Amazon.com Review
Marty Fish is 17 years old when she meets her future mother-in-law, the awe-inspiring Mrs. Hornstien. Mrs. Hornstien lives in an enormous apartment in Ritterhouse Square, Philadelphia, complete with marble stairs and mahogany walls and a zodiac painted on the library ceiling. Heady stuff indeed for a young girl of Marty's humble background. In
Mrs. Hornstien, Fredrica Wagman chronicles the relationships between Marty and her mother-in-law and Marty and her husband, Albert, from that first meeting in the Ritterhouse Square apartment to the engagement of Marty's own son 35 years later. It sounds like a pretty massive undertaking, but Wagman accomplishes it in under 120 pages.
The book might be slim, but it's certainly vocal. Everyone in Mrs. Hornstien seems to be shouting; scarcely a page passes without someone speaking in capital letters. This is especially true of Mrs. Hornstien, who seems to value DRIVE and AMBITION above all. One wishes she'd switch to emphatic italics from time to time. This is not a subtle book, but it is a heartfelt one. The message contained within it is obvious: trust love; let troubles strengthen, not break you. Mrs. Hornstien will fit nicely on the shelf next to anything by Robert Fulghum.
From Library Journal
Marty Fish is just 17 and deeply in love with the much older Albert when they appear before his mother, the imperious Ms. Hornstien, ruler of her family and of upper-crust Philadelphia society. Marty, whose own mother tears at her daughter with a harsh love that is shrouded in greed and self-absorption, is loudly reviled by Mrs. H. as soon as the couple announce their engagement. Speaking from a distance of 35 years, Marty looks back on the decades of balance and truce that bring her beyond the deathbed of Albert's mother and to her own front door as she becomes the next Mrs. Hornstien to her son's fiancee. Wagman's delicately etched scenes of emotional combat and redemption draw a picture of love and forgiveness and tragedy that bind, bless, and transform the narrator into a woman of great strength and depth.
-?Beth E. Andersen, Ann Arbor Dist. Lib. Mich.Copyright 1997 Reed Business Information, Inc.