1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best $22 I ever spent, February 14, 2008
This review is from: Musical Brotherhoods from the Trans-Saharan Highway (DVD)
Amazing music all the way through. Amplified Ouds, lutes, and banjoes abound. I know that banjoes are originally African, but the ones used look like 5 and 6 string American Standards. I read somewhere that the Jajouka Brotherhood, (not featured in this movie), are still using the same gear left by Brian Jones when he visited Morroco in the 60's.
Anyway, I'm sure this doc will inspire many crusty anarcho-punks to drop the Balkan-Gypsy music bag and to pick up Ouds and Rabbabs instead, for better or worse.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
DVD Review for the following, February 12, 2008
This review is from: Musical Brotherhoods from the Trans-Saharan Highway (DVD)
Musical Brotherhoods from the Trans-Saharan Highway
(Sublime Frequencies)
A film by Hisham Mayet
Musical Brotherhoods from the Trans-Saharan Highway (Sublime Frequencies-DVD) Filmed in Marrakesh, Morocco at a bazaar known as Jemaa Al Fna, Musical Brotherhoods from the Trans-Saharan Highway captures the rich musical life of this public meeting place, which every night transforms into a sprawling patchwork quilt of simultaneous musical performances. The "Brotherhoods" that take over the square at night each purvey their own brand of ecstatic trance music -- intricately ornamented (and often incredibly fast), electrified ouds, mandolins and banjos blare through improvised amplifiers cobbled together from car stereo parts and megaphones, backed by a battery of Moroccan frame drums, handclaps and group chants. Audience/performer boundaries seem to vanish in these nightly rituals, with members of the crowd taking turns drumming, clapping, singing and jumping into the circle to take a turn dancing solo. As I watched this DVD, I couldn't help feeling a little impoverished -- this is surely some of the most incredible communal music you will ever have the good-fortune of seeing, and it all happens in the street. Elsewhere in the square, boxing matches take place, a falcon trainer shows off his bird and a man spins selections from a dusty stack of Arabic 45s. As is the case with the vast majority of the Sublime Frequencies catalogue, Musical Brotherhoods does not provide answers or interpretation as much as it does a much needed sense of longing and humility in the face of the culture it documents; there is no narrator other than the camera's intimate hand-held movements, and filmmaker Hisham Mayet's (Jemaa Al Fna,Folk Music of the Sahara: Among the Tuareg of Libya, ISAN: Folk and Pop Music of Northeast Thailand, NIGER: Magic and Ecstasy in the Sahel) lingering gaze is easy to imagine as your own. Propelled by incredible music, Musical Brotherhoods is an entrancing, hour-long trip through what is undoubtedly an endangered musical form. If you liked the Group Doueh or Group Inerane records recently issued by Sublime Frequencies or have been bit by the Saharan guitar bug, this is essential viewing." Che Chen/othermusic.com
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
an hour in the jemaa el fna, April 7, 2008
This review is from: Musical Brotherhoods from the Trans-Saharan Highway (DVD)
almost all of this film was shot in the jemaa el fna in marrakesh....the only other footage comes from essaouira.....the documentary has no irritating voice-over and concentrates (as did the earlier dvd by sublime frequencies) on a few of the groups playing in this world-famous large public square.....whereas the earlier production had the camera wandering and taking in the crowds of spectators this present dvd focuses on the musicians to a greater extent.....i missed watching the faces in the crowd because the light of the gas lamps gives them a special presence and so was glad to see one section of a couple of minutes of nothing but close-ups of spectators.......the only "musical brotherhood" in the traditional academic sense of the term is the hamadsha and they are shown chanting accompaning themselves with their drums (gwal) -no ghaita or flutes (lira). there is only a two-second glimpse of the gnaoua fom a distance. so if you like raw footage of rough live music direct from the street with none of the formality of a concert and no "artistic" cutting and manipulation, you will like this dvd.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No