From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 3?Four people who love to work in their gardens live at the end of Blackberry Lane. Mr. Munsing has seedless watermelons, Ms. Elwood grows pumpkins, Mr. Febold sunflowers, and Mr. Carey has holes in his plants. His neighbors all have ideas on how to get rid of the snails that are causing the problem, but Mr. Carey rejects their well-meaning advice gently, saying: "I see it in a different light." One tranquil night, the sleepless neighbors venture out and discover Mr. Carey's secret-with their glistening trails and quiet munching, the snails make the garden a magical place in the moonlight. In fact, it's just right for sitting on the porch and relaxing, which is what the four friends do. Karas's childlike pastel illustrations done in gouache, acrylic, and pencil are marvelous. They blend perfectly with the text to offer a succinct but beautiful lesson in tolerance and understanding. Mr. Carey's Garden makes a good read-aloud choice for small groups, but its full impact needs to be absorbed one-on-one so that the snails and the details can be seen up close and savored.?Judith Constantinides, East Baton Rouge Parish Main Library, LA
Copyright 1996 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 5^-8. Ms. Elwood, Mr. Munsing, and Mr. Febold have impressive gardens, but Mr. Carey's is full of snails that eat holes in his plants. "Stick them in the freezer. Frozen snails," advises Ms. Elwood; "Salt," suggests Mr. Munsing; "Poison pellets," declares Mr. Febold. But Mr. Carey takes a different attitude toward his little visitors, an attitude that makes no sense to his neighbors until they catch a glimpse of Mr. Carey's nighttime garden, turned magical by glittering moonlit snail trails. A delicate palette of greens, earthy browns, and purples befit the subject, and there's a delightfully simple quirkiness to Karas' cast of elderly characters that makes them anything but stodgy. A quiet book, with a meaning that carries on beyond the confines of the story.
Stephanie Zvirin