read that stated that a whole bunch of the book was dedicated to her agonizing over whether to tell Edward about being a medium or not. Yes it is a major point toward the end of the book (not a majority of the book), but it is a question that is true to the story, and is true to the character and her history. The characters are enjoyable as is the overall story. I found Mozart to be rather funny, though certainly nothing new is presented about him (which wasn't the point of the book anyway!) I recommend this book as light reading for those who just enjoy spending time with a good book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No